全髋关节置换假体头颈结合部不同装配载荷下头部位移与拆卸力的评估
本研究评估三种装配载荷(A组2 kN、B组4 kN、C组6 kN,每组4个假体)对全髋关节置换假体头颈结合部强度的影响,测量头部在锥部上的初始位移及拆卸力。结果显示2 kN组最大头部位移与4 kN、6 kN组有显著差异(P=.029),4 kN与6 kN组间无显著差异(P=.89);三组拆卸力有显著差异(P=.007),随装配载荷增加拆卸力增大。作者结论认为2 kN装配力可能过低,推荐装配载荷大于2.5 kN。
要点
- 2 kN组最大头部位移与4 kN、6 kN组有显著差异(P=.029),4 kN与6 kN组间无显著差异(P=.89)。
- 三组拆卸力有显著差异(P=.007),随装配载荷增加拆卸力增大。
- 作者推荐装配载荷大于2.5 kN。
核心结论
- 2 kN的装配力可能过低,不足以克服头部接合所需的摩擦力并在锥部上实现最大位移,因此作者推荐装配载荷大于2.5 kN。
研究设计与样本
- 体外实验研究,评估三种装配载荷水平(A组2 kN、B组4 kN、C组6 kN),每组4个假体,以0.05 kN/s恒定速率施加装配载荷(ISO7260-10:2003),用激光传感器测量头部位移,以标准拉脱试验测定拆卸力。
主要发现
- 2 kN组最大头部位移与4 kN、6 kN组有显著差异(P=.029),4 kN组与6 kN组间无显著差异(P=.89)。
- 拆卸力三组间有显著差异(均值±标准差,A组1316±223 kN、B组2224±151 kN、C组3965±344 kN,P=.007),随装配载荷增加拉脱力增大。
- 4 kN和6 kN组在装配载荷记录中观察到约2.5 kN的第一个峰值,之后达到所需装配载荷,对应头部位移突然增加至约150 μm。
临床怎么用
- 作者推荐装配载荷大于2.5 kN。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Most femoral components used now for total hip arthroplasty are modular, requiring a strong connection at assembly. The aim of this study was to assess the effect of assembly force on the strength of head-trunnion interface and to measure the initial displacement of the head on the trunnion with different assembly forces. METHODS: Three assembly load levels were assessed (A: 2 kN, B: 4 kN, C: 6 kN) with 4 implants in each group. The stems were mounted in a custom rig and the respective assembly loads were applied to the head at a constant rate of 0.05 kN/s (ISO7260-10:2003). Load levels were recorded during assembly. Head displacement was measured with a laser sensor. The disassembly force was determined by a standard pull-off test. RESULTS: The maximum head displacement on the trunnion was significantly different between the 2 kN group and the other 2 groups (4 kN, 6 kN, P = .029), but not between the 4 kN and 6 kN groups (P = .89). The disassembly forces between the 3 groups were significantly different (mean ± standard deviation, A: 1316 ± 223 kN; B: 2224 ± 151 kN; C: 3965 ± 344 kN; P = .007), with increasing assembly load leading to a higher pull-off force. For the 4 kN and 6 kN groups, a first peak of approximately 2.5 kN was observed on the load recordings during assembly before the required assembly load was eventually reached corresponding to sudden increase in head displacement to approximately 150 μm. CONCLUSION: An assembly force of 2 kN may be too low to overcome the frictional forces needed to engage the head and achieve maximum displacement on the trunnion and thus an assembly load of greater than 2.5 kN is recommended.
引用
- Ramoutar DN, Crosnier EA, Shivji F, et al. Assessment of Head Displacement and Disassembly Force With Increasing Assembly Load at the Head/Trunnion Junction of a Total Hip Arthroplasty Prosthesis. J Arthroplasty. 2016. PMID: 28063775. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2016.11.054
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。