吸烟与TLIF联合后外侧腰椎融合术后CT评估的影像学融合无关:基于CT的回顾性队列研究
该回顾性队列研究纳入322例接受TLIF联合后外侧融合的退变性腰椎疾病患者,通过薄层CT评估融合。吸烟者与非吸烟者CT定义的融合率分别为65%和66%(OR 0.98,95%CI 0.55-1.74,p=0.52),吸烟包年数与融合质量或 cage 沉降无关。女性TLIF Grade 3融合率更高(87% vs 64%,p<0.001),且Grade 1沉降比例更高(模型p=0.03)。
要点
- 吸烟未降低TLIF联合后外侧融合术后CT定义的融合率(65% vs 66%,OR 0.98,p=0.52)。
- 吸烟包年数与融合质量或cage沉降无关联。
- 女性TLIF Grade 3融合率更高(87% vs 64%,p<0.001),Grade 1沉降比例更高(模型p=0.03)。
核心结论
- 在标准化技术下,吸烟与TLIF联合后外侧融合术后影像学融合受损无关。
- 生物学愈合能力、骨质量和构造相关变量可能比吸烟更能影响CT定义的融合。
- 仅吸烟本身不应作为延迟或拒绝手术的理由,但戒烟咨询仍重要。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心私人医院一位外科医生2013至2017年连续360例TLIF联合后外侧融合的退变性腰椎疾病患者。
- 最终队列322例,其中吸烟者63例(65%完成薄层CT),非吸烟者259例(95%完成薄层CT)。
- 吸烟暴露以包年数分类(阈值25包年)和连续变量分析,调整年龄、BMI和诊断。
- 样本提供80%把握度检测约17个百分点的融合率绝对差异(α=0.05,β=0.20)。
- 证据等级为III级治疗性研究。
主要发现
- 吸烟者与非吸烟者CT定义融合率分别为65%(41/63)和66%(170/259),OR 0.98(95%CI 0.55-1.74),p=0.52。
- TLIF和椎间横突融合等级分布在吸烟者与非吸烟者间无差异。
- 包年数与融合质量(TLIF或椎间横突)或cage沉降无关。
- 女性TLIF Grade 3融合率87%(132/151)高于男性64%(110/171),p<0.001。
- 女性椎间横突Grade 3融合率69%(104/151)高于男性44%(75/171),p<0.001;Grade 1沉降比例83%(125/151) vs 70%(120/171),观察p=0.08,模型p=0.03。
关键数值与推荐
- 融合评估采用薄层CT(术后至少6个月),分别评估TLIF和椎间横突床,采用严格融合定义。
- 吸烟暴露分类阈值25包年,并作为连续变量纳入调整模型。
- 融合等级作为有序结局比较分布,调整年龄、BMI和诊断。
临床怎么用
- 在标准化TLIF联合后外侧融合技术下,吸烟不应单独作为拒绝或延迟手术的理由,需综合评估其他围手术期风险。
- 戒烟咨询仍应进行,以改善整体健康和减少非融合相关并发症。
- 女性患者可能获得更高的融合等级但cage沉降风险需关注。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计。
- 仅评估影像学结局,不涉及围手术期并发症。
- 结果可能不适用于强制术前戒烟或采用不同围手术期方案的机构。
- 吸烟者CT随访完成率65%低于非吸烟者95%,可能存在选择偏倚。
- 样本量仅能检测约17个百分点的融合率差异,较小差异可能未检出。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Smoking is widely regarded as a risk factor for impaired spinal fusion, particularly in posterolateral fusion, and prior studies have generally relied on plain radiographs for assessment. However, data evaluating the association of smoking on transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion (TLIF) with adjunctive posterolateral arthrodesis using modern CT-based evaluation remain limited. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Is cigarette smoking associated with a reduced likelihood of achieving radiographic spinal fusion, as assessed by thin-slice CT, after TLIF with adjunctive posterolateral arthrodesis? (2) Does the quality of TLIF (interbody) and posterolateral (intertransverse) fusion differ between patients who smoked and those who did not? (3) Does smoking intensity, measured in pack-years, correlate with reduced fusion quality or increased odds of cage subsidence? (4) Are patient-related factors such as gender, age, and BMI associated with differences in fusion quality or cage subsidence? METHODS: Between 2013 and 2017, one surgeon at a single private hospital performed 360 TLIF procedures with adjunctive posterolateral fusion for degenerative lumbar disease. During this period, surgery was offered to patients who smoked after individual assessment of overall surgical risk, including medical stability and ability to adhere to follow-up recommendations. Of these 360 patients, 18% (63) smoked cigarettes and 82% (297) did not. Smoking exposure was summarized in pack-years and was analyzed both categorically, using a threshold of 25 pack-years, and as a continuous variable in the adjusted models. Among patients who smoked cigarettes, 65% (41 of 63) had thin-slice CT scans obtained at least 6 months after surgery (which is sufficient for assessing early fusion maturation); among patients who did not smoke, 95% (281 of 297) met the imaging requirement, resulting in a final cohort of 322 patients. Patients who smoked cigarettes and those who did not did not differ in age, BMI, and diagnosis, and these variables were included in the adjusted analysis. Fusion was assessed on thin-slice CT and evaluated separately for the TLIF and posterolateral beds. We compared fusion percentages and grades between patients who smoked cigarettes and those who did not, assessed the association of smoking intensity with fusion measures, and examined associations with age, gender, and BMI. To address our first question, we compared the likelihood of achieving fusion between patients who smoked cigarettes and those who did not using thin-slice CT as the reference standard and applying a strict definition of fusion for both the TLIF and intertransverse beds. To address our second question, we compared the distribution of TLIF and intertransverse fusion grades between patients who smoked and those who did not, treating the grading scales as ordinal outcomes. For our third question, smoking exposure was quantified in pack-years. For our fourth question, we examined whether age, gender, and BMI were associated with fusion grades or cage subsidence, and we included these variables in the adjusted models to evaluate their independent associations. The available sample included 63 patients who smoked cigarettes and 259 who did not. With alpha set at 0.05 and beta at 0.20, this sample provided 80% power to detect an absolute difference of approximately 17 percentage points in the likelihood of achieving fusion; smaller differences may not have been detected. RESULTS: Cigarette smoking was not associated with a lower likelihood of achieving CT-defined fusion after TLIF with posterolateral arthrodesis (patients who smoked cigarettes 65% [41 of 63] versus those who did not 66% [170 of 259], OR 0.98 [95% confidence interval 0.55 to 1.74]; p = 0.52). TLIF (interbody) and posterolateral (intertransverse) fusion grade distributions did not differ between patients who smoked cigarettes and those who did not. Smoking exposure measured by pack-years was not associated with fusion quality (TLIF or intertransverse) or with cage subsidence. Women were more likely to achieve TLIF Grade 3 fusion (87% [132 of 151] versus 64% [110 of 171]; p < 0.001) and more frequent intertransverse Grade 3 fusion (69% [104 of 151] versus 44% [75 of 171]; p < 0.001) and had a higher proportion of Grade 1 subsidence (83% [125 of 151] versus 70% [120 of 171]; observed p = 0.08; model p = 0.03). Age and BMI showed no associations with fusion or subsidence. CONCLUSION: We found that cigarette smoking was not associated with impaired radiographic fusion after TLIF with adjunctive posterolateral arthrodesis performed using a standardized technique. Under these conditions, factors such as biologic healing capacity, bone quality, and construct-related variables may be more influential determinants of CT-defined fusion. These findings address radiographic outcomes only and do not speak to perioperative complications; generalizability may be limited in settings that mandate preoperative cessation or use different perioperative protocols. Within the limits of a retrospective study, these findings suggest that if TLIF with adjunctive posterolateral fusion is otherwise indicated, ongoing smoking alone should not require delaying or denying surgery, when other perioperative risks are acceptable. Smoking cessation counseling remains important for general health and for reducing nonfusion-related complications, but concerns about impaired fusion alone should not be the primary reason to withhold this procedure. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Ohana N, Benharroch D, Abu-Gameh A, et al. Cigarette Smoking Was Not Associated With Lower Odds of Radiographic Fusion After Combined TLIF and Posterolateral Lumbar (270°) Arthrodesis: A CT-based Retrospective Cohort Evaluation. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2026. PMID: 41677169. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003844
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。