前交叉韧带重建中自体移植物类型比较:随机临床试验的系统综述与贝叶斯网络荟萃分析
该贝叶斯网络荟萃分析纳入44项随机临床试验共3491例患者,比较成人初次前交叉韧带重建中常用肌腱自体移植物。结果显示,股四头肌腱带骨(QTB)在IKDC、Tegner和旋转稳定性方面排名最高,且再断裂/翻修风险较低;但QTB在IKDC上虽优于骨-髌腱-骨(BPTB),差异可能无临床意义。
要点
- QTB在IKDC和Tegner评分中排名最高(SUCRA分别为90.1%和85.3%)。
- QTB的2级及以上轴移试验风险显著低于四股半腱肌(4SST)(RR=0.26,95%CI 0.07-0.85)。
- QTB再断裂/翻修风险较低(SUCRA=83.3%),BPTB在IKDC和Lysholm中排名最低。
核心结论
- 基于自体移植物排名,QTB总体上带来更好的功能、活动相关和稳定性结果,同时降低移植物失败风险。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与贝叶斯网络荟萃分析,检索PubMed、Scopus、Web of Science和Embase至2025年5月3日,纳入44项随机临床试验共3491例成人初次前交叉韧带重建患者。
主要发现
- QTB在IKDC上优于BPTB(平均差=3.46,95%可信区间0.29至6.77),但差异可能无临床意义。
- QTB在IKDC(SUCRA=90.1%)和Tegner(SUCRA=85.3%)中排名最高,BPTB在IKDC和Lysholm中排名最低。
- QTB在前后向稳定性中排名第二,在旋转稳定性中排名第一,且2级及以上轴移试验风险显著低于4SST(风险比=0.26,95%可信区间0.07至0.85)。
- QTB再断裂/翻修风险较低(SUCRA=83.3%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入比较至少两种以下肌腱自体移植物的随机临床试验:四股半腱肌(4SST)、四股半腱肌-股薄肌(4SSTG)及其五股变体(5SSTG)、骨-髌腱-骨(BPTB)、股四头肌腱带骨(QTB)和游离股四头肌腱(FQT)。
- 分析结局包括IKDC主观评分、Lysholm评分、Tegner活动量表、前后向(器械)和旋转(轴移试验)稳定性以及再断裂或翻修前交叉韧带重建率。
- 使用累积排名曲线下面积(SUCRA)值对自体移植物进行排名。
临床怎么用
- 对于初次前交叉韧带重建的成人患者,QTB在功能、活动水平和稳定性方面整体表现较好,且移植物失败风险较低,可作为优先考虑的移植物选择之一。
- QTB在IKDC上优于BPTB的差异可能无临床意义,临床决策时需结合患者具体情况。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The literature regarding optimal autograft choice for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction (ACLR) remains inconclusive. This network meta-analysis (NMA) compares common autografts for primary ACLR. METHODS: PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and Embase were searched up to May 3, 2025, for randomized clinical trials (RCTs) on primary ACLR in adults that compared ≥2 of the following tendon autografts: 4-strand semitendinosus (4SST), 4-strand semitendinosus-gracilis (4SSTG), its 5-strand variant (5SSTG), bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB), quadriceps tendon with bone (QTB), and free quadriceps tendon (FQT). Outcomes analyzed in the NMA were the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) subjective score, Lysholm score, Tegner Activity Scale, anteroposterior (instrumented) and rotational (pivot-shift) stability, and rerupture or revision ACLR rate. Autografts were ranked using surface under the cumulative ranking (SUCRA) values. RESULTS: A total of 44 RCTs with 3,491 patients were included in the NMA. With respect to the IKDC, QTB was statistically superior to BPTB (mean difference = 3.46, 95% credible interval [CrI]: 0.29 to 6.77), although the difference was likely not clinically meaningful. QTB ranked highest for the IKDC (SUCRA = 90.1%) and Tegner (SUCRA = 85.3%), while BPTB ranked lowest for the IKDC and Lysholm. With respect to knee laxity, QTB ranked second in anteroposterior and first in rotational stability, and it carried a significantly lower risk of a 2+ or higher pivot-shift than 4SST (risk ratio = 0.26, 95% CrI: 0.07 to 0.85). QTB was associated with a decreased risk of rerupture/revision compared with other autografts (SUCRA = 83.3%). CONCLUSIONS: Based on the autograft rankings, QTB was found to lead to improved functional, activity-related, and stability outcomes overall, while also reducing the risk of graft failure. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level I . See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Vosoughi F, Younesian S, Mousavi SM, et al. Comparison of Autograft Types in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Systematic Review and Bayesian Network Meta-Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2026. PMID: 41818333. doi:10.2106/JBJS.25.01315
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。