骨折风险评估工具的预测能力:系统综述的总览
该总览纳入评估骨折风险预测工具预测能力的系统综述,涉及男女人群及一般成年人群。共识别26种工具,AUC范围为0.58至0.90,无模型预测能力超过90%,多数模型AUC在0.7至0.75之间。FRAX(含或不含BMD)的AUC/C指数为0.58至0.90,Garvan模型AUC为0.57至0.84。
要点
- 共识别26种骨折风险预测工具,AUC范围为0.58至0.90。
- 无模型预测能力超过90%,多数模型AUC在0.7至0.75之间。
- FRAX(含或不含BMD)AUC/C指数为0.58至0.90,Garvan模型AUC为0.57至0.84。
核心结论
- 绝大多数模型的预测能力AUC在0.7至0.75之间。
- 比较不同工具预测骨折的表现时,必须考虑预测工具之间的差异、所考虑的风险因素数量以及变量的性质,这些因素会影响其在临床实践中的可行性。
- 预测结果的差异可能取决于性别、年龄、骨折类型以及预测的时间间隔,并可能影响工具在日常临床实践中的使用。
研究设计与样本
- 研究类型为系统综述的总览(overview of systematic reviews)。
- 纳入评估任何工具、评分、算法或其他骨折风险预测仪器预测能力的系统综述。
- 纳入研究男女人群及一般成年人群骨折的系统综述。
- 主要结局指标为通过受试者工作特征(ROC)分析获得的曲线下面积(AUC),代表特定时间范围内预测的骨折风险。
主要发现
- 共识别26种当前使用的骨折风险预测工具,共发现21,717个不同的预测变量。
- 不同工具使用的因素数量不同,从BWC模型仅使用单个预测变量到GSOS工具纳入21,717个预测变量(包括许多个体SNP)。
- 工具的AUC范围为0.58至0.90,无模型预测能力超过90%。
- 多数模型AUC在0.7至0.75之间,但不能说任何特定模型优于其他模型,所有模型在不同研究中表现出波动行为。
- 最常验证的两种模型:FRAX(含或不含BMD)在不同研究中AUC/C指数范围为0.58至0.90;Garvan模型AUC范围为0.57至0.84。
关键数值与推荐
- FRAX(含或不含BMD)的AUC/C指数范围为0.58至0.90。
- Garvan模型的AUC范围为0.57至0.84。
- 所有工具AUC范围为0.58至0.90,无模型超过90%。
- 多数模型AUC在0.7至0.75之间。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Conduct an overview of systematic reviews of the current fracture risk prediction tools in use. MATERIAL AND METHODS: We included systematic reviews (SRs) that assessed the predictive ability of any tool, score, algorithm, or other instrument for fracture risk. The primary outcome measure was the area under the curve (AUC) representing predicted fracture risk within a specified timeframe obtained from receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis. We included SRs that studied both men and women with fractures in the general adult population. RESULTS: The review identified 26 different tools currently in use to predict fracture risk. Within these tools a total, 21,717 different prediction variables were found. Among the different tools, a different number of factors were used ranging from the BWC model that used a single predictor variable to the GSOS tool that incorporated 21,717 predictor variables in its model (including many individual SNPs). Regarding the performance of the tools, AUC ranging from 0.58 to 0.90. None of the models had a prediction capacity greater than 90%. Most of the models are within the range of 0.7 and 0.75, but it cannot be said that any specific one stands out over the others. Rather, a fluctuating behavior is observed in all models within the different studies. The discrimination of the two most frequently validated models, including FRAX with and without BMD, varied among the studies with AUC/C index ranging from 0.58 to 0.90, respectively. Other commonly validated model, including the Garvan Model showed AUC between 0.57 to 0.84. CONCLUSIONS: The vast majority of the models performance is within the range of 0.7 and 0.75. To compare the performance of different tools when predicting fracture, it is very important to consider the differences between prediction tools, the number of risk factors considered, as well as the nature of the variables as they will have an important impact on the feasibility of its use in clinical practice. Likewise, differences in the prediction results may depend on sex, age, types of fractures, as well as the temporal intervals of the prediction and could affect the use of the tools in the daily clinical routine.
引用
- Cruz-Priego GA, Araiza-Nava B, Méndez-Sánchez L, et al. Predictive capacity of fracture risk assessment tools: overview of systematic reviews. Osteoporos Int. 2025. PMID: 40921865. doi:10.1007/s00198-025-07642-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。