退行性全层冈上肌腱撕裂患者保守治疗失败的相关因素:一项前瞻性队列研究
这项前瞻性队列研究纳入348例接受标准化物理治疗的退行性全层冈上肌腱撕裂患者,平均随访30.5个月。77%的患者保守治疗有效,无需手术;需要手术者年龄更轻、体力劳动者比例更高、BMI更高、初始ASES与SSV评分更低、有对侧肩手术史、矢状面撕裂更大。
要点
- 77%的退行性全层冈上肌腱撕裂患者经标准化物理治疗后可避免手术。
- 需手术者年龄更轻(58.7岁 vs 64.8岁,p<0.001)、体力劳动者比例更高(62.5% vs 44.8%,p=0.008)。
- 需手术者矢状面撕裂更大(14.7 mm vs 13.5 mm,p=0.021)、初始ASES和SSV评分更低。
核心结论
- 保守治疗对77%的退行性冈上肌腱撕裂患者有效。
- 年轻患者、体力劳动者、肩部疼痛更重者及有对侧肩手术史者需要手术的风险显著增加。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性队列研究,纳入348例接受标准化物理治疗方案的退行性全层冈上肌腱撕裂患者。
- 排除年龄>75岁、创伤性或巨大撕裂、肩袖关节病、无MRI扫描或随访不足两年的患者。
- 在3、6、12个月及此后每年随访,采用ASES评分、SSV和VAS评估疼痛,治疗失败定义为需要手术。
- 根据国际关节镜、膝关节外科与骨科运动医学学会标准对MRI上的撕裂进行分级,平均随访30.5个月(SD 6.2)。
主要发现
- 最终随访时268例(77%)患者保守治疗满意而未手术,ASES评分平均改善+31.3(SD 20),SSV平均改善+35.6(SD 24),VAS平均改善-4.3(SD 2.7),均p<0.001。
- 手术组与非手术组最终结局无显著差异。
- 手术组显著更年轻(58.7岁(SD 8)vs 64.8岁(SD 6.8),p<0.001)。
- 手术组体力劳动者比例显著更高(62.5%(50/80)vs 44.8%(120/268),p=0.008)。
- 手术组BMI显著更高、初始ASES和SSV评分更低、有对侧肩手术史、矢状面撕裂显著更大(14.7 mm(SD 5)vs 13.5 mm(SD 5),p=0.021)。
关键数值与推荐
- 撕裂分级:171例(49%)为C1级,131例(38%)为C2级,46例(13%)为C3级。
- 162例(46.6%)合并部分冈下肌腱撕裂,243例(69.8%)肩胛下肌腱受累(Lafosse I至II级)。
- 平均年龄63.4岁(SD 7.6),女性230例(66.1%),优势侧受累234例(67%),体力劳动者170例(49%)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: The conservative treatment of degenerative full-thickness supraspinatus tears yields satisfactory results in most patients. However, identifying those likely to require surgery remains difficult. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of conservative treatment and identify the characteristics of the patient or the size of the tear which are associated with treatment failure. METHODS: This prospective study included patients with degenerative full-thickness supraspinatus tears treated with a standardized physiotherapy protocol. Exclusion criteria were patients aged > 75 years, those with traumatic or massive tears, cuff arthropathy, those without MRI scans, or with < two years of follow-up. The patients were reviewed at three, six and 12 months and annually thereafter. Outcomes were assessed using the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) score, Subjective Shoulder Value (SSV), and pain using a visual analogue scale (VAS). Failure of treatment was defined as the need for surgery. The tears were classified from MRI scans according to the International Society of Arthroscopy, Knee Surgery and Orthopaedic Sports Medicine criteria. The mean follow-up was 30.5 months (SD 6.2). The study included 348 patients with a mean age of 63.4 years (SD 7.6); 230 (66.1%) were female, the dominant side was affected in 234 (67%), and 170 (49%) were manual workers. A total of 171 tears (49%) were grade C1, 131 (38%) were C2, and 46 (13%) were C3. Partial infraspinatus tears occurred in 162 (46.6%) and 243 (69.8%) had subscapularis involvement (Lafosse I to II). RESULTS: At the final follow-up, 268 patients (77%) had a satisfactory outcome without surgery. Mean improvements were: ASES +31.3 (SD 20); SSV +35.6 (SD 24); and VAS -4.3 (SD 2.7) (all p < 0.001). There were no significant differences in final outcomes between those who had surgery and those who did not. The surgical group were significantly younger (58.7 years (SD 8) vs 64.8 years (SD 6.8); p < 0.001), significantly more likely to be manual workers (62.5% (50/80) vs 44.8% (120/268); p = 0.008), had significantly higher BMI, lower initial ASES and SSV scores, previous contralateral shoulder surgery, and significantly larger sagittal tears (14.7 mm (SD 5) vs 13.5 mm (SD 5); p = 0.021). CONCLUSION: Conservative treatment was effective in 77% of patients with a degenerative supraspinatus tear. Younger patients, manual workers, those with more painful shoulders, and those with a history of previous surgery in the contralateral shoulder were at a significantly increased risk of requiring surgery.
引用
- Martinez-Catalan N, Gabardo-Calvo S, Valencia M, et al. Factors associated with failed conservative treatment in patients with degenerative full-thickness supraspinatus tears : a prospective cohort study. Bone Joint J. 2025. PMID: 41319708. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.107B12.BJJ-2025-0742.R2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。