多韧带膝关节手术后全膝关节置换术的翻修、再手术和假体限制性风险增加
本研究比较了有既往多韧带膝关节手术史的患者与匹配的原发性骨关节炎患者接受全膝关节置换术(TKA)后的结果。多韧带组的15年无翻修生存率低于对照组(42% vs 94%),更常使用限制性假体,再手术和感染风险更高。作者认为需要进一步研究确定特定的多韧带手术技术能否预防创伤后关节炎和TKA并发症。
要点
- 多韧带膝关节手术史患者TKA后15年无翻修生存率低于匹配的骨关节炎对照组(42% vs 94%;p < 0.001)。
- 多韧带组使用限制性假体的比例高于对照组(9/59 [15%] vs 0/110 [0%];OR,45;95% CI,3-781;p = 0.009)。
- 多韧带组再手术风险高于对照组(14/59 [24%] vs 7/118 [6%];OR,5;95% CI,2-14;p = 0.001)。
核心结论
- 有既往多韧带手术史与较低的长期假体生存率、较高的限制性TKA假体使用率以及较高的重大并发症(包括再手术和感染)风险相关。
- 需要进一步研究以确定特定的多韧带手术技术能否预防创伤后关节炎和TKA并发症。
- 证据等级为III级,治疗性研究。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为回顾性匹配对照研究,纳入1985年至2014年间在本机构接受TKA的59例有既往多韧带膝关节手术史(≥两个韧带)的患者(36男,23女;平均年龄53岁),共59个TKA。
- 随访5年、10年和15年的患者分别为39例(66%)、18例(31%)和6例(10%);平均随访5.4年(范围1-25年)。
- 按性别、初次TKA时年龄(相差5岁以内)和TKA日期(相差5年以内)以2:1比例匹配接受原发性骨关节炎TKA的对照组。
主要发现
- 多韧带组15年总体无翻修生存率低于匹配对照组(42% [95% CI,16%-73%] vs 94% [95% CI,81%-99%];p < 0.001)。
- 多韧带组初次TKA时使用内翻-外翻限制性假体的患者多于对照组(9/59 [15%] vs 0/110 [0%];OR,45;95% CI,3-781;p = 0.009)。
- 多韧带组因任何原因再手术的风险高于对照组(14/59 [24%] vs 7/118 [6%];OR,5;95% CI,2-14;p = 0.001)。
- 多韧带组感染发生率高于对照组(4/59 [7%] vs 1/118 [<1%];p = 0.04)。
- 在现有样本量下,TKA后麻醉下手法松解的发生率两组无差异(10% [6/59] vs 3% [4/118];p = 0.08)。
关键数值与推荐
- 多韧带组15年无翻修生存率42%(95% CI,16%-73%)vs 对照组94%(95% CI,81%-99%)(p < 0.001)。
- 使用限制性假体:多韧带组9/59(15%)vs 对照组0/110(0%);OR,45(95% CI,3-781;p = 0.009)。
- 再手术:多韧带组14/59(24%)vs 对照组7/118(6%);OR,5(95% CI,2-14;p = 0.001)。
- 感染:多韧带组4/59(7%)vs 对照组1/118(<1%)(p = 0.04)。
- 麻醉下手法松解:多韧带组10%(6/59)vs 对照组3%(4/118)(p = 0.08)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 随访5年、10年和15年的患者分别仅有39例(66%)、18例(31%)和6例(10%)。
- 需要进一步研究以确定特定的多韧带手术技术能否预防创伤后关节炎和TKA并发症。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The risk of major complications and revision arthroplasty after TKA in patients who previously underwent multiligament knee surgery have been poorly characterized. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Is multiligament knee surgery before TKA associated with (1) worse implant survival, (2) increased use of TKA design constraint, (3) a greater risk for major complications, and (4) poorer scores for pain and function compared with similar patients receiving TKA for primary osteoarthritis? METHODS: Fifty-nine TKAs were performed at our institution between 1985 and 2014 in 59 patients (36 men, 23 women; mean age, 53 years) with a history of previous multiligament knee surgery (≥ two ligaments). Of those, we had followup for 39 (66%), 18 (31%), and six (10%) patients at 5, 10, and 15 years, respectively; mean followup was 5.4 years (range, 1-25 years). A two-to-one matched control group consisting of patients undergoing primary TKA for the diagnosis of osteoarthritis was selected for comparison. Patients were matched based on gender, age at primary TKA (within 5 years), and date of the TKA (within 5 years). Medical records were reviewed for survivorship, TKA design, complications (reoperation, revision, infection, manipulation under anesthesia, and periprosthetic joint infection), TKA design, and clinical outcomes (Knee Society Scores [KSS], Knee Society Function Score [KSS-F]). RESULTS: The overall 15-year revision-free survival in patients with prior multiligament knee surgery was decreased in comparison to the matched controls (42% [95% CI, 16%-73%] vs 94% [95% CI, 81%-99%]; p < 0.001). Varus-valgus constraint implant design was used for more patients in the multiligament cohort at index TKA than in the matched control group (9/59 [15%] vs 0/110 [0%], respectively; odds ratio [OR], 45; 95% CI, 3-781; p = 0.009). Patients with a history of multiligament knee surgery also were at increased risk of reoperation for any cause (14/59 [24%] vs 7/118 [6%]; OR, 5; 95% CI, 2-14; p = 0.001). With the numbers available, there was no difference in the frequency of manipulation under anesthesia after TKA (10% [6/59] versus 3% [4/118]; p = 0.08) A higher proportion of patients in the multiligament cohort had infections develop compared with the matched controls (4/59 [7%] vs 1/118 [< 1%)], respectively; p = 0.04). There was no difference in the KSS improvement after TKA between the multiligament group and the control group (34 ± 18 vs 28 ± 15; p = 0.088). The final KSS and KSS-F scores likewise showed no difference between those groups (88 ± 13 vs 85 ± 10; p = 0.232) (85 ± 17 vs 84 ± 14; p = 0.75). CONCLUSIONS: A history of multiligament surgery is associated with lower long-term survivorship, higher use of constrained TKA designs, and higher risk of major complications, including reoperation and infection. Further research is necessary to determine if a particular multiligamentous surgical technique can prevent posttraumatic arthritis and TKA complications. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Pancio SI, Sousa PL, Krych AJ, et al. Increased Risk of Revision, Reoperation, and Implant Constraint in TKA After Multiligament Knee Surgery. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28091802. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5230-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。