选择股骨头:学术型成人重建外科医生的调查研究
本研究调查学术型成人重建外科医生对全髋关节置换术中股骨头材料的看法。向42个美国成人重建专科培训项目的274名教员发送16问调查,116人回复(回复率42.2%)。结果显示陶瓷头使用率72.9%,避免使用的最常见原因是费用(44.8%),94%曾观察钴铬头聚乙烯THA的头颈锥度腐蚀,仅6.0%见过Biolox Delta陶瓷碎裂。
要点
- 陶瓷头使用率72.9%,不使用的最常见原因是费用(44.8%)。
- 94%医生曾观察钴铬头对聚乙烯THA的头颈锥度腐蚀,陶瓷对聚乙烯为9.5%。
- 仅6.0%医生见过Biolox Delta陶瓷碎裂。
核心结论
- 学术型成人重建外科思想领袖受证据引导,认为陶瓷头的锥度腐蚀和碎裂罕见。
- 费用和个人经验也强烈影响他们的植入物选择。
- 使陶瓷头与钴铬头费用均等可能使外科医生能够纯粹基于证据行医。
研究设计与样本
- 通过电子邮件向42个美国成人重建专科培训项目的274名教员发送16问调查,评估对陶瓷头和钴铬头使用的态度。
主要发现
- 共116名回复,回复率42.2%。
- 教员使用陶瓷头的时间比例为72.9%。
- 不使用陶瓷头的最常见原因是费用(44.8%)。
- 94%的教员曾观察钴铬头对聚乙烯THA的头颈锥度腐蚀,9.5%的教员曾观察陶瓷对聚乙烯THA的头颈锥度腐蚀。
- 仅6.0%的外科医生见过Biolox Delta陶瓷碎裂。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,使陶瓷头和钴铬头的费用均等可能使外科医生能够纯粹基于证据行医。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Our aim was to examine how academic adult reconstructive surgeons have interpreted evidence on femoral head material in total hip arthroplasty (THA). METHODS: A 16-question survey to evaluate attitudes toward ceramic and cobalt-chrome head use was emailed to 274 faculty at 42 US adult reconstruction fellowship programs. RESULTS: With 116 respondents, the response rate was 42.2%. Faculty use ceramic heads 72.9% of the time. The most common reason why respondents do not use ceramic heads is cost (44.8%). Ninety-four percent of faculty have observed head-neck taper corrosion in cobalt-chrome on polyethylene THA, while 9.5% of faculty have observed head-neck taper corrosion in ceramic on polyethylene THA. Only 6.0% of surgeons have seen Biolox Delta ceramic fracture. CONCLUSION: Adult reconstruction thought leaders are guided by evidence suggesting that with ceramic heads, taper corrosion and fracture are rare. Cost and personal experience also strongly influence their implant selection. Efforts to equalize cost of ceramic and cobalt-chrome heads may free surgeons to practice in a purely evidence-based fashion.
引用
- Nandi S, Austin MS. Choosing a Femoral Head: A Survey Study of Academic Adult Reconstructive Surgeons. J Arthroplasty. 2016. PMID: 28065626. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2016.12.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。