文献速递骨肿瘤创伤骨科

骨科肿瘤医师对病理性骨折的判定一致性研究

Can Orthopaedic Oncologists Agree on What Is and Is Not a Pathologic Fracture?
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2026-08-25

该研究调查30名骨科肿瘤医师对20例转移性骨病患者影像的判定,两次调查间隔至少6个月,组间Fleiss kappa分别为0.54和0.64,组内Cohen kappa用于评估。医师在完全骨折线或骨移位时一致认为存在病理性骨折,但在皮质穿孔伴软组织肿块、皮质严重受损无明确断裂、不完全骨折线或骨痂等情形下分歧明显。

要点

  • 骨科肿瘤医师对病理性骨折的影像判定仅达中度至显著一致(Fleiss kappa 0.54–0.64)。
  • 完全可见骨折线或骨移位时医师一致判定为病理性骨折。
  • 皮质穿孔伴软组织成分、严重皮质受损无断裂、不完全骨折线或骨痂是主要分歧点。

核心结论

  • 骨科肿瘤医师常对影像表现看法一致,但对是否存在病理性骨折得出相反结论,分歧程度过大,难以形成共同语言和明确手术指征。
  • 需要进一步审查和共识以基于影像表现达成一致,从而制定可普遍应用的病理性骨折定义。
  • 该发现已推动MSTS内多学科共识项目的早期工作,旨在对骨骼病变进行分类以用于临床沟通、研究和登记。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究为诊断性研究,证据等级Level IV。
  • 调查20例转移性骨病患者的影像(包括X线、CT和MRI),发送给30名在MSTS担任委员会或领导职务的骨科肿瘤医师。
  • 影像 review 两次,间隔至少6个月;第一次调查仅问「是否存在病理性骨折?」回答是或否;第二次调查同样幻灯片不同顺序,并要求提供决策理由。
  • 使用Fleiss kappa评估组间一致性,Cohen kappa评估组内一致性。

主要发现

  • 第一次调查组间Fleiss kappa为0.54(p < 0.001),提示中度一致;第二次为0.64(p < 0.001),提示显著一致。
  • 对影像表现描述的Fleiss kappa为0.47(p < 0.001),提示中度一致。
  • 几乎每位外科医生同意,影像显示完全可见骨折线或骨移位的患者代表病理性骨折。
  • 影像显示骨侵蚀但无 obvious 完全皮质破坏的患者被判定不represent病理性骨折。
  • 主要分歧情形包括:(1)皮质穿孔伴 underlying tumor 的软组织成分;(2)皮质严重受损但无 clear discontinuity;(3)部分皮质的不完全骨折线或骨痂。

关键数值与推荐

  • 组间一致性Fleiss kappa:第一次调查0.54(p < 0.001),第二次调查0.64(p < 0.001)。
  • 影像表现描述一致性Fleiss kappa:0.47(p < 0.001)。
  • 一致性强度基于kappa值0.0至1.0的区间尺度分类。

临床怎么用

  • 临床中应认识到不同骨科肿瘤医师对病理性骨折的影像判定存在显著分歧,尤其在皮质穿孔伴软组织成分、严重皮质受损无断裂、不完全骨折线或骨痂等情形。
  • 在沟通和手术决策时需明确影像特征,避免因定义不一致导致治疗差异。
  • 可参考MSTS正在推进的多学科共识项目,期待形成统一的病理性骨折定义以用于临床、研究和登记。

局限性

  • 研究仅基于影像学表现,未考虑非影像学特征对病理性骨折定义的影响。
  • 样本量有限(20例患者,30名评估者),且评估者为MSTS委员会或领导职务的骨科肿瘤医师,可能不代表所有骨科肿瘤医师。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Orthopaedic oncologists have not agreed on a common definition of pathologic fracture despite abundant reports on diagnosis and management. A standard definition is important for treatment decisions, outcomes assessment, and administrative categorization; therefore, it is first necessary to understand areas of agreement and disagreement on the imaging findings exclusively before considering nonradiologic features of pathologic fracture. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Based on images (radiographs, CT scans, and MRIs), to what degree do orthopaedic oncologists agree on whether or not a pathologic fracture is present? (2) What imaging features lead orthopaedic surgeons to believe that a pathologic fracture is present? METHODS: We developed a survey of images from 20 patients with metastatic bone disease and distributed them to 30 orthopaedic oncologists holding committee or leadership positions in the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society (MSTS). Images were reviewed twice, at least 6 months apart. Each question consisted of a PowerPoint slide of a patient with metastatic bone disease, with representative plain radiographs, CTs, and MRIs when available. On the first survey, there was only one question for each patient scenario: "Is there a pathologic fracture?" Respondents were asked to respond simply "yes" or "no." In the second survey, consisting of the same PowerPoint slides in a different order, we asked the participants to provide additional insight and rationale behind their decision for each case regarding whether or not there was a fracture to further investigate areas of differences in interpretation or assessment. The Fleiss kappa (κ) was used to evaluate interrater agreement, and the Cohen kappa assessed intrarater agreement for the binary classification of pathologic fractures. The strength of agreement was classified on an interval scale based on a kappa value from 0.0 to 1.0. RESULTS: The Fleiss kappa for interrater reliability was 0.54 (p < 0.001) for the first survey, indicating moderate agreement, and 0.64 (p < 0.001) for the second, reflecting substantial agreement according to established definitions of agreement. The Fleiss kappa was 0.47 (p < 0.001) for the description of imaging findings, reflecting moderate agreement. We found that nearly every surgeon agreed that images from patients with a complete visible fracture line or bone displacement represented a pathologic fracture. Similarly, patients whose images showed bone erosion but no obvious complete cortical disruption were determined not to represent a pathologic fracture. The areas of major disagreement among orthopaedic oncologists in image interpretation occurred when there was (1) a cortical perforation with a soft tissue component from the underlying tumor, (2) a severely compromised cortex without a clear discontinuity, or (3) an incomplete fracture line or callus in a portion of the cortex. CONCLUSION: Often raters agreed on the imaging findings but drew opposite conclusions regarding whether a pathologic fracture was present based on sets of images that replicate common clinical scenarios. This disproportionality of responses is too great to have common language for communication and clear surgical indications. This indicates that further review and consensus aimed at agreement on imaging findings based on these data are needed to allow for a clear definition of a pathologic fracture that can be universally applied. Our findings have stimulated early work for a multispecialty consensus project within the MSTS, which aims to classify skeletal lesions for use in clinical communication, research, and registries. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, diagnostic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Dalamaggas A, Grothe A, Gao Y, et al. Can Orthopaedic Oncologists Agree on What Is and Is Not a Pathologic Fracture? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2026. PMID: 42641000. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000004101

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。