髋膝关节置换术等待时间延长的虚假节约:一项成本后果分析
该研究利用英国国家关节登记中心(NJR)、NHS Digital患者报告结局测量(PROMs)及已发表研究数据建模,模拟全髋关节置换术(THA)和全膝关节置换术(TKA)后10年内的健康相关生活质量(HRQoL)与质量调整生命年(QALY)。结果显示,等待3年较等待3个月每例THA额外成本为1756英镑(含效用损失为796英镑),TKA为2116英镑(含效用损失为1068英镑);等待1年使THA和TKA的10年QALY分别损失9%,等待3年分别损失45.5%和57.1%。结论提示等待超过3个月行THA/TKA导致超额成本并降低HRQoL,NHS等待时间延长看似虚假节约。
要点
- 等待3年较3个月每例THA额外成本1756英镑(含效用损失796英镑),TKA为2116英镑(含效用损失1068英镑)。
- 等待1年使THA和TKA的10年QALY均损失9%,等待3年THA损失45.5%、TKA损失57.1%。
- 等待3年使THA的每QALY成本增至2.00至2.44倍(等待1年为1.14至1.23倍),TKA增至2.45至2.93倍(等待1年为1.10至1.19倍)。
核心结论
- 该分析提示等待THA/TKA超过三个月导致超额成本并降低HRQoL,NHS等待时间延长看似虚假节约。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用公共数据源(包括NJR、NHS Digital PROMs及已发表研究)建模THA和TKA后的HRQoL增益。
- 基于EQ-5D指数评分模拟等待3个月、1年和3年时的净QALY,并绘制THA和TKA术后10年内的预期EQ-5D评分。
- 采用概率敏感性分析建模QALY轨迹,以曲线下面积(AUC)计算QALY短缺。
主要发现
- 纳入额外处方和非计划诊疗成本后,等待3年较3个月每例THA额外成本为1756英镑(含效用损失为796英镑),TKA为2116英镑(含效用损失为1068英镑)。
- 等待1年导致THA和TKA的10年QALY短缺均为9%,等待3年增至THA 45.5%和TKA 57.1%。
- 等待3年使THA的每QALY成本增至2.00至2.44倍(等待1年为1.14至1.23倍),TKA增至2.45至2.93倍(等待1年为1.10至1.19倍)。
- 若各等待时间之间EQ-5D改善值(而非绝对值)相等,TKA等待3年导致10年内净QALY损失。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Cost per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) can be used to estimate the financial consequences of delayed surgery. QALYs are determined by health-related quality of life (HRQoL) and the duration of the time spent in that state. Total hip arthroplasty (THA) and total knee arthroplasty (TKA) are cost-effective procedures, but it is not known whether prolonged waiting times have an impact on costs and QALYs associated with them. The aim of this study was to investigate how the time waiting for surgery can influence the overall cost and gains in QALYs over a ten-year period following THA or TKA. METHODS: Public data sources, including the National Joint Registry (NJR), NHS Digital patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) and previously published studies were used to model HRQoL gains following THA and TKA. Using EuroQol five-dimension questionnaire (EQ-5D) index scores, the net QALY was simulated for waiting times of three months, one year and three years. Expected EQ-5D scores up to ten years postoperatively were plotted for THA and TKA. The trjectories of QALYs were modelled using probabilistic sensitivity analysis. Shortfalls in QALYs were calculated as the area under the curve (AUC). RESULTS: When the costs of additional prescriptions and unscheduled care were included, the excess cost incurred per patient by waiting three years compared to three months was £1,756 (£796 with disutility) for THA, and £2,116 (£1,068 with disutility) for TKA. Waiting one year resulted in a ten-year shortfall of QALYs of 9% for both THA and TKA, increasing to 45.5% (THA) and 57.1% (TKA) after a three-year wait. Three-year waits increased the cost/QALY by 2.00 to 2.44 times for THA (1.14 to 1.23 for one year) and 2.45 to 2.93 times (1.10 to 1.19 for one year) for TKA. If improvements in EQ-5D (as opposed to absolute values) were equal between the waiting times, waiting three years for TKA resulted in a net loss of QALYs over ten years. CONCLUSION: This analysis suggests that waiting beyond three months for THA/TKA resulted in excess costs and diminished HRQoL. Increasing waiting times in the NHS, thus, appear to be a false economy.
引用
- Scott CEH, Yapp LZ, Makaram NS, et al. The false economy of increased waiting times for hip and knee arthroplasty : a cost consequence analysis. Bone Joint J. 2025. PMID: 40887048. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.107B9.BJJ-2024-0974.R2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。