骨科手术室哪些表面存在生物负载污染?一项使用ATP生物发光测定的研究
该研究在6间骨科手术室(2间成人重建、2间创伤、2间脊柱)术前对13种表面采样,用ATP生物发光测定相对光单位(RLU)。所有表面均检出生物负载,RLU均值从铺巾后准备台的8.3到手术台头板右侧的2539不等。作者认为ATP生物发光可识别手术室环境污染热点,未来需与微生物培养及感染率关联研究。
要点
- 所有采样的13种骨科手术室表面均检出生物负载。
- 铺巾后准备台RLU最低(8.3±3.4),手术台头板右侧最高(2539±5635.8)。
- 作者建议将手术台头板下表面、Bair Hugger™按钮和止血带机按钮纳入常规清洁方案。
核心结论
- ATP生物发光是测量骨科手术室清洁度的新方法,可帮助识别可能导致感染率增加的环境污染热点。
- 未来将ATP生物发光结果与微生物培养相关联的研究可增加该技术的临床实用性。
- 本研究未评估ATP生物发光与临床感染的相关性,这是未来研究的主题。
研究设计与样本
- 在某一天对6间骨科手术室(2间成人重建、2间创伤、2间脊柱)在术前进行ATP生物发光测定。
- 所有病例均为无感染的清洁手术,包括各采样手术室此前已实施的手术。
- 手术室已清洁并准备就绪,但患者尚未被带入房间。
- 每间手术室对13种不同表面各采样一次。
- 所测RLU与既往发表的医院和餐饮行业清洁度基准值250至500 RLU进行比较。
主要发现
- 所有表面均有生物负载;各表面ATP RLU(均值±标准差)按升序为:手术室准备台(铺巾后;8.3±3.4)、灭菌盘内部(9.2±5.5)、Bair Hugger™软管内部(212.5±155.7)、储物柜台面(281.7±236.7)、手术室灯柄(647.8±903.7)、手术室准备台(铺巾前;1054±387.5)、Clark-socket附件(1135.7±705.3)、全髋和脊柱体位用患者体位垫(1201.7±1144.9)、Bovie机按钮(1264.5±638.8)、Bair Hugger™按钮(1340.8±1064.1)、止血带机按钮(1666.5±2144.9)、电脑键盘(1810.8±929.6)、手术台头板右侧(2539±5635.8)。
关键数值与推荐
- 既往发表的ATP基准值250至500 RLU用于定义医院和餐饮行业的清洁度。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,手术台头板下表面、Bair Hugger™按钮和止血带机按钮应作为机构方案的一部分进行常规清洁。
- 作者建议,未来可评估从这些环境表面采集的微生物样本,并将其与ATP生物发光技术发现的生物负载增加相关联,以促进手术清洁实践的改进。
局限性
- 本研究未评估ATP生物发光与临床感染之间的相关性,这是未来研究的主题。
- 未来将ATP生物发光结果与微生物培养相关联的研究可增加该技术的临床实用性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Contaminated operating room surfaces can increase the risk of orthopaedic infections, particularly after procedures in which hardware implantation and instrumentation are used. The question arises as to how surgeons can measure surface cleanliness to detect increased levels of bioburden. This study aims to highlight the utility of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) bioluminescence technology as a novel technique in detecting the degree of contamination within the sterile operating room environment. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: What orthopaedic operating room surfaces are contaminated with bioburden? METHODS: When energy is required for cellular work, ATP breaks down into adenosine biphosphate (ADP) and phosphate (P) and in that process releases energy. This process is inherent to all living things and can be detected as light emission with the use of bioluminescence assays. On a given day, six different orthopaedic surgery operating rooms (two adult reconstruction, two trauma, two spine) were tested before surgery with an ATP bioluminescence assay kit. All of the cases were considered clean surgery without infection, and this included the previously performed cases in each sampled room. These rooms had been cleaned and prepped for surgery but the patients had not been physically brought into the room. A total of 13 different surfaces were sampled once in each room: the operating room (OR) preparation table (both pre- and postdraping), OR light handles, Bovie machine buttons, supply closet countertops, the inside of the Bair Hugger™ hose, Bair Hugger™ buttons, right side of the OR table headboard, tourniquet machine buttons, the Clark-socket attachment, and patient positioners used for total hip and spine positioning. The relative light units (RLUs) obtained from each sample were recorded and data were compiled and averaged for analysis. These values were compared with previously published ATP benchmark values of 250 to 500 RLUs to define cleanliness in both the hospital and restaurant industries. RESULTS: All surfaces had bioburden. The ATP RLUs (mean ± SD) are reported for each surface in ascending order: the OR preparation table (postdraping; 8.3 ± 3.4), inside the sterilized pan (9.2 ± 5.5), the inside of the Bair Hugger™ hose (212.5 ± 155.7), supply closet countertops (281.7 ± 236.7), OR light handles (647.8 ± 903.7), the OR preparation table (predraping; 1054 ± 387.5), the Clark-socket attachment (1135.7 ± 705.3), patient positioners used for total hip and spine positioning (1201.7 ± 1144.9), Bovie machine buttons (1264.5 ± 638.8), Bair Hugger™ buttons (1340.8 ± 1064.1), tourniquet machine buttons (1666.5 ± 2144.9), computer keyboard (1810.8 ± 929.6), and the right side of the OR table headboard (2539 ± 5635.8). CONCLUSIONS: ATP bioluminescence is a novel method to measure cleanliness within the orthopaedic OR and can help identify environmental trouble spots that can potentially lead to increased infection rates. Future studies correlating ATP bioluminescence findings with microbiology cultures could add to the clinical utility of this technology. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Surfaces such as the undersurface of the OR table headboard, Bair Hugger™ buttons, and tourniquet machine buttons should be routinely cleansed as part of an institutional protocol. Although correlation between ATP bioluminescence and clinical infection was not evaluated in this study, it is the subject of future research. Specifically, evaluating microbiology samples taken from these environmental surfaces and correlating them with increased bioburden found with ATP bioluminescence technology can help promote improved surgical cleaning practices.
引用
- Richard RD, Bowen TR. What Orthopaedic Operating Room Surfaces Are Contaminated With Bioburden? A Study Using the ATP Bioluminescence Assay. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28050814. doi:10.1007/s11999-016-5221-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。