基于有意义改善金标准比较,全膝关节置换术实质性临床获益估计的效度较弱
本研究比较全膝关节置换术实质性临床获益(SCB)估计与外部验证的有意义改善金标准的效度,使用KASTPain无效应随机临床试验和骨关节炎倡议(OAI)两个数据集,共纳入OAI的396名参与者和KASTPain的384名参与者,发现SCB估计的效度证据较弱,尤其对未达到SCB的参与者亚组。
要点
- 与金标准相比,KASTPain中达到或超过SCB的参与者一般可确认结局良好,但变化分数低于SCB者不能确认结局不良。
- OAI数据集中SCB估计的诊断效度较弱。
- 潜类别分析(Latent Class Analysis)估计的效度得到支持。
核心结论
- 研究发现SCB估计的效度证据较弱,尤其对未达到SCB的参与者亚组。
- 未来工作应探索在多个中心获得的基线四分位数调整SCB估计的效度。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用两个数据集:全膝关节置换术疼痛应对技能训练(KASTPain)无效应随机临床试验和骨关节炎倡议(OAI)中接受全膝关节置换术患者的数据。
- 两项研究均采集术前和多次术后的西安大略和麦克马斯特大学骨关节炎指数身体功能评分。
- OAI共纳入396名参与者,KASTPain共纳入384名参与者。
- 证据等级为1级诊断试验研究。
主要发现
- 与金标准相比,KASTPain中达到或超过SCB的参与者一般可确认结局良好,而低于SCB的变化分数不能确认结局不良。
- OAI中SCB估计的诊断效度较弱。
- 潜类别分析(Latent Class Analysis)估计的效度得到支持。
局限性
- SCB估计的效度证据较弱,尤其对未达到SCB的参与者亚组。
- 未来工作应探索在多个中心获得的基线四分位数调整SCB估计的效度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Estimates of the substantial clinical benefit (SCB) for knee arthroplasty have been endorsed by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services but have not been validated. We examined validity by comparing SCB estimates to an externally validated gold standard of meaningful improvement. METHODS: There were two datasets, the Knee Arthroplasty pain coping Skills Training (KASTPain) no-effect randomized clinical trial and the Osteoarthritis Initiative (OAI) data on patients who had a knee arthroplasty. Both studies captured preoperative and multiple postoperative Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index Physical Function scores. A total of 396 participants were included from the OAI, and 384 participants were from KASTPain. RESULTS: The validity of Latent Class Analysis estimates was supported. Compared to the gold standard, KASTPain participants meeting/exceeding the SCB generally ruled in a good outcome, while change scores less than the SCB did not rule in a poor outcome. The diagnostic validity of SCB estimates in OAI was weak. CONCLUSIONS: We found evidence of weak validity for SCB estimates, particularly for the subset of participants not meeting the SCB. Future work should explore the validity of baseline quartile-adjusted SCB estimates obtained at multiple sites. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level 1 Diagnostic test study.
引用
- Riddle DL, Dumenci L. Validity of Substantial Clinical Benefit Estimates in Knee Arthroplasty Is Weak Based on Comparisons to a Gold Standard of Meaningful Improvement. J Arthroplasty. 2025. PMID: 41232850. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2025.11.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。