新的金属股骨头能否恢复腐蚀性股骨颈的机械完整性?
本研究用22个钴铬合金和钛合金股骨颈(原始10个、腐蚀12个)及新金属头,在MTS机器上进行装配、拆卸、再装配、摆动和再拆卸测试,测量头-颈界面三维运动。结果显示腐蚀与原始股骨颈在新金属头植入后的力学性能无统计学差异,界面微动在约50个加载周期后稳定于平均30.6±3.2 μm。结论认为钴铬头替换钴铬颈时腐蚀不破坏机械完整性,但腐蚀钛颈上新金属头的界面运动增加需进一步研究。
要点
- 腐蚀与原始股骨颈植入新金属头后的力学性能无统计学差异。
- 头-颈界面微动在加载初期最大,约50个周期后稳定于平均30.6±3.2 μm。
- 腐蚀钛颈上新金属头的界面运动增加需额外研究。
核心结论
- 钴铬头替换钴铬颈时,股骨颈腐蚀不破坏接头的机械完整性。
- 腐蚀钛颈上新金属头的界面运动增加需额外研究。
- 球头尺寸对股骨颈机械完整性的评估也是未来研究的潜在课题,因为翻修时增大球头尺寸并不少见。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用22个股骨颈(钴铬合金n=12,钛合金n=10)和新金属头,其中10个为原始状态、12个有腐蚀损伤。
- 测试状态包括装配、拆卸、再装配、摆动和再拆卸,使用MTS机器进行。
- 加载过程中使用定制夹具测量头-颈接头的三维运动。
主要发现
- 腐蚀与原始股骨颈植入新金属股骨头后的测试力学性能无统计学差异。
- 头与颈界面的平均微动在加载开始时最大,约50个加载周期后稳定于平均30.6±3.2 μm。
局限性
- 腐蚀钛颈上新金属头的界面运动增加需额外研究。
- 球头尺寸对股骨颈机械完整性的评估也是未来研究的潜在课题。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Metal wear and corrosion from modular junctions in total hip arthroplasty can lead to further unwanted surgery. Trunnion tribocorrosion is recognized as an important contributor to failure. This study was performed to determine if new metal heads restore mechanical integrity of the original modular junction after impaction on corroded trunnions, and assess which variables affect stability of the new interface created at revision total hip arthroplasty. METHODS: Twenty-two trunnions, cobalt-chromium (CoCr) and titanium alloy (TiAIV), (CoCr, n = 12; TiAIV, n = 10) and new metal heads were used, 10 trunnions in pristine condition and 12 with corrosion damage. Test states were performed using an MTS Machine and included the following: 1, Assembly; 2, Disassembly; 3, Assembly; 4, Toggling; and 5, Disassembly. During loading, three-dimensional motion of the head-trunnion junction was measured using a custom jig. RESULTS: There were no statistical differences in the tested mechanical properties between corroded and pristine trunnions implanted with a new metal femoral head. Average micromotion of the head versus trunnion interface was greatest at the start of loading, stabilizing after approximately 50 loading cycles at an average of 30.6 ± 3.2 μm. CONCLUSION: Corrosion at the trunnion does not disrupt mechanical integrity of the junction when a CoCr head is replaced with a CoCr trunnion. However, increased interface motion of a new metal head on a corroded titanium trunnion requires additional study. The evaluation of ball head size on mechanical integrity of trunnions would also be a potential subject of future investigation, as increasing the ball head size at the time of revision is not uncommon in revisions today.
引用
- Derasari A, Gold JE, Ismaily S, et al. Will New Metal Heads Restore Mechanical Integrity of Corroded Trunnions? J Arthroplasty. 2016. PMID: 27836578. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2016.10.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。