标准手术台直接前入路全髋关节置换的框架式铺巾技术:高效且安全?
该回顾性比较队列研究描述了一种用于标准手术台直接前入路(DAA)全髋关节置换(THA)的新型框架式水平一体式铺巾技术,并评估其效率与安全性。结果显示框架式技术较传统袜套式技术缩短了铺巾时间与手术时间,且5年翻修率(包括假体周围感染翻修率)不高于全国其他技术基准。
要点
- 框架式DAA铺巾技术的中位铺巾时间为37分钟,短于传统袜套式技术的47分钟。
- 框架式技术的中位手术时间为63分钟,短于传统袜套式技术的72分钟。
- 框架式技术5年假体周围感染翻修率为0.43%,低于全国其他技术基准的0.94%。
核心结论
- 框架式铺巾技术用于标准手术台DAA THA简单、高效且安全。
- 与传统袜套式方法相比,框架式一体式铺巾缩短铺巾时间并消除腿过度伸展时污染风险。
- 与其他DAA THA技术相比,框架式技术未伴随更高的翻修率,尤其是假体周围感染方面。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性比较队列研究,描述框架式DAA THA技术并评估其效率与安全性。
- 效率评估使用2008年1月至2013年12月由单一位外科医生连续实施的单侧DAA THA的医院数据。
- 对照组387例采用传统袜套式技术(43%[167]男性;年龄73±10岁;64%[246]非骨水泥),干预组385例采用框架式技术(49%[188]男性;年龄70±10岁;89%[342]非骨水泥)。
- 安全性评估使用强制性瑞士国家关节登记处(SIRIS,覆盖瑞士全部THA的98%)的5年翻修率及翻修原因,包括在其他医院行翻修的患者。
- 比较本机构9973例DAA THA(框架式技术46%[4612]男性;年龄67±11岁;BMI 26 kg/m²±5;98%[9799]非骨水泥)与2014年1月至2024年12月全国88443例DAA THA(其他任何技术48%[42607]男性;年龄69±11岁;BMI 27±5 kg/m²;86%[75649]非骨水泥),两组ASA分级和适应证可比。
主要发现
- 框架式DAA THA技术中位铺巾时间(IQR)为37分钟(30至47),传统袜套式技术为47分钟(39至57),p<0.001。
- 框架式DAA THA技术中位手术时间(IQR)为63分钟(56至75),传统袜套式技术为72分钟(63.0至81.5),p<0.001。
- 与全国其他技术DAA THA基准相比,框架式技术5年假体周围感染翻修率为0.43%(16/3651)[95%CI 0.31%至0.60%],全国基准为0.94%(292/31070)[95%CI 0.88%至1.02%]。
- 框架式技术5年总体翻修率为1.34%(49/3651)[95%CI 1.10%至1.62%],全国基准为3.52%(1094/31070)[95%CI 3.39%至3.67%],两项比较p<0.001。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为框架式铺巾技术用于标准手术台DAA THA简单、高效且安全。
- 作者指出与传统袜套式方法相比,框架式一体式铺巾缩短铺巾时间并消除腿过度伸展时污染风险。
- 作者指出与其他DAA THA技术相比,框架式技术未伴随更高的翻修率,尤其是假体周围感染方面。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Performing a direct anterior approach (DAA) for THA without the use of a traction table requires precise leg manipulation and exposure. We developed a novel frame-based horizontal one-piece drape with an impermeable cover enabling repeated leg hyperextension while maintaining sterility. However, the efficiency and revision risks of this frame-based DAA for THA on a standard table remain unevaluated, which may concern surgeons who are considering the technique. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Does the frame-based DAA for THA technique require less time for setup and surgery than the traditional stockinette-based technique with its multipiece cover? (2) Is the frame-based DAA for THA technique associated with a higher infection revision rate or overall revision rate compared with other institutions as measured in the national joint registry? METHODS: This retrospective, comparative cohort study described the frame-based DAA for THA technique and evaluated its efficiency and safety. Efficiency was assessed as operative setup time and surgery duration using hospital data from consecutive unilateral DAA THAs performed by a single surgeon between January 2008 and December 2013. The control group included 387 patients (43% [167] male; mean ± SD age 73 ± 10 years; 64% [246] uncemented) using the traditional stockinette-based technique, while the intervention group comprised 385 patients (49% [188] male; age 70 ± 10 years; 89% [342] uncemented) using the frame-based technique. Safety was evaluated as 5-year revision rates and reason for revision from the mandatory Swiss National Joint Registry (SIRIS, covering 98% of all THAs in Switzerland), which also included patients who underwent revision at a different hospital than where the primary THA was performed. We compared 9973 DAA THAs performed at our institution (frame-based technique 46% [4612] male; age 67 ± 11 years; BMI 26 kg/m 2 ± 5; 98% [9799] cementless) with 88,443 DAA THAs performed nationwide (any other technique 48% [42,607] male; age 69 ± 11 years; BMI 27 ± 5 kg/m 2 ; 86% [75,649] cementless) between January 2014 and December 2024. The groups were comparable in terms of ASA classification and indication. RESULTS: The frame-based DAA for THA technique had a shorter median (IQR) setup time (37 minutes [30 to 47] versus 47 minutes [39 to 57]; p < 0.001) and a shorter median (IQR) surgery duration (63 minutes [56 to 75] versus 72 minutes [63.0 to 81.5]; p < 0.001) compared with the stockinette-based DAA for THA technique. When compared with the national benchmark for DAA THAs performed using other techniques, the frame-based technique demonstrated a lower 5-year revision rate for periprosthetic joint infection (PJI) (0.43% [16 of 3651] [95% confidence interval (CI) 0.31% to 0.60%] versus 0.94% [292 of 31,070] [95% CI 0.88% to 1.02%]) and a lower overall 5-year revision rate (1.34% [49 of 3651] [95% CI 1.10% to 1.62%] versus 3.52% [1094 of 31,070] [95% CI 3.39% to 3.67%]; p < 0.001 for both comparisons). CONCLUSION: The frame-based draping technique for DAA THAs on a standard table is simple, efficient, and safe. Compared with the traditional stockinette-based method, the frame-based technique with its one-piece drape shortens setup time and eliminates the risk of contamination when lowering the legs into hyperextension. Compared with other DAA for THA techniques, it is not associated with higher revision rates, particularly regarding PJI. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Aepli M, Carli A, Mündermann A, et al. Frame-based Draping Technique for Standard Table Direct Anterior Approach THA: Efficient and Safe? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 41329519. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003789
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。