上横无创重建全髋关节置换术与直接前入路相比获得相似的满意度和最小临床重要差异:一项倾向评分匹配的两年结局研究
该回顾性研究在高容量三级医院纳入2018年1月至2022年12月期间接受初次全髋关节置换术且年龄>60岁、至少随访2年的患者,将直接前入路(DAA)与上横无创重建(STAR)后外侧入路按1:1倾向评分匹配各132例。DAA组在术后2年牛津髋关节评分、西安大略和麦克马斯特大学骨关节炎指数僵硬、身体功能、SF-36身体功能、总体健康、社会功能、躯体成分评分和精神成分评分上显著更高,但两组在达到最小临床重要差异(MCID)、患者满意度和期望满足评分上无差异。作者认为DAA的功能优势临床相关性可能有限,因为手动STAR全髋关节置换术同样达到了MCID阈值并获得了高满意度且未增加并发症。
要点
- DAA组术后2年牛津髋关节评分显著高于STAR组(P=0.0140)。
- 两组在MCID达标率、患者满意度和期望满足评分上无差异。
- STAR全髋关节置换术手动完成,同样达到MCID阈值且未增加并发症。
核心结论
- 技术辅助DAA全髋关节置换术在两年时显示出更好的功能结局,但其临床相关性可能有限。
- 手动STAR全髋关节置换术同样达到了MCID阈值并获得了高患者满意度率,且未增加并发症。
- 作者认为略低的功能评分并不影响全髋关节置换术的整体成功。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2018年1月至2022年12月在一家高容量三级医院实施的所有初次全髋关节置换术。
- 纳入全髋关节置换术时年龄>60岁且至少随访2年、具有牛津髋关节评分、西安大略和麦克马斯特大学骨关节炎指数、SF-36子量表及汇总评分(躯体成分评分/精神成分评分)、患者满意度和期望满足评分的患者。
- DAA全髋关节置换术在透视或机器人辅助下完成,STAR全髋关节置换术手动完成。
- 采用逻辑回归估计倾向评分,随后按1:1比例贪婪匹配建立DAA组和STAR组。
- 成功匹配132例DAA全髋关节置换术与132例STAR全髋关节置换术。
主要发现
- DAA组术后2年牛津髋关节评分显著高于STAR组(P=0.0140)。
- DAA组西安大略和麦克马斯特大学骨关节炎指数僵硬评分显著高于STAR组(P=0.0455)。
- DAA组西安大略和麦克马斯特大学骨关节炎指数身体功能评分显著高于STAR组(P=0.0125)。
- DAA组SF-36身体功能(P=0.00537)、总体健康(P=0.0495)、社会功能(P=0.0266)、躯体成分评分(P=0.0478)和精神成分评分(P=0.0482)均显著高于STAR组。
- 两组在MCID达标率、患者满意度和期望满足评分上无差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 术后2年牛津髋关节评分DAA组显著高于STAR组(P=0.0140)。
- 术后2年西安大略和麦克马斯特大学骨关节炎指数僵硬评分DAA组显著高于STAR组(P=0.0455)。
- 术后2年西安大略和麦克马斯特大学骨关节炎指数身体功能评分DAA组显著高于STAR组(P=0.0125)。
- 术后2年SF-36身体功能DAA组显著高于STAR组(P=0.00537),总体健康DAA组显著高于STAR组(P=0.0495),社会功能DAA组显著高于STAR组(P=0.0266),躯体成分评分DAA组显著高于STAR组(P=0.0478),精神成分评分DAA组显著高于STAR组(P=0.0482)。
- MCID达标率、患者满意度和期望满足评分两组无差异。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Numerous studies comparing the direct anterior approach (DAA) and postero-lateral approach in total hip arthroplasty (THA) have been inconclusive, mostly demonstrating earlier recovery with DAA, with no differences in outcomes by one year. However, there are limited studies comparing the DAA with the superior transverse atraumatic reconstruction (STAR) THA, which is a type of postero-lateral approach. This study aimed to compare the 2-year follow-up patient-reported outcome measures, satisfaction, and complication rates between DAA and STAR THA. METHODS: A retrospective analysis of all primary THAs performed (January 2018 to December 2022) at a high-volume tertiary hospital was conducted. The study included patients >60 year at the time of THA with minimum 2-year outcomes of Oxford Hip Score, Western Ontario and McMaster University Arthritic Index, Short-Form 36 Health Survey subscale and summative (physical component score/mental component scores), patient satisfaction, and expectation fulfillment scores. The DAA THA was performed with either fluoroscopic or robotic assistance, whereas the STAR THA was performed manually. Logistic regressions were performed to estimate propensity scores, followed by greedy matching in a 1:1 ratio to establish the DAA and STAR groups. Parametric and nonparametric statistical tests were used to compare postoperative scores and the proportion attaining a minimal clinically important difference (MCID). A total of 132 DAA THA were successfully matched with 132 STAR THA. RESULTS: The DAA group demonstrated significantly higher scores in 2-year postoperative Oxford Hip Score (P = 0.0140), Western Ontario and McMaster University Arthritic Index stiffness (P = 0.0455), physical function (P = 0.0125), Short-Form 36 Health Survey physical function (P = 0.00537), general health (P = 0.0495), social function (P = 0.0266), physical component score (P = 0.0478), and mental component score (P = 0.0482). There was no difference in MCID attainment, patient satisfaction, or expectation fulfillment scores noted. CONCLUSIONS: While technology-assisted DAA THA demonstrated better functional outcomes at two years, its clinical relevance may be limited, as manually performed STAR THA also attained MCID thresholds and yielded high patient satisfaction rates without additional complications. This suggests that slightly lower functional scores do not compromise overall THA success.
引用
- Jared Chua HY, Jiawei C, Yeo SJ, et al. Superior Transverse Atraumatic Reconstruction Total Hip Arthroplasty Achieves Similar Satisfaction and Minimal Clinically Important Differences When Compared to the Direct Anterior Approach: A Propensity Score Matched Study With Two-Year Outcomes. J Arthroplasty. 2025. PMID: 41067456. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2025.09.043
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。