单中心参与医疗改善捆绑支付计划的早期经验
本文介绍美国医疗保险和医疗补助服务中心(CMS)于2011年实施的医疗改善捆绑支付(BPCI)计划,阐述其对骨科医生在成本控制、手术安全与质量保障方面的领导作用要求,讨论医生与医院对齐模式、收益共享安排及风险分层,并分享作者所在三级学术医疗中心的早期全关节置换BPCI经验。
要点
- BPCI要求组织在承担绩效与财务责任的同时维持质量并以更低成本提供照护。
- 骨科医生须在成本控制、手术安全和质量保障中承担领导角色以提供高性价比照护。
- CMS推荐每年至少100至200例;小型机构须谨慎,因为一例高成本患者可能显著影响整个项目财务。
核心结论
- BPCI要求维持质量并以更低成本提供照护,这需要医生与医院利益整合。
- 骨科医生必须在成本控制、手术安全和质量保障中承担领导角色以提供高性价比照护。
- 由于多数骨科医生独立执业且不受雇于医院,医生-医院对齐模式或执业机构与医院之间的 contracted gainsharing 安排可能为成功捆绑定价所必需。
- 捆绑定价依赖规模经济;小型机构必须谨慎,因为一例高成本患者可能显著影响整个项目的财务。
- CMS推荐每年至少100至200例;作者还建议参与者利用技术最大化效率并为实施捆绑支付提供最佳环境。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为单中心早期经验讨论,介绍作者所在三级学术医疗中心的全关节置换BPCI早期经验。
- CMS于2011年实施BPCI计划,通过该计划组织签订包含绩效与财务责任的支付协议。
主要发现
- BPCI下医院、外科医生或第三方共享奖励但承担捆绑的风险。
- 对患者而言,成本节约必须与质量指标的维持或改善相关联。
- 质量的定义可能不同,流程和结果的奖励也可能不同。
- 捆绑定价协议中应考虑对潜在并发症进行风险分层,以防止排除合并症多且照护成本较高的患者(例如使用假体治疗的髋部骨折)。
- 发展改善照护协调、管理质量数据和分配支付的项目需要大量基础设施投资;小型机构可能难以投入资源进行这些基础设施变革,尽管一旦启动变革可能实施得更彻底。
关键数值与推荐
- CMS推荐每年至少100至200例。
- 作者建议参与者利用技术最大化效率并为实施捆绑支付提供最佳环境。
临床怎么用
- BPCI要求医生与医院合并利益,骨科医生须在成本控制、手术安全和质量保障中承担领导角色。
- 由于多数骨科医生独立执业且不受雇于医院,可能需要医生-医院对齐模式(如医生-医院组织)或执业机构与医院之间的 contracted gainsharing 安排。
- 捆绑定价协议中应考虑对潜在并发症进行风险分层,以防止排除合并症多且照护成本较高的患者(例如使用假体治疗的髋部骨折)。
- 小型机构必须谨慎,因为一例高成本患者可能显著影响整个项目的财务。
- 作者建议参与者利用技术最大化效率并为实施捆绑支付提供最佳环境。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) implemented the Bundled Payments for Care Improvement (BPCI) initiative in 2011. Through BPCI, organizations enlisted into payment agreements that include both performance and financial accountability for episodes of care. To succeed, BPCI requires quality maintenance and care delivery at lower costs. This necessitates physicians and hospitals to merge interests. Orthopaedic surgeons must assume leadership roles in cost containment, surgical safety, and quality assurance to deliver cost-effective care. Because most orthopaedic surgeons practice independently and are not employed by hospitals, models of physician-hospital alignment (e.g., physician-hospital organizations) or contracted gainsharing arrangements between practices and hospitals may be necessary for successful bundled pricing. Under BPCI, hospitals, surgeons, or third parties share rewards but assume risks for the bundle.For patients, cost savings must be associated with maintenance or improvement in quality metrics. However, the definition of quality can vary, as can the rewards for processes and outcomes. Risk stratification for potential complications should be considered in bundled pricing agreements to prevent the exclusion of patients with substantial comorbidities and higher care costs (e.g., hip fractures treated with prostheses). Bundled pricing depends on economies of scale for success; smaller institutions must be cautious, as 1 costly patient could substantially impact the finances of its entire program. CMS recommends a minimum of 100 to 200 cases yearly. We also suggest that participants utilize technologies to maximize efficiency and provide the best possible environment for implementation of bundled payments. Substantial investment in infrastructure is required to develop programs to improve coordination of care, manage quality data, and distribute payments. Smaller institutions may have difficulty devoting resources to these infrastructural changes, although changes may be implemented more thoroughly once initiated. Herein, we discuss our early total joint arthroplasty BPCI experience at our tertiary-care academic medical center.
引用
- Iorio R, Bosco J, Slover J, et al. Single Institution Early Experience with the Bundled Payments for Care Improvement Initiative. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2017. PMID: 28060238. doi:10.2106/JBJS.16.00066
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。