文献速递运动医学关节外科

25岁以下患者ACL重建中BPTB、腘绳肌腱与股四头肌腱自体移植物失败率的Meta分析

Graft Failure Rates in Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone, Hamstring, and Quadriceps Tendon Autografts in Patients Younger Than 25 Years: A Meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Sports Med · 2026-02-24

该Meta分析纳入46项研究共10624例≤25岁ACL重建患者,比较BPTB、腘绳肌腱(HT)与股四头肌腱(QT)自体移植物的失败率。HT失败率最高(11.1%),显著高于BPTB(5.1%),QT为2.5%但与BPTB、HT均无显著差异;男女失败风险相似。结论提示年轻患者HT并非最优选择,可考虑BPTB。

要点

  • ≤25岁ACL重建患者中,HT自体移植物失败率11.1%,显著高于BPTB的5.1%。
  • QT失败率2.5%,与BPTB和HT比较均无统计学显著差异。
  • 男女患者无论采用何种移植物,失败风险相似。

核心结论

  • 在≤25岁接受ACL重建的患者中,HT移植物失败率显著高于BPTB,提示HT并非该人群的最佳选择,可考虑BPTB以降低失败风险。
  • QT与BPTB的比较尚需更大样本的随机对照试验进一步确定。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述与Meta分析,证据等级为4级。
  • 纳入46项报告≤25岁患者ACL移植物(BPTB、HT、QT)再损伤率且随访至少24个月的研究。
  • 共纳入10624例患者:HT 6090例(女性47.0%,平均随访54.5个月),BPTB 3990例(女性63.0%,平均随访63.6个月),QT 544例(女性40.3%,平均随访41.6个月)。
  • 排除涉及翻修ACL重建、同种异体移植物ACL重建、同种异体移植物增强ACL重建、合并外侧关节外腱固定术或未按移植物类型和≤25岁年龄报告再损伤率的研究。

主要发现

  • HT失败率最高,为11.1%(95%CI,8.8%-13.9%)。
  • BPTB失败率为5.1%(95%CI,3.5%-7.2%),QT失败率为2.5%(95%CI,0.5%-11.2%)。
  • HT失败率显著高于BPTB(Q=13.1;P<.001)。
  • HT与QT失败率无显著差异(Q=3.7;P=.06),BPTB与QT失败率亦无显著差异(Q=0.8;P=.4)。
  • 无论采用何种移植物类型,男性和女性的移植物失败风险相似。

关键数值与推荐

  • 纳入标准:报告≤25岁患者ACL移植物(BPTB、HT、QT)再损伤率,随访至少24个月。
  • 排除标准:翻修ACL重建、同种异体移植物ACL重建、同种异体移植物增强ACL重建、合并外侧关节外腱固定术,或未按移植物类型和≤25岁年龄报告再损伤率。
  • HT失败率11.1%(95%CI,8.8%-13.9%),BPTB失败率5.1%(95%CI,3.5%-7.2%),QT失败率2.5%(95%CI,0.5%-11.2%)。
  • HT vs BPTB:Q=13.1,P<.001;HT vs QT:Q=3.7,P=.06;BPTB vs QT:Q=0.8,P=.4。

临床怎么用

  • 对于≤25岁需行ACL重建的年轻患者,选择移植物时应考虑HT失败率较高,BPTB可作为降低失败风险的优选。
  • QT在本分析中失败率较低,但与BPTB及HT的比较尚无统计学显著差异,临床应用需结合个体情况并期待更高质量证据。
  • 性别不应作为选择移植物类型以降低失败风险的主要依据,因男女失败风险相似。

局限性

  • 本Meta分析为系统综述与Meta分析,证据等级为4级,纳入研究以观察性研究为主。
  • QT移植物样本量较小(544例),随访时间较短(平均41.6个月),其失败率的置信区间较宽。
  • 原文指出需更大样本的随机对照试验以确定QT与BPTB在该人群中的比较效果。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) is being increasingly performed in part because of higher injury rates among young athletes (≤25 years). High allograft failure rates support the use of autograft for ACLR in young patients. However, data examining the failure rates of the different autografts used in this population are lacking. PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to compare graft failure rates among bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB), hamstring tendon (HT), and quadriceps tendon (QT) autografts in patients ≤25 years old. The secondary aim was to stratify graft failure by potential modifiers, including sex, mean follow-up, time to graft rupture, and concomitant meniscal surgery. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: Studies were included that reported anterior cruciate ligament graft (BPTB, HT, QT) reinjury rates in patients ≤25 years old with a minimum 24 months of follow-up. Studies were excluded if they examined revision ACLR, allograft ACLR, allograft augmentation ACLR, or concomitant lateral extra-articular tenodesis or if they failed to report reinjury rates by graft type and young age (≤25 years). RESULTS: This review included 46 studies comprising 10,624 patients (HT: n = 6090, 47.0% female, 54.5-month mean follow-up; BPTB: n = 3990, 63.0% female, 63.6-month mean follow-up; QT: n = 544, 40.3% female, 41.6-month mean follow-up). HT exhibited the highest failure rate at 11.1% (95% CI, 8.8%-13.9%). Failure rates for BPTB and QT were 5.1% (95% CI, 3.5%-7.2%) and 2.5% (95% CI, 0.5%-11.2%), respectively. HT had a significantly higher failure rate than BPTB (Q = 13.1; P < .001). There were no significant differences in failure rates between HT and QT (Q = 3.7; P = .06) or between BPTB and QT (Q = 0.8; P = .4). Males and females had a similar risk of graft failure regardless of graft type. CONCLUSION: The results of this meta-analysis suggest that HT grafts are not the optimal choice for young patients undergoing ACLR. Instead, these patients should consider BPTB to reduce the risk of graft failure. Further research including randomized controlled trials with larger sample sizes are required to determine how QT grafts compare with BPTB grafts in this population.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Petit CB, Hussain ZB, Read PJ, et al. Graft Failure Rates in Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone, Hamstring, and Quadriceps Tendon Autografts in Patients Younger Than 25 Years: A Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2026. PMID: 41733021. doi:10.1177/03635465261415842

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。