医疗保险全关节置换手术中风险调整后的医院结局
本研究基于2010至2012年医疗保险有限数据集,对行择期全髋或全膝关节置换术的医院建立风险调整模型,评估住院死亡、住院时间异常延长、出院后90天死亡及再入院等不良结局。共纳入253978例全髋置换和672515例全膝置换患者,观察到的总体不良结局率分别为12.0%和11.6%。风险调整后不良结局率在表现最好与最差的十分位医院间差异明显,全髋为6.6%对19.8%,全膝为6.4%对19.3%,提示医院间存在较大变异。
要点
- 全髋置换观察到的总体不良结局率为12.0%,全膝置换为11.6%。
- 全髋置换医院z评分范围为-5.09至+5.62,98家优于预测≥2个标准差,142家差于预测≥2个标准差。
- 全膝置换医院z评分范围为-5.85至+11.75,223家优于预测≥2个标准差,319家差于预测≥2个标准差。
核心结论
- 风险调整后的结局显示医院间存在广泛变异,表明表现较差的医院在关节置换手术捆绑支付中有改进需求。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入医疗保险有限数据集2010至2012年中行择期全髋或全膝关节置换术且合格病例≥50例的医院。
- 针对住院死亡、住院时间异常延长、出院后90天未再入院死亡及排除无关再入院后的90天再入院等不良结局建立逻辑回归风险模型。
主要发现
- 共纳入253978例行全髋置换和672515例行全膝置换的患者。
- 全髋置换观察到的总体不良结局率为12.0%,全膝置换为11.6%。
- 行全髋置换的1483家医院z评分从-5.09(优于预测)至+5.62(差于预测),其中98家优于预测≥2个标准差,142家差于预测≥2个标准差。
- 行全膝置换的2349家医院z评分从-5.85(优于预测)至+11.75(差于预测),其中223家优于预测≥2个标准差,319家差于预测≥2个标准差。
- 风险调整后不良结局率在全髋置换中表现最好十分位医院为6.6%,最差十分位医院为19.8%;全膝置换中分别为6.4%和19.3%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Comparative measurement of hospital outcomes can define opportunities for care improvement and will assume great importance as alternative payment models for inpatient total joint replacement surgical procedures are introduced. The purpose of this study was to develop risk-adjusted models for Medicare inpatient and post-discharge adverse outcomes in elective lower-extremity total joint replacement and to apply these models for hospital comparison. METHODS: Hospitals with ≥50 qualifying cases of elective total hip replacement and total knee replacement from the Medicare Limited Data Set database of 2010 to 2012 were studied. Logistic risk models were designed for adverse outcomes of inpatient mortality, prolonged length-of-stay outliers in the index hospitalization, 90-day post-discharge deaths without readmission, and 90-day readmissions after excluding non-related readmissions. For each hospital, models were used to predict total adverse outcomes, the number of standard deviations from the mean (z-scores) for hospital performance, and risk-adjusted adverse outcomes for each hospital. RESULTS: A total of 253,978 patients who underwent total hip replacement and 672,515 patients who underwent total knee replacement were studied. The observed overall adverse outcome rates were 12.0% for total hip replacement and 11.6% for total knee replacement. The z-scores for 1,483 hospitals performing total hip replacements varied from -5.09 better than predicted to +5.62 poorer than predicted; 98 hospitals were ≥2 standard deviations better than predicted and 142 hospitals were ≥2 standard deviations poorer than predicted. The risk-adjusted adverse outcome rate for these hospitals was 6.6% for the best-decile hospitals and 19.8% for the poorest-decile hospitals. The z-scores for the 2,349 hospitals performing total knee replacements varied from -5.85 better than predicted to +11.75 poorer than predicted; 223 hospitals were ≥2 standard deviations better than predicted and 319 hospitals were ≥2 standard deviations poorer than predicted. The risk-adjusted adverse outcome rate for these hospitals was 6.4% for the best-decile hospitals and 19.3% for the poorest-decile hospitals. CONCLUSIONS: Risk-adjusted outcomes demonstrate wide variability and illustrate the need for improvement among poorer-performing hospitals for bundled payments of joint replacement surgical procedures. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Adverse outcomes are known to occur in the experience of all clinicians and hospitals. The risk-adjusted benchmarking of hospital performance permits the identification of adverse events that are potentially preventable.
引用
- Fry DE, Pine M, Nedza SM, et al. Risk-Adjusted Hospital Outcomes in Medicare Total Joint Replacement Surgical Procedures. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2017. PMID: 28060228. doi:10.2106/JBJS.15.01455
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。