大鼠暴露于二手烟损害骨折愈合
研究用41只雌性Wistar大鼠建立股骨中段骨折髓内钉固定模型,比较骨折前暴露、骨折前后均暴露烟草烟雾与假暴露对照组的骨痂质量。暴露组骨痂形成延迟,骨密度、骨矿物含量、骨痂体积、编织骨比例及力学性能均较差,骨折前后均暴露者改变更明显。作者认为需在人类被动吸烟者中进一步研究验证。
要点
- 大鼠二手烟暴露后骨痂BMD、BMC、编织骨比例及力学强度均低于对照。
- 骨折前后均暴露组骨痂BMD 0.146±0.009 g/cm2,低于仅骨折前暴露组的0.199±0.008 g/cm2。
- 作者认为需在人类被动吸烟者中进一步研究以确认或否定本发现。
核心结论
- 暴露于烟草烟雾的大鼠骨折愈合延迟,骨痂成熟度、密度和力学抗力降低,所有评估方法均证实此结果。
- 骨折前后均暴露烟草烟雾时上述效应更明显。
- 作者认为未来应在人类被动吸烟者中开展研究以确认或否定本骨折骨痂形成发现。
研究设计与样本
- 研究在41只雌性Wistar大鼠股骨制作中段骨折并以金属髓内针固定,排除14只(9只骨折不合格、5只K针退出)。
- 烟草暴露由吸烟机每日4支香烟提供,每支香烟产生10 mg焦油和0.8 mg尼古丁,以新鲜空气30秒与烟雾空气15秒交替抽吸。
- 烟雾暴露预先调整至血清可替宁水平与人类二手烟暴露相似。
- 分组:骨折前间断暴露组n=11,骨折前后均暴露组n=7,骨折前后均假暴露对照组n=9。
- 骨折后28天评估标本,指标包括双能X线吸收法(BMD、BMC、骨痂面积)、μCT(骨痂体积、编织骨比例)和机械弯曲(最大力、刚度)。
主要发现
- BMD:对照组0.302±0.008 g/cm2 vs 骨折前暴露组0.199±0.008 g/cm2(均数差=0.103 g/cm2,95%CI 0.094-0.112 g/cm2)vs 骨折前后均暴露组0.146±0.009 g/cm2(均数差=0.156 g/cm2,95%CI 0.147-0.167 g/cm2),p<0.01。
- BMC:对照组0.133±0.005 g vs 骨折前暴露组0.085±0.0034 g(均数差=0.048 g,95%CI 0.045-0.052 g)vs 骨折前后均暴露组0.048±0.003 g(均数差=0.085 g,95%CI 0.088-0.090 g),p<0.01。
- 骨痂体积:对照组7.656±1.963 mm3 vs 骨折前暴露组17.952±1.600 mm3(均数差=-10.30 mm3,95%CI -14.12至6.471 mm3)vs 骨折前后均暴露组40.410±3.340 mm3(均数差=-32.75 mm3,95%CI -36.58至28.93 mm3),p<0.01。
- 编织骨比例:对照组42.076±3.877% vs 骨折前暴露组16.655±3.021%(均数差=0.103%,95%CI 0.094-0.112%)vs 骨折前后均暴露组8.015±1.565%(均数差=0.156%,95%CI 0.147-0.166%),p<0.01。
- 最大力:对照组427.122±63.952 N.mm vs 骨折前暴露组149.230±67.189 N.mm(均数差=277.9 N.mm,95%CI 201.1-354.7 N.mm)vs 骨折前后均暴露组123.130±38.206 N.mm(均数差=304 N.mm,95%CI 213.2-394.8 N.mm),p<0.01;刚度:对照组491.397±96.444 N.mm/mm vs 骨折前暴露组73.157±36.511 N.mm/mm(均数差=418.2 N.mm/mm,95%CI 306.3-530.1 N.mm/mm)vs 骨折前后均暴露组154.049±134.939 N.mm/mm(均数差=337.3 N.mm/mm,95%CI 188.8-485.9 N.mm/mm),p<0.01。
临床怎么用
- 作者指出,二手烟对啮齿类动物骨折愈合的潜在危害应促使未来在人类被动吸烟者中开展临床研究。
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 作者认为未来应在人类被动吸烟者中开展研究以确认或否定本骨折骨痂形成发现。
- 原文在结论中提出未来需在人类被动吸烟者中进一步研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Nonsmokers may be affected by environmental tobacco smoke (secondhand smoke), but the effects of such exposure on fracture healing have not been well studied. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: To explore the possible effects of passive inhalation of tobacco smoke on the healing of a diaphyseal fracture in femurs of rats. We hypothesized that secondhand exposure to tobacco smoke adversely affects fracture healing. METHODS: A mid-diaphyseal fracture was created in the femur of 41 female Wistar rats and fixed with an intramedullary metallic pin; 14 rats were excluded (nine for inadequate fractures and five for K wire extrusion). Tobacco exposure was provided by a smoking machine on a daily basis of four cigarettes a day. Each cigarette yielded 10 mg tar and 0.8 mg nicotine, and was puffed by alternating injections of fresh air for 30 seconds and smoke air for 15 seconds. The smoke exposure was previously adjusted to provide serum levels of cotinine similar to human secondhand tobacco exposure. Cotinine is a predominant catabolite of nicotine that is used as a biological biomarker for exposure to tobacco smoke. In one group (n = 11), the animals were intermittently exposed to tobacco smoke before sustaining the fracture but not afterward. In another group (n = 7), the exposure occurred before and after the fracture. The control group (n = 9) was sham-exposed before and after the fracture. We evaluated the specimens 28 days after bone fracture. The callus quality was measured by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (bone mineral density [BMD], bone mineral content [BMC], and callus area), μCT (callus volume and woven bone fraction), and mechanical bending (maximum force and stiffness). RESULTS: Tobacco exposure resulted in delayed bone callus formation, which is represented by decreased BMD (Control: 0.302 ± 0.008 g/cm2 vs Preexposed: 0.199 ± 0.008 g/cm2 and Pre- and Postexposed: 0.146 ± 0.009 g/cm2; mean difference = 0.103 g/cm2, 95% CI, 0.094-0.112 g/cm2and mean difference = 0.156 g/cm2, 95% CI, 0.147-0.167 g/cm2; p < 0.01), BMC (Control: 0.133 ± 0.005 g vs Preexposed: 0.085 ± 0.0034 g and Pre- and Postexposed: 0.048 ± 0.003 g; mean difference = 0.048 g, 95% CI, 0.045-0.052 g and mean difference = 0.085 g, 95% CI, 0.088-0.090 g; p < 0.01), callus volume (Control: 7.656 ± 1.963 mm3 vs Preexposed: 17.952 ± 1.600 mm3 and Pre- and Postexposed: 40.410 ± 3.340 mm3; mean difference = -10.30 mm3, 95% CI, -14.12 to 6.471 mm3 and mean difference, -32.75 mm3, 95% CI, -36.58 to 28.93 mm3; p < 0.01), woven bone fraction (Control: 42.076 ± 3.877% vs Preexposed: 16.655 ± 3.021% and Pre- and Postexposed: 8.015 ± 1.565%, mean difference = 0.103%, 95% CI, 0.094-0.112% and mean difference = 0.156%, 95% CI, 0.147-0.166%; p < 0.01), maximum force (Control: 427.122 ± 63.952 N.mm vs Preexposed: 149.230 ± 67.189 N.mm and Pre- and Postexposed: 123.130 ± 38.206 N.mm, mean difference = 277.9 N.mm, 95% CI, 201.1-354.7 N.mm and mean difference = 304 N.mm, 95% CI, 213.2-394.8 N.mm; p < 0.01) and stiffness (Control: 491.397 ± 96.444 N.mm/mm vs Preexposed: 73.157 ± 36.511 N.mm/mm and Pre- and Postexposed: 154.049 ± 134.939 N.mm/mm, mean difference = 418.2 N.mm/mm, 95% CI, 306.3-530.1 N.mm/mm and mean difference = 337.3 N.mm/mm, 95% CI, 188.8-485.9 N.mm/mm; p < 0. 01). CONCLUSIONS: Rats exposed to tobacco smoke showed delayed fracture healing and callus that was characterized by decreased maturity, density, and mechanical resistance, which was confirmed by all assessment methods of this study. Such effects were more evident when animals were exposed to tobacco smoke before and after the fracture. Future studies should be done in human passive smokers to confirm or refute our findings on fracture callus formation. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The potential hazardous effects of secondhand smoke on fracture healing in rodents should stimulate future clinical studies in human passive smokers.
引用
- Santiago HA, Zamarioli A, Sousa Neto MD, et al. Exposure to Secondhand Smoke Impairs Fracture Healing in Rats. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2016. PMID: 27905059. doi:10.1007/s11999-016-5184-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。