半月板同种异体移植术后患者报告结局变化及非失败再手术的预测因素:系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析纳入154项研究、11413例患者和11548个移植半月板,评估半月板同种异体移植术(MAT)后Lysholm评分变化(ΔLysholm)及非失败再手术的预测因素。Meta分析未发现与ΔLysholm差异显著相关的预后因素;外侧MAT较内侧MAT的非失败再手术风险更高(ln[RR] -0.74,95%CI -1.37至-0.108,P=0.022)。多变量回归显示,半月板切除至MAT间隔较短(P=0.007)和年龄较大(P=0.02)预测队列ΔLysholm评分较差;损伤至MAT间隔较长(P=0.039)及内侧MAT采用骨桥固定相较骨栓固定(P<0.001)预测非失败再手术风险更高。
要点
- 外侧MAT较内侧MAT的非失败再手术风险更高(ln[RR] -0.74,95%CI -1.37至-0.108,P=0.022)。
- 半月板切除至MAT间隔较短(P=0.007)和年龄较大(P=0.02)预测ΔLysholm评分较差。
- 损伤至MAT间隔较长(P=0.039)及内侧MAT骨桥固定相较骨栓固定(P<0.001)预测再手术风险更高。
核心结论
- 外侧MAT是非失败再手术的显著危险因素。
- 年龄较大和半月板切除至MAT间隔较短与较差的ΔLysholm评分显著相关。
- 半月板损伤至MAT间隔较长及内侧MAT采用骨桥固定相较骨栓固定与更高的再手术风险显著相关。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,证据等级4。
- 系统检索Ovid Medline、Embase、Scopus和Clinicaltrials.gov数据库中关于MAT后临床结局的研究。
- 从2347条筛选标题中纳入154项符合标准的研究,共11413例患者和11548个移植半月板。
- 主要结局为ΔLysholm评分和非失败再手术;非失败再手术定义为初次MAT后旨在改善膝关节功能的任何非失败半月板相关手术;失败定义为转为全膝/单髁膝关节置换、全半月板或次全半月板切除/移植物取出或翻修MAT。
- 采用Meta分析或加权线性回归分析预测因素与结局的关系,显著因素纳入多变量Meta回归。
主要发现
- 估计合并ΔLysholm评分为24.2(SD 6.08)。
- 非失败再手术发生率为3.36%(SD 7.46%)。
- Meta分析未发现任何预后因素与ΔLysholm评分差异显著相关。
- 外侧MAT较内侧MAT的非失败再手术风险更高(ln[RR] -0.74,95%CI -1.37至-0.108,P=0.022)。
- 多变量回归显示,半月板切除至MAT间隔较短(P=0.007)和年龄较大(P=0.02)预测队列ΔLysholm评分较差;损伤至MAT间隔较长(P=0.039)及内侧MAT骨桥固定相较骨栓固定(P<0.001)预测非失败再手术风险更高。
关键数值与推荐
- 非失败再手术定义为初次MAT后旨在改善膝关节功能的任何非失败半月板相关手术。
- 失败定义为转为全膝/单髁膝关节置换、全半月板或次全半月板切除/移植物取出或翻修MAT。
- 外侧MAT较内侧MAT非失败再手术风险:ln[RR] -0.74(95%CI -1.37至-0.108,P=0.022)。
- 半月板切除至MAT间隔较短预测较差ΔLysholm评分(P=0.007),年龄较大预测较差ΔLysholm评分(P=0.02)。
- 损伤至MAT间隔较长(P=0.039)及内侧MAT骨桥固定相较骨栓固定(P<0.001)预测非失败再手术风险更高。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Meniscal allograft transplantation (MAT) has been established as a safe, effective treatment for meniscal deficiency. However, questions remain regarding pre- and perioperative factors that affect MAT outcomes. PURPOSE: To assess predictive factors for preoperative to postoperative change in Lysholm score (ΔLysholm) and nonfailure reoperations after MAT. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: The Ovid Medline, Embase, Scopus, and Clinicaltrials.gov databases were systematically searched for studies investigating clinical outcomes after MAT, including Lysholm scores, failure, complications, or reoperations. Study characteristics, predictive factors, and outcomes were extracted. The primary outcomes included ΔLysholm scores and nonfailure reoperations. Nonfailure reoperation was defined as any nonfailure meniscus-related procedure after primary MAT aiming to improve knee function. Failure was defined as conversion to total/unilateral knee arthroplasty, total or subtotal meniscectomy/allograft removal, or revision MAT. Relationships between predictive factors and outcomes were analyzed by meta-analysis or by weighted linear regression. Significant factors were included in a multivariable meta-regression. RESULTS: Of 2347 screened titles, 154 met inclusion criteria. A total of 11,413 patients and 11,548 transplanted menisci were identified. The estimated pooled ΔLysholm score was 24.2 (SD, 6.08), and the nonfailure reoperation incidence rate was 3.36% (SD, 7.46%). No prognostic factors were significantly associated with differing ΔLysholm scores from meta-analysis. Lateral MATs had greater risk of nonfailure reoperation than medial MATs (ln[RR], -0.74; 95% CI, -1.37 to -0.108; P = .022). From multivariable regression, shorter time between meniscectomy and MAT (P = .007) and older age (P = .02) predicted less favorable cohort ΔLysholm scores. Longer intervals between injury and MAT (P = .039) and bone-bridge graft fixation for medial MAT compared with bone-plug fixation (P < .001) predicted higher risk of nonfailure reoperation. CONCLUSION: This systematic review and meta-analysis identified lateral MAT as a significant risk factor for nonfailure reoperation. Older age and shorter time interval between meniscectomy and MAT were significantly associated with less favorable ΔLysholm scores. A longer meniscal injury-MAT time interval and bone-bridge compared with bone-plug fixation technique for medial MAT were significantly associated with higher reoperation risk.
引用
- Haider AA, Fulkerson DE, Boghosian T, et al. Predictive Factors for Change in Patient-Reported Outcome Measures and Nonfailure Reoperations After Meniscal Allograft Transplantation: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2026. PMID: 41502119. doi:10.1177/03635465251383058
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。