磁控生长棒与脊柱生长引导手术治疗特发性早发性脊柱侧凸的三维分析对比
回顾性队列研究比较磁控生长棒(MCGR)与脊柱生长引导手术(SpGG)治疗特发性早发性脊柱侧凸(i-EOS)的效果,使用三维真脊柱长度(3D-TSL)评估。161例患者(SpGG 31例、MCGR 130例)随访至少两年,结果显示两组3D-TSL增长相似(SpGG 16.8 mm/y vs MCGR 14.2 mm/y,P=0.2),SpGG冠状面矫正率更高且维持最大后凸。
要点
- SpGG与MCGR术后两年3D-TSL增长相似:SpGG 16.8 mm/y vs MCGR 14.2 mm/y(P=0.2)。
- SpGG冠状面矫正率高于MCGR(P=0.03),且维持最大后凸(SpGG +9° vs MCGR -7°,P<0.001)。
- 再手术率:SpGG 19.3% vs MCGR 8.5%。
核心结论
- 术后两年,MCGR的3D-TSL增长为14.2 mm/y,SpGG为16.8 mm/y,总体而言SpGG与MCGR术后两年结局相似。
- SpGG具有更高的冠状面矫正百分比并维持最大后凸。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,查询多中心数据库,纳入接受MCGR或SpGG且随访至少两年的特发性早发性脊柱侧凸患者。
- 共161例患者(99例女性;SpGG 31例,MCGR 130例),手术时平均年龄8.1岁。
主要发现
- SpGG将脊柱侧凸从67°降至术后26°至末次随访35°(矫正46%,P=0.02)。
- MCGR将脊柱侧凸从71°降至术后40°至末次随访42°(矫正34%,P<0.001)。
- 术后两年SpGG的冠状面弯曲矫正百分比大于MCGR(P=0.03)。
- SpGG维持最大测量后凸从术前至术后即刻,随访时增加(41°至43°至50°,P=0.004);MCGR术后即刻降低(49°至36°,P<0.001),末次随访增加(+6°,42°,P=0.002)。
- 最大测量后凸变化SpGG +9° vs MCGR -7°(P<0.001);全队列T1至S1高度从281 mm增至314 mm,两年时336 mm(P<0.001);3D-TSL从术前至术后即刻无显著变化(338 mm至342 mm)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective cohort. OBJECTIVE: Compare spinal growth guidance surgery (SpGG) and magnetically controlled growing rods (MCGR) outcomes in idiopathic early-onset scoliosis (i-EOS) using three-dimensional true spine length (3D-TSL). SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: SpGG and MCGR are techniques aimed to correct and control severe progressive spine deformity while maintaining growth. Past studies yielded comparable results between constructs using vertical coronal measures, which fail to account for growth outside plane of measurement due to three-dimensional deformity. METHODS: A multicenter database was queried for i-EOS patients undergoing MCGR or SpGG with minimum two-year follow-up. Patients were included with perioperative and two-year measurements. RESULTS: There were 161 patients (99 female; 31 SpGG/130 MCGR), with a mean age at surgery 8.1 years. 19.3% SpGG and 8.5% MCGR underwent repeat surgeries. SpGG reduced scoliosis from 67° to 26° postoperatively to 35° final (46% correction, P =0.02). MCGR reduced scoliosis 71° to 40° postoperatively to 42° final (34% correction, P <0.001). SpGG had greater coronal curve percent correction than MCGR at two years ( P =0.03). SpGG maintained maximal measured kyphosis (MMK) preoperative to immediate postoperative with increase at follow-up (41° to 43° to 50°, P =0.004). MCGR initially decreased postoperatively (49° to 36°, P <0.001) with an increase at final (+6, 42°, P =0.002). There was a significant change in MMK between SpGG and MCGR (SpGG +9 vs. MCGR-7; P <0.001). Total cohort T1 to S1 height increased (281-314 mm) and at two years (336 mm) ( P <0.001). 3D-TSL didn't significantly change preoperative to immediate postoperative (338-342 mm) for either construct. At two-year SpGG 3D-TSL increased 16.8 mm/y, whereas MCGR increased 14.2 mm/y ( P =0.2). CONCLUSIONS: At two years, 3D-TSL increased for 14.2 mm/y for MCGR and 16.8 mm/y for SpGG. Overall, SpGG and MCGR offer similar outcomes two years postoperatively as assessed by 3D-TSL. SpGG had greater coronal curve percent correction and maintained maximal kyphosis.
引用
- Narro Garcia F, Hurry J, McCarthy RE, et al. Comparison Between Magnetically Controlled Growing Rods and Spinal Growth Guidance Surgery for Idiopathic Early-Onset Scoliosis: A Three-Dimensional Analysis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2025. PMID: 41066152. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000005532
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。