文献速递运动医学关节外科

关节镜下肩袖修复术后临床结局在回顾性与前瞻性研究之间是否存在显著差异:一项纳入60,505例修复的系统综述

Are there significant differences in the clinical outcomes following arthroscopic rotator cuff repair which are reported in retrospective compared with prospective studies? : a systematic review including 60,505 repairs.
PubMed 文献 · Bone Joint J · 2025-10-01

该研究通过PRISMA指南检索文献,纳入315项研究共60,505例关节镜下肩袖修复(ARCR),比较回顾性与前瞻性研究报告的临床结局。前瞻性研究的再撕裂率显著高于回顾性研究(18.8% vs 16.1%,p < 0.001),而翻修率两组无显著差异(均为3.7%,p = 0.161)。

要点

  • 前瞻性研究报告的ARCR术后再撕裂率显著高于回顾性研究(18.8% vs 16.1%,p < 0.001)。
  • 两组翻修率无显著差异(均为3.7%,p = 0.161)。
  • 作者认为再撕裂率差异可能源于前瞻性研究采用了改进的影像学和随访方案。

核心结论

  • 前瞻性研究报告的ARCR术后再撕裂率显著高于回顾性研究,可能源于前瞻性研究采用了改进的影像学和随访方案。
  • 两种研究设计中的翻修率均较低,提示再撕裂通常无症状。
  • 作者认为外科医生在为考虑接受ARCR的患者提供咨询时应考虑这些发现。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,遵循PRISMA指南进行文献检索,纳入报告ARCR术后临床结局且随访至少24个月的研究。
  • 由两名独立研究者按纳入和排除标准系统收集数据,并使用改良Coleman方法学评分评估纳入研究质量。
  • 共纳入315项研究、60,505例ARCR,其中回顾性研究232项(54,237例修复),前瞻性研究83项(6,268例修复)。

主要发现

  • 总体再撕裂率为16.7%,总体翻修率为3.7%。
  • 前瞻性研究报告的再撕裂率显著高于回顾性研究(18.8% vs 16.1%,p < 0.001)。
  • 两组翻修率无显著差异(均为3.7%,p = 0.161)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为外科医生在为考虑接受ARCR的患者提供咨询时应考虑这些发现。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIMS: As the number of patients who require arthroscopic rotator cuff repair (ARCR) continues to increase, the number of studies in which the clinical outcomes after this procedure are reported also increases. However, most studies reporting the outcomes of ARCR are retrospective with biases which are consistent with low levels of evidence. The aims of this study were to determine whether the clinical outcomes which have been reported following ARCR differ between retrospective and prospective studies. The hypothesis was that prospective studies report higher re-tear rates due to more rigorous follow-up and imaging techniques. METHODS: A literature search was performed using PRISMA guidelines to identify studies in which the clinical outcomes after ARCR with a minimum of 24 months' follow-up were reported. Two independent investigators systematically collected data using inclusion and exclusion criteria, and assessed the quality of the included studies using the Modified Coleman Methodology Score. RESULTS: A total of 315 studies including 60,505 ARCRs were included. There were 232 retrospective and 83 prospective studies, including 54,237 and 6,268 repairs, respectively, with overall re-tear and revision rates of 16.7% and 3.7%, respectively. A significantly higher re-tear rate was reported in the prospective studies compared with the retrospective studies (18.8% vs 16.1%; p < 0.001). There was no significant difference in the revision rates between the two groups (both 3.7%; p = 0.161). CONCLUSION: Significantly higher re-tear rates have been reported after ARCR in prospective studies rather than in retrospective studies. This was probably due to improved imaging and follow-up protocols used in prospective studies. However, revision rates remain low in both designs of study, suggesting that re-tears are usually asymptomatic. Surgeons should consider these findings when counselling patients who are considering undergoing an ARCR.

来源:Bone Joint J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Davey MS, O'Dwyer L, Kilkenny C, et al. Are there significant differences in the clinical outcomes following arthroscopic rotator cuff repair which are reported in retrospective compared with prospective studies? : a systematic review including 60,505 repairs. Bone Joint J. 2025. PMID: 41027615. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.107B10.BJJ-2025-0160.R1

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。