全膝关节置换术手术入路对活动度、患者报告结局指标及再手术率的影响:随机对照试验的系统综述
该系统综述检索2010年1月1日至2024年12月31日PubMed与Embase数据库,纳入27篇随机对照试验(均为1级证据,改良Coleman评分平均74.9、范围64至89),评估不同全膝关节置换术入路对膝关节活动度、患者报告结局指标及再手术率的影响。结论为基于近期高质量随机对照试验,没有单一手术入路在活动度、患者报告结局指标及再手术率方面持续优于其他入路,但少数研究显示股内侧肌下、股内侧肌中间及迷你内侧髌旁入路具有潜在获益。
要点
- 25项评估术后活动度的随机对照试验中,18项未发现不同入路间差异。
- 26项评估患者报告结局指标的研究中,19项未发现不同入路间差异。
- 21项评估再手术率的研究中,10项两组均无再手术,4项无差异,7项报告了再手术。
核心结论
- 基于近期高质量随机对照试验,没有单一手术入路在活动度、患者报告结局指标及再手术率方面持续优于其他入路。
- 少数研究显示股内侧肌下、股内侧肌中间及迷你内侧髌旁入路具有潜在获益。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索PubMed与Embase数据库2010年1月1日至2024年12月31日发表的文献。
- 纳入标准为评估不同全膝关节置换术入路膝关节活动度、患者报告结局指标及再手术率的随机对照试验。
- 排除非英文稿件、每组患者少于30例的研究以及平均随访不足3个月的研究。
- 最终纳入27篇稿件,均为1级证据,改良Coleman评分平均74.9、范围64至89。
主要发现
- 25项评估术后膝关节活动度的随机对照试验中,3项支持股内侧肌下入路、2项支持股内侧肌中间入路、2项支持迷你内侧髌旁入路优于标准内侧髌旁入路,其余18项未发现不同入路间活动度差异。
- 26项评估患者报告结局指标的研究中,3项支持股内侧肌下入路、2项支持股内侧肌中间入路、1项支持迷你内侧髌旁入路、1项支持标准内侧髌旁入路,其余19项未发现不同入路间差异。
- 21项评估再手术率的研究中,10项两组均无再手术,4项未发现再手术率差异,7项报告了再手术情况。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入的27篇随机对照试验均为1级证据,改良Coleman评分平均74.9、范围64至89。
- 排除标准包括每组患者少于30例及平均随访不足3个月。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Various surgical approaches may be used to perform total knee arthroplasty (TKA). This systematic review assessed randomized controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating various TKA approaches and their influence on knee range of motion (ROM), patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs), and reoperation rates. METHODS: A search of PubMed and Embase databases was performed for manuscripts published between January 1, 2010, and December 31, 2024. Inclusion criteria consisted of RCTs evaluating knee ROM, PROMs, and reoperation rates of various TKA surgical approaches. Modified Coleman methodology scoring and level of evidence were assigned to each study. Non-English manuscripts, studies with fewer than 30 patients in each group, or studies with a mean follow-up of less than three months were excluded. A total of 27 manuscripts met final inclusion, and all were level 1 evidence with fair or better modified Coleman scores (mean 74.9, range 64 to 89). RESULTS: Among the 25 RCTs that evaluated postoperative knee ROM, three studies supported the subvastus approach, two supported the midvastus approach, and two supported the mini medial parapatellar (MPP) approach when compared to a standard MPP. The remaining 18 studies found no difference in ROM between surgical approaches. Various PROMs were evaluated in 26 studies. Of these, three studies favored the subvastus approach, two favored the midvastus approach, one favored the mini MPP approach, and one favored the standard MPP approach. The remaining 19 studies found no difference in PROMs. Of the 21 studies that evaluated reoperation rates, 10 studies had no reoperations in either group, four studies found no difference in reoperation rates, and seven studies reported on reoperations. CONCLUSIONS: Based on recent, high-quality RCTs, no single surgical approach consistently outperforms others regarding ROM, PROMs, and reoperation rates. However, a small number of studies demonstrated potential benefits with the subvastus, midvastus, and mini MPP approaches.
引用
- Rainey JP, Radtke LE, Gililland JM, et al. The Influence of Total Knee Arthroplasty Surgical Approach on Range of Motion, Patient-Reported Outcome Measures, and Reoperation Rates: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials. J Arthroplasty. 2025. PMID: 41240972. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2025.11.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。