指南与共识关节外科运动医学

髋关节不稳定的影像学定义:国际多学科德尔菲共识

Which Imaging Modalities, Parameters, and Diagnostic Thresholds Best Define Hip Instability? Consensus Statements From a Scoping Review and an International Multidisciplinary Delphi Study.
指南 / 共识 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2026-03-19

本研究通过范围综述和改良德尔菲法,由国际多学科专家组制定27条关于髋关节不稳定影像学检查的共识声明。经两轮匿名投票,81%(22/27)的声明达成共识,明确了X线、MRI和CT的基础地位及多个定量阈值,但动态和软组织指标未达成共识。

要点

  • X线(骨盆正位、假斜位、Dunn位)、MRI和CT是评估髋关节不稳定的基础影像模式。
  • LCEA<20°诊断髋发育不良,20°-25°提示可能临床不稳定;AWI<0.30、PWI<0.8、髋臼版本<5°或>30°为共识阈值。
  • FEAR指数、新月征、前关节囊厚度和动态股骨头移位等指标未达成共识。

核心结论

  • 国际德尔菲共识定义了髋关节不稳定评估的核心影像学方法和阈值,但对较新的软组织和动态指标缺乏共识。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用改良德尔菲技术的共识研究,遵循ACCORD指南,基于范围综述制定27条声明,由国际多学科专家组进行两轮匿名投票,共识定义为≥75%同意。

主要发现

  • 81%(22/27)的声明达成共识;X线、MRI和CT被认为是基础影像模式,软骨成像技术和动态超声为辅助手段。
  • LCEA、AWI、PWI和Tönnis角等放射学测量指标达成共识,作为关键形态学指标。

关键数值与推荐

  • LCEA<20°被认为诊断髋发育不良,20°至25°之间提示可能的临床髋关节不稳定。
  • AWI<0.30、PWI<0.8、髋臼版本<5°或>30°为共识阈值。
  • FEAR指数、新月征、前关节囊厚度和动态股骨头移位未达成共识。

临床怎么用

  • 对疑似临床髋关节不稳定的患者,首选标准X线检查,随后针对性使用CT和MRI评估三维骨形态和软组织稳定结构。
  • 影像学发现应在逐步算法框架内结合临床评估和多个互补影像参数解读,而非依赖孤立测量。
  • 需认识到髋关节不稳定可能在没有典型影像学征象时也存在。

局限性

  • 未达成共识的较新软组织和动态指标需要未来研究。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The diagnosis of hip instability remains challenging because of its multifactorial etiology and the variability of imaging practices across institutions. Hip instability refers to a clinical condition of insufficient osseous and/or soft tissue constraint with abnormal femoral head motion and symptoms, which may occur along a morphologic spectrum that overlaps with-but is not synonymous with-developmental dysplasia of the hip. Although numerous imaging modalities and imaging parameters have been proposed, there is limited consensus on which are most relevant, how they should be measured, and what diagnostic thresholds best correlate with instability. To address this gap, a Delphi consensus study with an international panel of experts to establish standardized clinical statements for the diagnostic criteria of hip instability was conducted. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What are the imaging modalities and protocols for investigating hip instability? (2) Which imaging parameters are most strongly associated with clinical hip instability? (3) What are the quantitative imaging thresholds for diagnosing hip instability? METHODS: A consensus study using a modified Delphi technique was conducted in accordance with the Accurate Consensus Reporting Document (ACCORD) guideline. Following a scoping review, 27 statements addressing imaging modalities and protocols (question 1), imaging parameters associated with hip instability (question 2), and quantitative imaging thresholds (question 3) were developed. These statements were evaluated by a multidisciplinary international expert panel during a structured consensus meeting, with two rounds of anonymous voting and consensus defined a priori as ≥ 75% agreement. Consensus was achieved for 81% (22 of 27) of statements. RESULTS: There was strong agreement that radiography (AP pelvis, false-profile, Dunn view) and MRI and CT constitute the foundational imaging modalities for the assessment of hip instability, whereas cartilage mapping techniques and dynamic ultrasound were considered adjunctive modalities with a more limited and evolving role. Radiographic measurements such as lateral center-edge angle (LCEA), anterior wall index (AWI), posterior wall index, and Tönnis angle reached consensus as key morphologic indicators. Several quantitative thresholds were endorsed. An LCEA of < 20° was considered diagnostic for hip dysplasia, a condition in which clinical hip instability is highly prevalent, whereas values between 20° and 25° were considered concerning for possible clinical hip instability. Additional thresholds included an AWI of < 0.30, PWI of < 0.8, and acetabular version < 5° or > 30°. In contrast, no consensus was reached for less-established imaging metrics such as the FEAR index, crescent sign, anterior capsule thickness, and dynamic femoral head translation. CONCLUSION: This international Delphi consensus defined core imaging approaches and threshold values for the evaluation of hip instability. Although agreement was reached on key morphometric parameters and diagnostic thresholds, a lack of consensus exists around newer soft tissue and dynamic measures, highlighting important areas for future research. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: In patients with suspected clinical hip instability, standard radiography should be used as the first-line imaging modality, followed by targeted use of CT and MRI to evaluate three-dimensional bony morphology and soft tissue stabilizers. Imaging findings should be interpreted within a stepwise, algorithmic framework that integrates clinical assessment with multiple complementary imaging parameters rather than relying on isolated measurements. Ultimately, accurate diagnosis of hip instability depends on the integration of findings from multiple modalities. Additionally, it must be recognized that hip instability may exist even in the absence of characteristic radiologic signs.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Leopold VJ, Rakhra K, Spiker AM, et al. Which Imaging Modalities, Parameters, and Diagnostic Thresholds Best Define Hip Instability? Consensus Statements From a Scoping Review and an International Multidisciplinary Delphi Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2026. PMID: 41926199. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003905

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。