磁共振研究:内翻膝中内侧副韧带在15°内翻内不挛缩,外侧副韧带可能延长
比较100例内翻骨关节炎膝与100例正常膝的MRI,测量内侧副韧带(MCL)和外侧副韧带(LCL)长度及骨赘宽度。发现MCL/TEA比值不随畸形显著变化,>15°内翻时MCL平均缩短5mm,LCL/TEA比值在5-15°内翻增大。结论提示≤15°内翻时MCL不挛缩而是被骨赘顶起,LCL可能延长。
要点
- ≤15°内翻膝中MCL长度无显著缩短,其紧张感可能源于骨赘顶起而非解剖挛缩。
- LCL/TEA比值在5-15°内翻膝中增大,提示LCL可能随畸形延长。
- >15°内翻时MCL平均缩短5mm,可能因骨丢失或半脱位所致。
核心结论
- 内翻骨关节炎膝中MCL不缩短而是被内侧骨赘顶起,LCL可能随畸形延长最多2mm。
- >15°内翻时,浅层MCL和LCL的无应力长度似减少,可能因骨丢失和半脱位。
- ≤15°内翻膝的紧张感可能非解剖挛缩所致,质疑常规MCL松解的必要性。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性磁共振成像比较研究,纳入100例骨关节炎内翻膝与100例正常对照膝。
- 测量经上髁轴宽度、MCL和LCL沿迂曲长度、附着点直线距离、髋膝踝角及内外侧骨赘宽度。
主要发现
- MCL/TEA比值在不同畸形组间无显著差异。
- >15°内翻膝中MCL平均长度减少5mm(P<0.001)。
- LCL/TEA比值在5-10°内翻(P=0.001)和10-15°内翻(P=0.007)膝中增大。
- MCL差值(MCL1线减MCL长度)与股骨骨赘宽度(P=0.009)和胫骨骨赘宽度(P=0.044)显著相关。
关键数值与推荐
- ≤15°内翻膝中MCL不挛缩,LCL可能延长最多2mm。
- >15°内翻膝中MCL平均缩短5mm,LCL无应力长度亦可能减少。
- MCL差值增加与股骨和胫骨骨赘宽度显著相关(P=0.009和P=0.044)。
临床怎么用
- ≤15°内翻膝矫正时或无需松解MCL,可优先行骨赘切除。
- 避免仅为避免MCL松解而常规选择替代对线理念。
- >15°内翻膝需注意骨丢失和半脱位对韧带长度的影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The question of whether the superficial medial collateral ligament (MCL) undergoes contracture in the presence of osteoarthritic changes remains unresolved. Addressing this fundamental scientific inquiry is crucial for determining the surgical technique of correcting varus deformity and evaluating the need for deploying alternative alignment philosophies. METHODS: Magnetic resonance (MR) images of 100 knees with established osteoarthritis were compared to those of 100 normal control knees. We measured the width of the transepicondylar axis (TEA), lengths of the MCL and lateral collateral ligaments (LCL) along their tortuosity, the straight line distance between their attachments (MCL1 line and LCL1 line), the hip-knee-ankle angle, and the width of medial femoral and tibial osteophytes. RESULTS: The MCL/TEA ratios did not differ significantly with deformity. The mean MCL length was reduced by five mm in knees greater than 15° varus (P < 0.001). The LCL/TEA ratios were greater in knees with 5 to 10° (P = 0.001) and 10 to 15° varus (P = 0.007). The MCL difference (MCL1 line minus MCL length) significantly correlated with femoral (P = 0.009) and tibial osteophyte width (P = 0.044). CONCLUSIONS: In varus arthritic knees, the MCL does not shorten but is tented over medial osteophytes. The LCL may elongate by up to two mm with increasing deformity. At extreme deformity (greater than 15°), possibly due to bone loss and subluxation, the unstressed lengths of superficial MCL and LCL appear to be reduced. This study questions the need for releasing the MCL in knees with up to 15° varus, as anatomical contracture may not be the primary cause of tightness; alternative techniques such as osteophyte excision should be prioritized. It may suggest reconsideration of alternative alignment philosophies solely to avoid superficial MCL release.
引用
- Mullaji AB, Nadal RR. A Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study Comparing Varus Arthritic to Normal Knees Indicates that the Medial Collateral Ligament Does Not Contract in up to 15° of Varus Deformity, Whereas the Lateral Collateral Ligament May Elongate. J Arthroplasty. 2026. PMID: 41936831. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2026.03.093
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。