术前中重度内翻对活动平台全踝关节置换至少5年生存率与疗效的影响
单中心回顾性比较研究,分析417例活动平台全踝关节置换中103例内翻踝与131例中立踝,至少随访5年。两组患者报告结局与假体生存率无差异,但内翻组不对称聚乙烯垫磨损比例更高(42%比17%)。
要点
- 术前中重度内翻踝行活动平台全踝置换后,患者报告结局与中立踝无临床重要差异。
- 10年无金属组件翻修生存率两组无差异(93.7%比94.2%)。
- 内翻组不对称聚乙烯垫磨损比例显著更高(42%比17%,p<0.001)。
核心结论
- 术前中重度内翻畸形患者行该活动平台全踝置换后,患者报告结局与假体生存率与中立踝相比无差异,但内翻踝不对称聚乙烯垫磨损比例更高,可能增加后续翻修风险。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心、单术者(非设计者)回顾性比较研究,2004年9月至2019年5月共行417例全踝置换,均使用同一活动平台假体。
- 382例合格踝中,内翻组168踝(术前冠状面胫距角≥10°内翻),中立组214踝(<10°内翻或外翻)。
- 内翻组103例(61%)、中立组131例(61%)获得至少5年完整影像与患者报告结局随访,为本研究分析对象;中位随访123个月(60至230)。
主要发现
- 至少5年随访时两组患者报告结局评分无临床重要差异。
- 内翻组术前内翻畸形更大(18°±6°比3°±4°,平均差15°[95%CI 14°至17°],p<0.001),术后残余内翻多1°(3°±2°比2°±2°,平均差1°[95%CI 0°至1°],p=0.01)。
- 至少10年无金属组件翻修生存率两组无差异(中立组93.7%[95%CI 89.9%至99.4%]比内翻组94.2%[95%CI 89.8%至98.9%],p=0.88)。
- 至少10年无任何组件翻修(含聚乙烯垫更换)生存率两组无差异(68.7%[95%CI 60.3%至78.3%]比75.1%[95%CI 66.3%至85.1%],p=0.19)。
- 至少10年无任何非计划再手术生存率两组无差异(63.4%[95%CI 54.8%至73.3%]比63.1%[95%CI 53.6%至74.3%],p=0.94);内翻组不对称聚乙烯垫磨损比例更高(42%[43/103]比17%[22/131],p<0.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 内翻踝定义为术前冠状面胫距角≥10°内翻,中立踝定义为<10°内翻或外翻。
- 需时由术者决定是否行额外操作矫正冠状面力线。
- 采用Kaplan-Meier法分析5年与10年三个终点生存率:金属组件翻修或取出、任何组件翻修(含聚乙烯垫更换)、任何非计划再手术。
- 临床结局评估包括VAS疼痛评分、踝骨关节炎量表疼痛与功能障碍亚评分及踝关节活动度;影像评估包括术后冠状面胫距角与不对称聚乙烯垫磨损,并用金属伪影削减CT评估骨溶解。
临床怎么用
- 对术前中重度内翻踝行活动平台全踝置换时,可预期与中立踝相似的短期患者报告结局和假体生存率,不应仅因内翻而排除该术式。
- 术后需关注内翻踝不对称聚乙烯垫磨损风险,规律影像随访以早期发现磨损并评估翻修时机。
局限性
- 为单中心、单术者回顾性研究,两组仅约61%患者获得至少5年完整随访,存在失访偏倚可能。
- 两组创伤后骨关节炎与炎性关节炎构成不同,基线病因分布存在差异。
- 研究仅使用一种活动平台假体,结论外推至其他假体设计需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Analyses of long-term results after mobile-bearing total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) in ankles with preoperative moderate to severe varus deformity with adequate sample sizes remain limited. Because preoperative moderate to severe varus alignment may influence implant survival and functional outcomes, clarifying its long-term impact is important. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Do the clinical and radiologic outcomes of mobile-bearing TAA differ between ankles with preoperative neutral alignment and those with moderate to severe varus alignment? (2) What are the 5- and 10-year prosthesis survivorship, survivorship free from any revision including polyethylene exchange, and survivorship free from any unplanned reoperation in each group after mobile-bearing TAA? (3) Did the incidence of asymmetric polyethylene wear differ between the groups? METHODS: Between September 2004 and May 2019, a single nondeveloper surgeon performed 417 TAAs. All procedures were performed using a single-design mobile-bearing device. The general indications for TAA were painful end-stage ankle arthritis. Of the 382 eligible ankles, 44% (168 ankles) were in patients with varus ankles (a preoperative coronal tibiotalar ankle ≥ 10° of varus) and 56% (214 ankles) were in neutral ankles (defined as < 10° of varus or valgus). Sixty-one percent (103 of 168) of the varus group and 61% (131 of 214) of the neutral group were available for follow-up with complete radiographic imaging and patient-reported outcome scores at a minimum of 5 years, and these patients were the focus of this retrospective, comparative study. The median (range) follow-up time was 123 months (60 to 230). The groups were similar with respect to age (63 versus 64 years; p = 0.34), gender (53% versus 44% men; p = 0.19), BMI (25.1 versus 25.5 kg/m 2 ; p = 0.58), and follow-up duration (124 versus 116 months; p = 0.09). Although posttraumatic osteoarthritis was more common in the varus group and inflammatory arthritis in the neutral group, baseline demographic characteristics were otherwise comparable. Additional procedures to correct coronal alignment were performed at the discretion of the surgeon when necessary. Clinical outcomes were evaluated using VAS pain scores, Ankle Osteoarthritis Scale pain and disability subscores, as well as ankle ROM. Radiologic assessment included measurements of the postoperative coronal tibiotalar angle and development of asymmetric polyethylene inlay wear. CT scans with metal artifact reduction were performed to evaluate osteolysis. Survivorship was analyzed using the Kaplan-Meier method at 5 and 10 years for three endpoints: (1) revision or removal of a metal component, (2) revision of any component (including polyethylene exchange), and (3) any unplanned reoperation. RESULTS: There were no clinically important differences in patient-reported outcome scores between the neutral and varus groups at a minimum of 5-year follow-up. The varus group had greater preoperative varus deformity (3° ± 4° versus 18° ± 6°, mean difference 15° [95% confidence interval (CI) 14° to 17°]; p < 0.001). Postoperative coronal plane alignment differed between groups, with the varus group demonstrating 1° more residual varus (2° ± 2° versus 3° ± 2°, mean difference 1° [95% CI 0° to 1°]; p = 0.01). Survivorship free from metal component revision did not differ between the neutral and varus groups at a minimum of 10-year follow-up (93.7% [95% CI 89.9% to 99.4%] versus 94.2% [95% CI 89.8% to 98.9%]; p = 0.88). Survivorship free from all-kind revision (including polyethylene exchange) did not differ between the neutral and varus groups at a minimum of 10-year follow-up (68.7% [95% CI 60.3% to 78.3%] versus 75.1% [95% CI 66.3% to 85.1%]; p = 0.19). Survivorship free from any unplanned reoperation did not differ between the neutral and varus groups at a minimum of 10-year follow-up (63.4% [95% CI 54.8% to 73.3%] versus 63.1% [95% CI 53.6% to 74.3%]; p = 0.94). The varus group had a higher proportion of patients who developed asymmetric polyethylene inlay wear than did the neutral group (42% [43 of 103] versus 17% [22 of 131]; p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: In patients with moderate to severe preoperative varus deformity treated with this mobile-bearing TAA, we found no difference in patient-reported outcomes and implant survivorship compared with neutral ankles. However, varus ankles demonstrated a higher proportion of asymmetric polyethylene inlay wear, which may increase the risk of subsequent revision. Future studies should determine which patterns of varus deformity and residual malalignment are most strongly associated with edge-loading and how surgical correction strategies may mitigate this risk. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Yoon YK, Park KH, Shim DW, et al. Is Preoperative Moderate to Severe Varus Alignment Associated With Survivorship and Outcome Scores at a Minimum of 5 Years After Mobile-bearing Total Ankle Arthroplasty With the Hintegra Device? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2026. PMID: 41974497. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003932
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。