功能良好尸检全膝关节置换术中骨水泥髌骨假体的机械加载至剪切失败研究
研究对22例功能良好尸检全膝关节置换术的骨水泥髌骨假体进行孤立剪切应力加载至失败,平均失败载荷为1881±621 N; multivariable分析显示失败载荷与骨体积分数正相关,与体重指数、植入时长和假体-骨表面积覆盖率负相关。作者建议在两种髌骨假体尺寸间选择时考虑较小尺寸,可能提高髌骨结构的最大剪切强度。
要点
- 22例功能良好尸检TKA髌骨骨水泥假体平均剪切失败载荷为1881±621 N。
- 失败部位:骨-骨水泥界面9例、假体-骨水泥界面7例、两者兼有6例,无假体-栓柱交界失败。
- multivariable分析中失败载荷与骨体积分数正相关,与BMI、植入时长和假体-骨表面积覆盖率负相关。
核心结论
- 在功能良好尸检TKA的骨水泥髌骨假体队列中,加载至剪切失败高于既往报道的尸体原生髌骨骨水泥假体。
- 髌骨假体对骨的覆盖量与剪切强度呈负相关(校正其他相关因素后)。
- 作者建议在两种髌骨假体尺寸间选择时考虑较小尺寸,可能提高髌骨结构的最大剪切强度。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为对22例功能良好尸检全膝关节置换术的髌骨标本进行剪切应力加载至失败的实验研究;平均植入时长9.1年(范围1.7至19.6年)。
- 评估了三种全聚乙烯3栓柱onlay髌骨假体设计,并对聚乙烯损伤、假体-骨尺寸比、微结构参数及假体-骨水泥-骨界面进行评估。
- 使用伺服液压试验机对髌骨标本施加孤立剪切应力直至失败,采用单变量和多变量线性回归分析临床与影像学因素的影响。
主要发现
- 平均加载至剪切失败为1881±621 N。
- 失败部位:骨-骨水泥界面9例,假体-骨水泥界面7例,两者兼有6例;无假体-栓柱交界失败。
- 多变量分析中,失败载荷与骨体积分数正相关,与体重指数、植入时长和假体-骨表面积覆盖率负相关。
- 加载至剪切失败与表面损伤或影像学参数无关联,且在三种髌骨假体设计间无差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,当在两种髌骨假体尺寸间选择时,术者可考虑选择较小尺寸,可能提高髌骨结构的最大剪切强度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Shear forces on the patella can lead to patellar loosening and failure in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Our objectives were as follows: (1) evaluate the mechanical load-to-shear failure in a unique cohort of cemented patellar components in well-functioning postmortem TKAs and (2) determine the influence of clinical and radiographic factors on load-to-shear failure. METHODS: There were 22 patellae that were harvested from well-functioning postmortem TKAs (mean implantation duration 9.1 years [range, 1.7 to 19.6]). There were three all-polyethylene 3-peg onlay patellar designs evaluated. The patellae were evaluated for polyethylene damage, implant-to-bone size ratios, microarchitectural parameters, and implant-cement-bone interface. Patellar specimens were loaded with isolated shear stress using a servo-hydraulic test frame until failure. Univariate and multivariable linear regression models were used to analyze the influence of clinical and radiographic factors on load-to-shear failure. RESULTS: The mean load-to-shear failure was 1,881 ± 621 N. There were nine patellae that failed at the bone-cement interface, seven that failed at the implant-cement interface, and six that involved both interfaces. There were no failures at the peg-implant junction. On multivariable analyses, load to failure was positively associated with bone volume fraction and negatively associated with body mass index, duration of implantation, and implant-to-bone surface area coverage. Load-to-shear failure was not associated with surface damage or radiographic parameters and did not differ across the three patellar implant designs. CONCLUSIONS: In this novel cohort of cemented patellar buttons from well-functioning postmortem TKAs, load-to-shear failure was higher than previously reported in buttons cemented in cadaver native patellae. The amount of bony coverage by the patellar button was inversely associated with shear strength after accounting for other pertinent factors. When choosing between two patellar button sizes, surgeons should consider opting for the smaller size, which may improve the maximum shear strength of the patellar construct.
引用
- LeBrun DG, Sacher SE, Siljander B, et al. Mechanical Load-To-Shear Failure of Cemented Patellar Components in Well-Functioning Postmortem Total Knee Arthroplasties. J Arthroplasty. 2025. PMID: 41072562. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2025.10.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。