儿童发育性髋关节发育不良闭合复位方案:联合开放腰大肌与内收肌松解及短腿石膏固定——113髋中期结果
研究评估标准化闭合复位方案治疗2岁以下发育性髋关节发育不良(DDH)儿童的维持复位效果及中期结果。共纳入120名儿童133髋,闭合复位后短腿石膏固定3个月,随访至少5年。结果显示该方案可获良好中期结果,但Tönnis 4级髋不适合此方案。
要点
- 133髋中67髋(51%)为Tönnis 3/4级;12个月内20髋(15%)复位失败需开放复位。
- 113例成功闭合复位中98髋(87%)为Severin 1级;32髋(29%)出现骨坏死,其中28髋为一过性,2名儿童(1.5%)为严重骨坏死。
- 双侧脱位失败率显著更高,多数Tönnis 4级髋复位失败;该方案不推荐用于Tönnis 4级髋。
核心结论
- 对于2岁以下DDH儿童,闭合复位联合必要时内收肌和腰大肌松解及短腿石膏固定3个月可获得良好中期结果。
- 该方案不推荐用于Tönnis 4级髋。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入120名2岁以下儿童共133髋,均接受闭合复位,随访至少5年或直至后续手术。
- 方案定义了可接受复位的标准及同期软组织松解的指征;所有儿童短腿石膏固定3个月。
- 闭合复位时及6周后行关节造影;6个月、1年、2年、5年及末次随访时摄X线片,记录Tönnis分级、髋臼指数、Severin分级及骨坏死征象。
主要发现
- 67髋(51%)为Tönnis 3/4级。
- 12个月内20髋(15%)复位未维持,需开放复位;其中55%为Severin 1级,其余为Severin 2级(因轻度髋臼发育不良)。
- 113例成功闭合复位中98髋(87%)为Severin 1级;10髋因残余DDH接受手术。
- 32髋(29%)出现骨坏死,其中28髋为一过性;2名儿童(1.5%)发生严重骨坏死。
- 双侧脱位失败率显著更高,多数Tönnis 4级髋复位失败。
关键数值与推荐
- 方案定义可接受复位标准及同期软组织松解指征(原文未列出具体数值)。
- Tönnis分级、髋臼指数、Severin分级及骨坏死征象为评估指标(原文未列出具体阈值)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,对2岁以下DDH儿童,闭合复位联合必要时内收肌和腰大肌松解及短腿石膏固定3个月可获得良好中期结果。
- 作者不推荐将该方案用于Tönnis 4级髋。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Our aim was to assess the effectiveness of a protocol involving a standardised closed reduction for the treatment of children with developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) in maintaining reduction and to report the mid-term results. METHODS: A total of 133 hips in 120 children aged less than two years who underwent closed reduction, with a minimum follow-up of five years or until subsequent surgery, were included in the study. The protocol defines the criteria for an acceptable reduction and the indications for a concomitant soft-tissue release. All children were immobilised in a short- leg cast for three months. Arthrograms were undertaken at the time of closed reduction and six weeks later. Follow-up radiographs were taken at six months and one, two and five years later and at the latest follow-up. The Tönnis grade, acetabular index, Severin grade and signs of osteonecrosis were recorded. RESULTS: A total of 67 hips (51%) were Tönnis grade 3/4 hips. By 12 months, 20 reductions (15%) had not been maintained, and these required open reduction. In all, 55% of these were Severin 1; the others were Severin 2, due to minor acetabular dysplasia. Of the 113 successful closed reductions, 98 hips (87%) were Severin 1. Surgery for residual DDH was offered for ten hips. Osteonecrosis was seen in 32 hips (29%) but was transient in 28. In total, two children (1.5%) had severe osteonecrosis. Bilateral dislocations were significantly more likely to fail and most Tönnis 4 hips failed. CONCLUSION: Closed reduction, with concomitant adductor and psoas release when required and the use of a short leg plaster of Paris cast for three months, can produce good mid-term results in children with DDH aged less than two years. This protocol is not recommended for Tönnis 4 hips. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2016;98-B:1548-53.
引用
- Tennant SJ, Eastwood DM, Calder P, et al. A protocol for the use of closed reduction in children with developmental dysplasia of the hip incorporating open psoas and adductor releases and a short-leg cast: Mid-term outcomes in 113 hips. Bone Joint J. 2016. PMID: 27803233
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。