股四头肌腱自体移植物取材技术影响移植物强度与横截面积
结果显示QT移植物显著大于且强于BTB,全层双刀片取材的CSA和失败载荷最大,超声CSA测量可靠且与移植物强度相关。
要点
- QT移植物较BTB具有更大的横截面积和更高的最大载荷。
- 全层双刀片取材的QT移植物CSA和失败载荷最大。
- 超声测量CSA可靠,且与移植物强度正相关。
核心结论
- QT移植物显著大于且强于BTB,全层双刀片取材产生最大CSA和失败载荷。
- 超声是测量CSA的可靠工具,CSA与移植物强度相关。
研究设计与样本
- 包括15条用9毫米双刀片手术刀获取的BTB、7条同法获取的全层QT(DB-QT)和8条用专有9毫米圆柱形QT取材器获取的QT(CH-QT)。
- 由2名评估者超声测量3个区域的CSA,随后进行循环加载和拉伸至失败测试,并分析组间差异及CSA与生物力学结果的线性回归。
主要发现
- 超声CSA信度良好至优秀(ICC2,1=0.70-0.87;ICC2,k=0.82-0.93)。
- CSA组间差异显著(均值±SD:BTB 0.44±0.08 cm2;CH-QT 0.64±0.10;DB-QT 0.97±0.22;所有两两比较P<.01),方差不齐(Levene P=.002)。
- DB-QT的CSA变异性大于BTB(P=.005),与CH-QT无差异(P=.055)。
- 最大载荷和最大载荷能量组间差异显著(总体P<.001),DB-QT>CH-QT>BTB,事后比较有显著差异。
- 配对膝分析中,混合QT移植物较同标本BTB最大位移更大;CH-QT最大载荷变异性大于BTB(P=.002)和DB-QT(P=.045)。
临床怎么用
- QT移植物较BTB具有更大的结构容量,取材技术影响移植物尺寸和强度。
- 双刀片取材可产生更大、更强的移植物。
- 超声可作为测量移植物CSA的可靠工具,CSA与强度相关。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Bone-patellar tendon-bone (BTB) autografts have been considered the gold standard for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, although the popularity of quadriceps tendon (QT) autografts is increasing. HYPOTHESIS/PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to compare the ultrasound-derived cross-sectional area (CSA) and biomechanical strength of BTB and QT grafts harvested with different techniques. The authors hypothesized that ultrasound CSA measurements would be reliable and that QT grafts would be larger and stronger than BTB grafts, without differences between QT harvest methods. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Thirty grafts from 15 cadaveric knees included 15 BTB grafts harvested with a 9-mm double-blade scalpel, 7 full-thickness QT grafts harvested with the same 9-mm double-blade scalpel (DB-QT), and 8 QT grafts harvested with a proprietary 9-mm cylindrical QT harvester (CH-QT). CSA was measured at 3 regions with ultrasound by 2 raters, followed by cyclic loading and pull-to-failure testing. Between-group differences were analyzed, and associations between CSA and biomechanical outcomes were assessed with linear regression. RESULTS: Ultrasound CSA demonstrated good to excellent reliability (ICC2,1 = 0.70-0.87; ICC2,k = 0.82-0.93). CSA differed between graft types (mean ± SD; BTB, 0.44 ± 0.08 cm2; CH-QT, 0.64 ± 0.10; DB-QT, 0.97 ± 0.22; all pairwise P < .01), with heterogeneous variance (Levene P = .002). DB-QT demonstrated greater CSA variability than BTB (P = .005) and no difference in variability when compared with CH-QT (P = .055). Maximum load and energy to maximum load differed significantly (both omnibus P < .001) with DB-QT > CH-QT > BTB, with significant post hoc differences. In paired-knee analyses, pooled QT grafts also demonstrated greater maximum displacement than BTB grafts from the same specimens. CH-QT demonstrated significantly greater variability in maximum load than BTB (P = .002) and DB-QT (P = .045). Mean displacement at maximum load and stiffness were similar, although variance differed. Cyclic elongation differed among grafts (omnibus P = .011), with DB-QT < CH-QT < BTB, while other cyclic measures did not differ. When grafts were pooled, CSA correlated positively with maximum load and energy to maximum load; however, within-graft type regressions were not significant. After normalization to CSA, stress and strain were similar across graft types. CONCLUSION: QT grafts were significantly larger and stronger than BTB, with full-thickness double-blade harvest producing the greatest CSA and load to failure. Ultrasound was a reliable tool to measure CSA, which correlated with graft strength. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: QT grafts demonstrate greater structural capacity than BTB, and QT harvest technique influences graft size and strength, with double-blade harvest producing larger, stronger grafts.
引用
- Bi AS, Augustin EJ, Smelley CC, et al. Quadriceps Tendon Autograft Harvest Technique Affects Both Graft Strength and Cross-sectional Area. Am J Sports Med. 2026. PMID: 42683675. doi:10.1177/03635465261478369
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。