长腿X线片仍是确定膝关节冠状面力线分类的最佳方法:与CT扫描图或短膝X线片的比较
本研究回顾性分析300例接受机器人辅助初次全膝关节置换术(TKA)的膝关节,比较站立位长腿X线片(LLR)、仰卧位CT扫描图和站立位短膝X线片在测量下肢力线及膝关节冠状面力线(CPAK)分型上的一致性。结果显示各模态测量值强相关,但CPAK分型仅中度一致,超过30%的膝关节在CT或短膝片下与LLR分型不同,故建议使用CPAK分型时采用LLR。
要点
- CT扫描图和短膝X线片与LLR的力线测量值均呈强相关。
- CT扫描图和短膝X线片与LLR的CPAK分型仅中度一致。
- 超过30%的膝关节在CT或短膝片下CPAK分型与LLR不同。
核心结论
- 尽管各影像模态测量下肢力线强相关,但CPAK分型仅中度一致,使用CPAK分型确定TKA手术力线策略或报告相关结果时应使用LLR。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性综述300例接受机器人辅助初次TKA的膝关节,所有患者均有术前LLR、CT扫描图和短膝X线片,由两名评估者独立测量。
主要发现
- 与LLR测量相比,CT扫描图的机械外侧远端股骨角(mLDFA)和机械内侧近端胫骨角测量相关系数分别为0.839和0.819,短膝X线片分别为0.845和0.896。
- CT扫描图和短膝X线片与LLR的CPAK分型一致率分别为61.7%(Cohen's kappa 0.455)和68.7%(Cohen's kappa 0.571)。
- 超过30%的膝关节在CT扫描图或短膝X线片下确定的CPAK分型与LLR不同。
临床怎么用
- 使用CPAK分型确定TKA手术力线策略或报告CPAK相关结果时,应使用LLR而非CT扫描图或短膝X线片。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The coronal plane alignment of the knee (CPAK) classification is a pragmatic method to characterize constitutional limb alignment. The CPAK classification was originally described using radiographic measurements from standing long-leg radiographs (LLRs). Surgeons who do not obtain LLRs before total knee arthroplasty (TKA) may estimate CPAK using alternative modalities, including supine computed tomography (CT) scanograms and standing short knee radiographs. This study was performed to evaluate the correlation in measurements of lower limb alignment and the agreement of CPAK classification between these three imaging modalities. METHODS: A retrospective review of 300 knees undergoing robotic-assisted primary TKA was performed. All patients had preoperative LLRs, CT scanograms, and short knee radiographs. There were two reviewers who independently measured the mechanical lateral distal femoral angle (mLDFA) and mechanical medial proximal tibial angle on each modality. A five-degree adjustment was made to the anatomical lateral distal femoral angle measured on short knee radiographs to calculate an estimated mLDFA. Correlation coefficients for measurements between imaging modalities were evaluated. The agreement of CPAK phenotypes using each modality was assessed. RESULTS: When compared to LLR measurements, strong correlations were found for the mLDFA and mechanical medial proximal tibial anglemeasurements from CT scanograms (correlation coefficient, 0.839 and 0.819, respectively) and short knee radiographs (0.845 and 0.896, respectively). Moderate agreement for the CPAK type on LLRs was determined from CT scanograms (61.7% agreement; Cohen's kappa, 0.455) and short knee radiographs (68.7% agreement; 0.571). However, a different CPAK classification versus LLRs was determined from CT scanograms and short knee radiographs in over 30% of knees. CONCLUSIONS: Despite a strong correlation between imaging modalities for all radiographic measurements of limb alignment, only moderate agreement was noted in CPAK types. Therefore, surgeons who use CPAK classification to determine surgical alignment strategy in TKA, or when reporting outcomes associated with CPAK, should use LLRs.
引用
- Wininger AE, Wing CW, Bingham JS, et al. Coronal Plane Alignment of the Knee Classification Remains Best Determined on Long-Leg Radiographs Compared to Computed Tomography Scanograms or Short Knee Radiographs. J Arthroplasty. 2026. PMID: 41967984. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2026.01.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。