髌骨截骨与复合厚度对全膝关节置换术后活动度及并发症的影响
该研究基于28年间3位术者完成的3655例全膝关节置换术,分析髌骨厚度变化与术后活动度及并发症的关系。结果显示髌骨厚度变化与活动度仅呈显著但微弱相关(P<.01,ρ=-0.046),复合髌骨厚度每增加10mm可致膝关节活动度丢失3°;厚度变化与手法松解(P<.05)、伸膝装置断裂(P=.01)及髌骨撞击/摩擦音(P<.01)存在显著差异。作者建议避免破坏髌骨骨床与肌腱止点,当原生髌骨较薄(<18mm)时维持12mm髌骨骨床并接受复合厚度增加。
要点
- 复合髌骨厚度每增加10mm,膝关节活动度可丢失3°(P<.01,ρ=-0.046)。
- 髌骨厚度变化与手法松解、伸膝装置断裂及髌骨撞击/摩擦音显著相关。
- 原生髌骨<18mm时,作者建议维持12mm髌骨骨床并接受复合厚度增加。
核心结论
- 数据未显示髌骨厚度增加时活动度丢失的强烈趋势,作者建议避免破坏髌骨骨床与肌腱止点。
- 当原生髌骨较薄(<18mm)时,作者建议维持12mm髌骨骨床并接受复合厚度增加。
研究设计与样本
- 28年间由3位术者完成的3655例全膝关节置换术,所有膝关节均在髌骨截骨前、假体植入后以卡尺测量髌骨厚度,并于术后1或2年将活动度记录于数据库。
主要发现
- 复合髌骨厚度分为相同(1034膝)、增厚(1617膝)和变薄(1004膝)三组。
- 髌骨厚度变化与活动度呈显著但微弱相关(P<.01,ρ=-0.046),复合髌骨厚度增加10mm可致膝关节活动度丢失3°。
- 髌骨厚度变化与手法松解(P<.05)、伸膝装置断裂(P=.01)及髌骨撞击/摩擦音(P<.01)存在显著差异。
- 髌骨骨床厚度<12mm与≥12mm相比,骨折无差异(P=.26),且骨床厚度<12mm的膝关节未发生伸膝装置断裂。
- 原生髌骨厚度≤18mm与>18mm相比,骨折(P<.01)和髌骨透亮线(P=.01)存在显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议避免破坏髌骨骨床与肌腱止点。
- 当原生髌骨较薄(<18mm)时,作者建议维持12mm髌骨骨床并接受复合厚度增加。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Little data exist on the influence of patellar thickness on postoperative motion or complications after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). This study addresses the following questions: Is postoperative motion influenced by change in composite patellar thickness? Is change in patellar thickness associated with more complications? And do more complications occur in the knees with a patellar bone remnant (<12 mm) and a native patellar thickness <18 mm? METHODS: In total, 3655 TKAs were performed by 3 surgeons over a 28-year interval. All knees had caliper measurement of patellar thickness before the patellar cut, after implantation of the component and postoperative motion recorded in the database 1 or 2 years after TKA. RESULTS: Patellar composite thickness was the same (1034 knees), thicker (1617 knees), and thinner (1004 knees). A significant but weak relationship was identified between the change in patellar thickness and motion (P < .01, ρ = -0.046); an increase in "composite patellar thickness" of 10 mm would result in a 3° loss of knee motion. Significant differences were identified between change in thickness and manipulations (P < .05), ruptures (P = .01), and patellar clunk/crepitus (P < .01). Examining knees with bone remnant thicknesses (<12 mm/≥12 mm), there was no difference in fractures (P = .26). No extensor ruptures occurred in knees with remnant thickness <12 mm. Comparing knees with native bone thickness (≤18 mm/>18 mm), significant differences were found in fractures (P < .01) and patellar radiolucencies (P = .01). CONCLUSION: As this data does not demonstrate a strong tendency toward losing motion when the patellar thickness is increased, the authors recommend avoiding compromise of the patellar bone stock and tendon insertion. When native patellar bone is thin (<18 mm), we recommend maintaining 12 mm of patellar bone stock and accept the increase in composite thickness.
引用
- Hamilton WG, Ammeen DJ, Parks NL, et al. Patellar Cut and Composite Thickness: The Influence on Postoperative Motion and Complications in Total Knee Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2016. PMID: 28108171. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2016.12.033
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。