注册表与大型数据库研究中现代非骨水泥与骨水泥全膝关节置换术的系统综述
该系统综述检索了2010至2024年注册表与大型数据库研究,评估现代非骨水泥全膝关节置换术(TKA)的生存率。纳入8项注册表研究和2项大型数据库研究,方法学质量普遍较差(平均MCM评分35.5和36.0),非骨水泥假体占比多不足5%,但翻修率差异通常小于1%。与27项随机对照试验(平均MCM评分76.9)相比,注册表证据质量较低,但生存率结果总体相似。
要点
- 注册表研究平均MCM评分35.5,均为III级证据,方法学质量差。
- 非骨水泥与骨水泥TKA翻修率差异通常小于1%。
- 多数研究中非骨水泥假体占比不足5%,比较数据有限。
核心结论
- 注册表和大型数据库研究关于现代非骨水泥TKA的比较数据有限且方法学质量较低,但生存率结果与骨水泥TKA总体相似。
主要发现
- 8项注册表研究平均MCM评分35.5(范围29-39),均为III级证据;2项大型数据库研究平均MCM评分36.0(范围35-37),均为II级证据。
- 非骨水泥与骨水泥TKA翻修率差异通常小于1%。
- 多数研究中非骨水泥假体占评估植入物的不到5%,一项研究评估了1,056,492例骨水泥TKA与26,768例非骨水泥TKA。
- 一项大型数据库研究仅随访1年,两项均未报告具体假体生存率。
关键数值与推荐
- MCM评分85-100为优秀,70-84为良好,55-69为一般,低于55为差。
- 注册表研究平均MCM评分35.5,大型数据库研究平均MCM评分36.0,随机对照试验系统综述平均MCM评分76.9(范围61-91)。
临床怎么用
- 临床决策时可参考非骨水泥与骨水泥TKA翻修率差异小于1%的结果,但需注意注册表证据方法学质量较低且非骨水泥假体占比小。
局限性
- 注册表和大型数据库研究比较数据有限,方法学质量差,非骨水泥假体占比小,部分研究随访时间短或未报告具体生存率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Interest is growing in durable, cementless fixation in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). This study aimed to systematically review registry and large database studies, evaluating their quality of evidence and assessing implant survivorship. Additionally, we compared these findings to a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. METHODS: A search of PubMed and Embase was conducted to identify eligible registry and large database studies on contemporary cementless TKA survivorship published between January 1, 2010, and December 31, 2024. Overlapping studies from the same registry were excluded. Modified Coleman methodology (MCM) scores were used to assess methodological quality, with a score of 85 to 100 considered excellent, 70 to 84 considered good, 55 to 69 considered fair, and below 55 considered poor. In addition, level of evidence assessments were made. RESULTS: Among eight included registry studies, the mean MCM score was 35.5 (range, 29 to 39), reflecting poor quality, and all were level III evidence. Differences in revision rates between cementless and cemented TKA were typically less than 1%. Cementless prostheses comprised less than 5% of total implants evaluated for most studies, with one study evaluating 1,056,492 cemented versus 26,768 cementless TKAs. For the two large database studies, the mean MCM score was low at 36.0 (range, 35 to 37), and both were level II evidence. Of these, one included only a 1-year follow-up, and neither reported specific implant survivorship. However, a recent systematic review of contemporary cementless TKA included 27 randomized controlled trials with a mean MCM score of 76.9 (range, 61 to 91), indicating good quality. CONCLUSIONS: Registry and large database studies on contemporary cementless TKA have limited comparative data, often of lower methodological quality, with cementless implants representing a small proportion of cases. Despite these shortcomings, results for survivorship are generally similar for cementless and cemented TKAs.
引用
- Lombardi AV, Rainey JP, Gililland JM, et al. A Systematic Review of Registry and Large Database Studies Comparing Contemporary Cementless and Cemented Total Knee Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2026. PMID: 42373150. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2026.01.069
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。