文献速递小儿骨科运动医学

Garceau技术比改良Ponseti技术所需的机械功更少:一项尸体生物力学研究

Garceau Technique Requires Less Mechanical Work Than Modified Ponseti for Tibialis Anterior Tendon Transfer: A Biomechanical Study in Cadavers.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2025-10-03

该研究在10具尸体下肢标本上模拟胫骨前肌收缩,比较Garceau与改良Ponseti技术行胫骨前肌腱转移的生物力学差异。结果显示Garceau技术达到最大背屈所需的峰值力、肌腱位移和机械功均低于改良Ponseti技术。作者认为Garceau技术可能降低步态中的能量需求,但需临床步态分析研究验证其优势能否转化为更好的临床结局。

要点

  • Garceau技术达到最大背屈的峰值力低于改良Ponseti技术(27±4 N vs 37±5 N)。
  • Garceau技术的肌腱位移小于改良Ponseti技术(26±3 mm vs 33±3 mm)。
  • Garceau技术所需机械功低于改良Ponseti技术(269±47 J vs 443±76 J)。

核心结论

  • Garceau技术达到足最大背屈所需的机械功少于改良Ponseti技术,可能因为肌腱走行更直接、未形成额外的肌腱反折滑轮。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究为尸体生物力学研究,纳入10具来自10名不同供体的冷冻保存下肢(6女4男,平均年龄82±8岁)。
  • 每具标本按顺序在三种条件下重复测量:对照(原生肌腱止点,手术操作前)、改良Ponseti技术后、以及将改良Ponseti技术转换为Garceau转移后。
  • 采用Mecmesin MultiTest 2.5-d牵引系统模拟胫骨前肌收缩,记录峰值力、肌腱位移和达到最大背屈的机械功。

主要发现

  • Garceau技术达到最大背屈的峰值力低于改良Ponseti技术(改良Ponseti 37±5 N vs Garceau 27±4 N,平均差10 [95%CI 4至16];p=0.009)。
  • Garceau技术的肌腱位移小于改良Ponseti技术(改良Ponseti 33±3 mm vs Garceau 26±3 mm,平均差7 [95%CI 4至10];p<0.001)。
  • Garceau技术达到最大背屈的机械功低于改良Ponseti技术(改良Ponseti 443±76 J vs Garceau 269±47 J,平均差174 [95%CI 84至264];p=0.005)。

临床怎么用

  • 对于肌肉力量有限的患者,Garceau技术可能降低步态中的能量需求,支持其在复发性马蹄内翻足手术治疗中的考虑。

局限性

  • 需要开展比较性临床步态分析研究,量化每种转移技术术后的背屈力量、步态动力学和复发率,以确定该生物力学优势能否转化为改善的临床和功能结局。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Tibialis anterior tendon transfer is used to correct dynamic supination in patients with relapsed clubfoot. While both the Garceau and modified Ponseti techniques are clinically accepted, they differ in tendon routing: The Garceau approach follows a straighter path without additional pulley formation, whereas the modified Ponseti technique may create a secondary distal pulley that increases the force required for dorsiflexion, which could have clinical implications for patient selection. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Does the Garceau technique (1) require less force, (2) result in reduced tendon displacement, or (3) decrease the mechanical work needed to dorsiflex the foot, and if so, are differences in the resulting force-displacement curves reflected in earlier force onset, lower peak force at maximum dorsiflexion, and shorter tendon displacement to reach that end point compared with the modified Ponseti technique? METHODS: Ten cryopreserved lower limbs from 10 unique donors (6 females, 4 males; mean ± SD age 82 ± 8 years) underwent simulated tibialis anterior contraction using a linear traction device. Limbs with no visible surgical scars, hardware, deformity, or arthrodesis of the tibiotalar, subtalar, or midtarsal joints were included; specimens showing any of these features or cutaneous defects were excluded. Each specimen was evaluated in a repeated-measure design under three sequential conditions: control (native tendon insertion, prior to surgical manipulation), after modified Ponseti technique, and finally after converting the modified Ponseti technique to a Garceau transfer. To simulate tibialis anterior muscle contraction, we used a Mecmesin MultiTest 2.5-d traction system (Slinfold). Peak force, tendon displacement, and mechanical work to achieve maximum dorsiflexion (defined for each specimen as the greatest dorsiflexion attainable under linear traction before additional load produced no further change) were recorded with Grafilino Max v 1.24 software (DataMicra). Repeated-measures ANOVA with post hoc testing was used. RESULTS: The Garceau technique required lower peak force than the modified Ponseti technique to achieve maximal dorsiflexion (mean ± SD modified Ponseti 37 ± 5 N versus Garceau 27 ± 4 N, mean difference 10 [95% confidence interval (CI) 4 to 16]; p = 0.009). The Garceau technique also produced smaller tendon displacement than the modified Ponseti technique (modified Ponseti 33 ± 3 mm versus Garceau 26 ± 3 mm, mean difference 7 [95% CI 4 to 10]; p < 0.001). Consequently, the mechanical work needed to achieve maximum dorsiflexion was lower with the Garceau technique (modified Ponseti 443 ± 76 J versus Garceau 269 ± 47 J, mean difference 174 [95% CI 84 to 264]; p = 0.005), a reduction qualitatively reflected in earlier force application and shorter excursions on the force-displacement curve. CONCLUSION: The Garceau technique requires less mechanical work than the modified Ponseti method to reach maximum dorsiflexion of the foot, likely because the tendon follows a more direct path, creating no additional tendon-reflection pulley. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: For patients with limited muscular strength, the Garceau technique may lower energy demand during gait, supporting its consideration in surgical management of recurrent clubfoot. Comparative clinical gait-analysis studies that quantify postoperative dorsiflexion strength, gait kinetics, and relapse rates after each transfer technique are needed to determine whether this biomechanical advantage translates into improved clinical and functional outcomes.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Martínez-Collado P, Falcón-Goicoechea J, Soza-Leiva DB, et al. Garceau Technique Requires Less Mechanical Work Than Modified Ponseti for Tibialis Anterior Tendon Transfer: A Biomechanical Study in Cadavers. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 41099559. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003719

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。