内翻性关节炎膝关节的外侧间室骨赘与外侧间室软骨退变无关
该前瞻性研究纳入61例患者(71膝)内翻性骨关节炎行全膝关节置换术,术前评估外侧间室骨赘分级,术中取外侧胫骨平台和股骨远端骨软骨柱行生物力学与组织学评估。结果显示不同骨赘分级间Ha、DM及OARSI组织学分级无差异,但样本量小、检验效能不足。
要点
- 外侧间室骨赘存在与否不提示外侧软骨生物力学变弱或组织学退变更重。
- 评估内侧单髁置换时不应仅依据外侧骨赘有无判断外侧软骨状态。
- 样本量小(71膝),检验效能不足以检测小到中等程度的生物力学变化。
核心结论
- 在内翻性关节炎膝关节中,外侧间室骨赘与生物力学上更弱的软骨或更晚期的组织学退变征象无关。
- 鉴于样本量小(71膝),研究检验效能不足,无法检测生物力学性能的小到中等程度下降。
- 需要未来更大样本量的研究来证实当前发现。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,纳入2010年5月至2012年1月期间因内翻性骨关节炎行全膝关节置换术的患者,最终分析61例患者(71膝),男性29例(48%)、女性32例(52%),平均年龄65岁(范围49-89岁),平均BMI 26 kg/m2(范围17-47 kg/m2)。
- 术前站立位膝关节正位X线片由两名观察者根据OARSI放射学图谱模板对外侧间室骨赘进行分级。
- 术中从外侧胫骨平台和股骨远端外侧取骨软骨柱,行生物力学和组织学评估;生物力学测定内禀材料系数聚集模量(Ha)和动态模量(DM),施加20 g压缩载荷1小时;组织学分析采用定性骨关节炎软骨组织病理学评估系统。
- 采用Mann-Whitney U检验比较变量分布;以α=0.05、检验效能80%、样本量71进行效能分析,可检测效应量为0.6。
主要发现
- 在可获得的数值范围内,比较外侧胫骨骨赘Grade 0、1、2的膝关节,Ha和DM无差异。
- 对于胫骨骨赘Grade 3(n=3),外侧胫骨软骨显示低Ha(0.39 MPa;SD,0.17 MPa)和低DM(2.85 MPa;SD,2.12 MPa)。
- 在外侧股骨,可获得的数值范围内,Grade 0至3骨赘之间未观察到Ha和DM差异。
- 不同骨赘分级之间,外侧胫骨平台和股骨远端外侧的OARSI组织学分级在可获得的数值范围内无差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 骨赘分级采用OARSI放射学图谱模板,由两名观察者在站立位膝关节正位X线片上评估。
- 生物力学参数为聚集模量(Ha)和动态模量(DM),通过施加20 g压缩载荷1小时测定。
- 组织学评估采用定性骨关节炎软骨组织病理学评估系统。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,在为内侧间室关节炎患者评估内侧单髁置换时,应考虑外侧间室骨赘存在与否之外的其他因素。
- 作者指出,需要未来研究来明确平片在排除内翻膝外侧间室软骨退变方面的局限性。
局限性
- 样本量小(71膝),研究检验效能不足以检测生物力学性能的小到中等程度下降。
- 需要未来更大样本量的研究来证实当前发现。
- 需要未来研究来明确平片在排除内翻膝外侧间室软骨退变方面的局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Progression of arthritis in the lateral compartment is one of the main failure modes of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA). The decision regarding whether to perform a medial UKA sometimes is made based on whether lateral-compartment osteophytes are visible on plain radiographs obtained before surgery, but it is not clear whether the presence of lateral-compartment osteophytes signifies that the cartilage in the lateral compartment is arthritic. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Is the presence of lateral compartment osteophytes associated with biomechanical properties of lateral-compartment cartilage, and (2) are osteophytes in the lateral compartment associated with particular histologic features of cartilage in the lateral compartment? METHODS: Between May 2010 and January 2012, we performed 201 TKAs for varus osteoarthritis confirmed on standardized AP hip-to-ankle standing radiographs. All patients with a varus deformity were considered for this prospective study. During the enrollment period, 100 patients (101 knees) were not enrolled for this study because of declined consent or because they were unable to perform all required preoperative radiographic examinations. That left 84 patients (100 knees), of whom an additional 23 patients (27%) were excluded because either radiographic or biomechanical data were missing. For final analysis, 61 patients (71 knees) were available. There were 29 males (48%) and 32 females (52%) with a mean age of 65 years (range, 49-89 years). Their mean BMI was 26 kg/m2 (range, 17-47 kg/m2). Lateral-compartment osteophytes were graded by two observers on AP standing knee radiographs based on a template of the Osteoarthritis Research Society International (OARSI) radiographic atlas. During surgery, osteochondral plugs were harvested from the lateral tibial plateau and the distal lateral femur for biomechanical and histologic assessments. The intrinsic material coefficients aggregate modulus (Ha) and dynamic modulus (DM) were determined by applying a compressive load of 20 g for 1 hour. The histologic analysis was performed according to the qualitative osteoarthritis cartilage histopathology assessment system. The Mann-Whitney U test was performed to compare the distribution of variables. Power analysis was performed for the Mann-Whitney U test using an alpha of 0.05, a power of 80%, and a sample size of 71 resulting in a detectable effect size of 0.6. Owing to the limited sample size, only medium or large effects in changes of biomechanical properties can be excluded with adequate power. RESULTS: Ha and DM were not different with the numbers available when comparing knees with osteophyte Grades 0, 1, and 2 on the lateral tibia. For Grade 3 tibial osteophytes (n = 3), the lateral tibia cartilage showed low Ha (0.39 MPa; SD, 0.17 MPa) and low DM (2.85 MPa; SD, 2.12 MPa). On the lateral femur, no differences of Ha and DM were observed with the numbers available between Grades 0 to 3 osteophytes. No differences with the numbers available in the OARSI histologic grades on the lateral tibia plateau and the distal lateral femur were observed between the different osteophyte grades. CONCLUSIONS: Lateral-compartment osteophytes are not associated with biomechanically weaker cartilage or with more-advanced histologic signs of degeneration of lateral-compartment cartilage in knees with varus arthritis. Given the small sample size of 71, the study was underpowered to detect small-to-modest decreases in biomechanical properties. Future studies with larger sample sizes are needed to confirm the current findings. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Factors other than the presence or absence of lateral-compartment osteophytes should be considered when evaluating patients with medial-compartment arthritis for medial UKA. Future studies are required to define the limitations of plain radiographs to rule out cartilage degeneration in the lateral compartment of varus knees.
引用
- Waldstein W, Kasparek MF, Faschingbauer M, et al. Lateral-compartment Osteophytes are not Associated With Lateral-compartment Cartilage Degeneration in Arthritic Varus Knees. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2016. PMID: 27830485. doi:10.1007/s11999-016-5155-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。