成人舟骨腰部骨折早期手术固定与石膏制动的放射学结局:舟骨腰部骨折内固定试验五年随访
本研究为SWIFFT试验的五年随访,评估成人舟骨腰部骨折早期手术固定与石膏制动两种治疗的放射学结局(骨愈合与骨关节炎发生)。439例随机患者中267例(60.8%)在五年时提供影像,两组完全愈合比例及骨关节炎患病率、严重程度相似;骨关节炎更重者PRWE评分更差。
要点
- 五年时182例(68.2%)完全愈合(手术固定92例、石膏制动90例),7例骨不连(2.6%;手术固定3例、石膏制动4例)。
- 一年时至少20%愈合的骨折随时间推移无需干预而巩固愈合。
- 五年时140例(占提供影像者的52.4%)至少一个关节发生骨关节炎,两组患病率相似。
核心结论
- 随机化后1至5年间,桥接愈合超过20%的骨折无需干预即巩固愈合。
- 两种治疗在五年时完全愈合、几乎完全愈合、部分愈合、轻微愈合及骨不连的比例保持相似。
- 五年间骨关节炎患病率和严重程度增加,但两组相似。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为SWIFFT试验的五年随访放射学评估。
- 邀请随机化后五年时仍在试验中的患者行患腕X线平片和CT扫描及对侧腕后前位X线片。
- 影像由三名观察者独立评估骨折愈合及骨关节炎分布与严重程度,分析遵循预先设定的统计分析计划。
- 评估骨关节炎与五年时患者腕部评价(PRWE)评分的关系。
主要发现
- 439例随机患者中267例(60.8%)在五年时提供影像,其特征与原始队列相似。
- 182例(68.2%)完全愈合(手术固定92例、石膏制动90例),7例骨不连(2.6%;手术固定3例、石膏制动4例)。
- 一年时至少20%愈合的骨折随时间推移无需干预而巩固。
- 两组从基线至五年舟骨周围关节均见骨关节炎进展;五年时140例(占五年时有影像者的52.4%)至少一个关节发生骨关节炎,两组患病率相似。
- 两组骨关节炎患病率、受累关节数目及最大严重程度相似;439例初始队列中344例(78.4%)提供五年时有效PRWE评分,骨关节炎更严重者平均评分更高,提示疼痛与功能更差。
关键数值与推荐
- 完全愈合:手术固定组92例 vs 石膏制动组90例(合计182例,68.2%)。
- 骨不连:手术固定组3例 vs 石膏制动组4例(合计7例,2.6%)。
- 五年时至少一个关节骨关节炎:140例(占五年时有影像者的52.4%),两组患病率相似。
- 五年时提供有效PRWE评分:344/439例(78.4%)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 439例随机患者中仅267例(60.8%)在五年时提供影像。
- 439例初始队列中仅344例(78.4%)提供五年时有效PRWE评分。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: In the Scaphoid Waist Internal Fixation for Fractures Trial (SWIFFT), surgical fixation was compared with cast immobilization, with the primary endpoint being the outcomes at one year. The aim of the current study was to assess the radiological outcomes (union and the development of osteoarthritis (OA)) of the two forms of treatment at five years. METHODS: Patients who remained in the trial at five years after randomization were invited to have plain radiographs and a CT scan of the injured wrist, and a posterior-anterior radiograph of the contralateral wrist. This imaging was reviewed by three observers independently for union of the fracture and the distribution and severity of OA. This analysis followed a pre-specified statistical analysis plan. The relationship between OA and the Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation (PRWE) scores at five years was assessed. RESULTS: Of the 439 patients who were randomized, 267 (60.8%) provided imaging at five years. Their characteristics were similar to those of the original cohort. A total of 182 patients (68.2%) (n = 92 fixation, n = 90 cast) had complete union and seven had a nonunion (2.6%; n = 3 fixation, n = 4 cast). Fractures with a minimum of 20% union at one year consolidated with the passage of time without intervention. Progression of OA in the joints around the scaphoid was seen in both groups from baseline to five years. By five years, 140 patients (52.4% of those with imaging at five years) had OA in at least one joint with similar prevalences in both groups. The prevalence of OA, the number of arthritic joints and the maximum severity of OA, was similar in the two groups. A total of 344 of the initial cohort of 439 patients (78.4%) provided a valid PRWE score at five years and the mean score was higher in those with more severe OA, indicating worse pain and function. CONCLUSION: Between one and five years after randomization, union consolidated in those with > 20% bridging without intervention. The proportion of patients with full, almost full, partial, slight, and nonunion for the two forms of treatment remained similar at five years. The prevalence and severity of OA increased during the five years but was similar in both groups.
引用
- Dias JJ, Brealey SD, Coleman E, et al. Radiological outcome of early surgical fixation versus cast immobilization for adults with a scaphoid waist fracture: five-year follow-up of the Scaphoid Waist Internal Fixation for Fractures Trial. Bone Joint J. 2026. PMID: 41475366. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.108B1.BJJ-2025-0125.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。