建立肩袖修复最小临床重要差异、实质临床获益和患者可接受症状状态阈值最佳值的新方法学
该系统综述纳入2000年1月1日至2022年5月31日发表的41项报告肩袖修复术后最小临床重要差异(MCID)、实质临床获益(SCB)和患者可接受症状状态(PASS)阈值的研究,提出优先采用锚定问题、受试者工作特征(ROC)分析和多选项锚定问题计算阈值的方法学框架,并为至少4项研究报告的阈值给出推荐值。
要点
- 该系统综述推荐肩袖修复的MCID阈值:美国肩肘外科医师(ASES)评分21、疼痛视觉模拟量表(VAS)1.5、单次评估数值评价(SANE)12、加州大学洛杉矶分校肩关节评分6、Constant-Murley评分5.5。
- 该系统综述推荐肩袖修复的SCB阈值:ASES评分26、SANE评分20;推荐PASS阈值:ASES评分78、疼痛VAS 1.7、SANE评分71、Constant-Murley评分23.3。
- 该系统综述建议未来研究收集术前和术后12个月的患者报告结局测量数据,锚定问题应涉及手术总体满意度并提供多个具体答案选项,阈值应通过ROC分析并与均值标准误或最小可检测变化比较以确保统计学显著性。
核心结论
- 标准化的肩袖修复MCID、SCB和PASS阈值具有巨大潜力,可推动未来比较研究、指导报销政策并辅助患者决策。
- 未来关于新型MCID、SCB和PASS阈值的研究应收集术前和术后12个月的患者报告结局测量数据。
- 锚定问题应涉及手术总体满意度并提供多个具体答案选项,数据应通过ROC分析进行关联,阈值应与均值标准误或最小可检测变化比较以确保统计学显著性。
研究设计与样本
- 该系统综述通过系统检索提取2000年1月1日至2022年5月31日发表的报告肩袖修复术后MCID、SCB和PASS阈值的研究。
- 共纳入41项研究,证据等级为3级。
- 收集的数据包括随访时长和患者失访情况、报告的阈值以及阈值计算相关数据(方法、锚定问题及回答、曲线下面积和置信区间)。
主要发现
- 41项研究中,37项(90%)报告MCID阈值,11项(27%)报告SCB阈值,16项(39%)报告PASS阈值。
- 12项研究使用基于锚定的方法计算阈值,6项研究通过基于分布的方法计算阈值。
- 作者优先选择使用锚定问题计算的值而非未使用锚定问题的值,优先选择ROC分析计算的值而非均值变化和逻辑回归计算的值,优先选择具有多个回答选项的锚定问题而非二元回答选项的锚定问题。
关键数值与推荐
- MCID推荐值:ASES评分21、疼痛VAS 1.5、SANE评分12、加州大学洛杉矶分校肩关节评分6、Constant-Murley评分5.5。
- SCB推荐值:ASES评分26、SANE评分20。
- PASS推荐值:ASES评分78、疼痛VAS 1.7、SANE评分71、Constant-Murley评分23.3。
- 作者为至少4项研究报告的每个阈值给出推荐。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The heterogeneity of threshold values for the minimal clinically important difference (MCID), substantial clinical benefit (SCB), and Patient Acceptable Symptom State (PASS) as reported in the rotator cuff repair literature undermines the utility of these concepts. This systematic review identifies studies with published threshold values and proposes a methodologic framework for determining which values should be used for rotator cuff repair moving forward. PURPOSE: To provide recommendations for the MCID, SCB, and PASS thresholds of commonly utilized patient-reported outcome measures for rotator cuff repair, as well as recommendations for how these thresholds should be calculated moving forward. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic review; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: All studies reporting MCID, SCB, and PASS threshold values after rotator cuff repair published between January 1, 2000, and May 31, 2022, were extracted via systematic review. The following data were collected: follow-up duration and patient attrition; reported threshold values; and data relevant to threshold calculation, including method, anchor questions and responses, area under the curve, and confidence intervals. The authors prioritized values calculated with an anchor question over those calculated without one, values from receiver operator characteristic analysis over those from mean change and logistic regression, and anchor questions with multiple response options over those with binary response options. RESULTS: In total, 41 studies were included in the systematic review: 37 (90%), 11 (27%), and 16 (39%) reported MCID, SCB, and PASS thresholds, respectively. In addition, 12 studies calculated threshold values using anchor-based methods, and 6 calculated threshold values through distribution-based methods. The authors made recommendations for each threshold reported by at least 4 studies: for MCID, American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) = 21, visual analog scale for pain = 1.5, single assessment numeric evaluation (SANE) = 12, University of California at Los Angeles shoulder score = 6, and Constant-Murley score = 5.5; for SCB, ASES = 26 and SANE = 20; and for PASS, ASES = 78, visual analog scale for pain = 1.7, SANE = 71, and Constant-Murley score = 23.3. CONCLUSION: With standardized MCID, SCB, and PASS threshold values for rotator cuff repair surgery, these concepts hold enormous potential to power future comparative studies, guide reimbursement policy, and aid patient decision-making. Future research on novel MCID, SCB, and PASS threshold values should collect preoperative and 12-month postoperative patient-reported outcome measure data. Anchor questions should pertain to overall satisfaction with surgery and have multiple specific answer choices. These data should be correlated by receiver operator characteristic analysis, and any threshold values should then be compared with the standard error of the mean or minimal detectable change to ensure statistical significance.
引用
- Lee AC, Chiang J, Li X, et al. A Novel Methodology for Establishing Best Values for MCID, SCB, and PASS Thresholds for Rotator Cuff Repair. Am J Sports Med. 2026. PMID: 41502123. doi:10.1177/03635465251380288
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。