前路椎体拴系与后路脊柱融合治疗青少年特发性胸椎侧凸的非随机临床试验比较
本研究比较前路椎体拴系(AVBT)与后路脊柱融合(PSF)治疗青少年特发性胸椎侧凸的疗效、生活质量、翻修风险和资源利用。2017至2022年非随机对照试验中,AVBT组20例,PSF组27例(随访2年时PSF组21例可分析)。AVBT组2年内主胸弯矫正至<50°且未因翻修重返手术室的比例为70%(14/20),PSF组为100%(21/21),差异有统计学意义(P < 0.001);AVBT组支具断裂率35%(7例),30%(6例)需翻修。作者认为PSF结局更优,AVBT需更多研究支持其非劣效性。
要点
- AVBT组2年内主胸弯矫正至<50°且无翻修重返手术室的比例为70%,低于PSF组的100%。
- AVBT组2年时胸弯矫正率为34%,低于PSF组的61%。
- AVBT组支具断裂率为35%,需翻修比例为30%;PSF组无内固定并发症和翻修。
核心结论
- 作者认为,小儿骨科脊柱外科医生应与青少年特发性脊柱侧凸患者仔细讨论椎体拴系的适用性,因为现有证据表明更成熟的后路脊柱融合技术带来更好的结局。
- 作者指出,在AVBT被广泛提供给患者和家庭之前,需要更多研究支持其在影像学和安全指标上非劣效于PSF。
研究设计与样本
- FDA批准的研究性器械豁免临床试验中,2017至2022年评估87例患者资格,20例符合Lenke 1或2型、胸弯35°至60°、腰弯<35°、Risser 0或Sanders骨龄≤4的患者接受AVBT。
- 选择PSF的Lenke 1或2型患者27例被前瞻性分析作为对照,2年随访时AVBT组20例(100%)、PSF组21例(78%)纳入分析,PSF组失访6例(22%)。
- 研究证据等级为III级,治疗性研究。
主要发现
- 2年内主胸弯矫正至<50°且未因翻修重返手术室的比例:AVBT组70%(14/20)vs PSF组100%(21/21),P < 0.001。
- 首次直立位胸弯矫正率:AVBT组35% vs PSF组65%,P < 0.001;2年时矫正率:AVBT组34% vs PSF组61%,P < 0.001。
- 2年时SRS-22总分:AVBT组4.3±0.5 vs PSF组4.5±0.4,P = 0.14,无显著差异。
- AVBT组35%(7例)发生支具断裂,30%(6例)在2年随访前需翻修;PSF组无内固定并发症和翻修。
- AVBT组住院时间2±1天 vs PSF组3±1天(P = 0.02),固定节段7±1 vs 10±1(P < 0.001),手术时间231±41分钟 vs 194±26分钟(P = 0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,小儿骨科脊柱外科医生应与青少年特发性脊柱侧凸患者仔细讨论椎体拴系的使用,因为证据指向更成熟的后路脊柱融合技术带来更好结局。
- 作者指出,在AVBT广泛用于患者之前,需要更多研究支持其在影像学和安全指标上非劣效于PSF。
局限性
- 研究为非随机设计,患者及其家庭根据临床特征和治疗目标选择 preferred treatment。
- PSF组22%(6例)失访,2年随访时仅78%(21例)纳入分析。
- 作者指出需要更多研究支持AVBT在影像学和安全指标上非劣效于PSF。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recently, there has been an increased interest in alternative surgical options for treating idiopathic scoliosis. For instance, anterior vertebral body tethering (AVBT) is an emerging surgical solution used in lieu of posterior spinal fusion (PSF). This technology has been gaining in popularity because of its potential benefits of preservation of spinal growth, motion, and functional activity. Although prior retrospective studies have indicated the potential efficacy of AVBT in patients with primary thoracic curves, a direct comparison to PSF, the most widely used definitive treatment for pediatric scoliosis, has yet to be conducted. Differences in efficacy, quality of life, and revision risk may exist across the techniques. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We compared AVBT to PSF in terms of (1) the proportion of patients whose main thoracic curve was corrected to < 50° without a return to the operating room for revision within 2 years, (2) residual thoracic and lumbar curve magnitude at 2 years, (3) health-related quality of life (HRQoL) scores, and (4) the frequency of serious complications and healthcare resource utilization. METHODS: From 2017 to 2022, patients (n = 87) were assessed for eligibility to participate in an FDA-approved investigational device exemption clinical trial for AVBT based on presenting to the clinic with a diagnosis of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis that had entered into surgical range. Based on clinical characteristics and the family's stated goals of care, AVBT and PSF were both discussed, but ultimately the patient and their family selected their preferred treatment. Under guidance from the FDA, a sample of 20 patients who met the inclusion criteria of a Lenke Type 1 or 2 curve classification, a thoracic curve between 35° and 60°, a lumbar curve < 35°, and a skeletal maturity score of either Risser 0 or Sanders bone age of ≤ 4 were eligible to participate in the trial and undergo AVBT. Patients with Lenke 1 and 2 curves who elected to undergo PSF (n = 27) were prospectively analyzed for comparison. No patients who underwent AVBT and 22% (n = 6) of those who underwent PSF were lost prior to the minimum study follow-up of 2 years, leaving 100% (20) and 78% (n = 21) in each group, respectively, for analysis. All patients in the PSF group who were lost to follow-up did not report any complications at 1 year. Patients who underwent AVBT (80% [ 16 ] girls) were generally younger, more skeletally immature, and had smaller preoperative curvature at the time of surgery compared with patients who underwent PSF (81% [ 17 ] girls). No differences in gender, height, or revised Scoliosis Research Society-22 (SRS-22) patient questionnaire scores were observed across the two groups at baseline. Patients in both cohorts were followed at the preoperative, first erect, and 2-year time points. Radiographic, health-related quality of life, unplanned return to the operating room, complications, and healthcare resource utilization outcomes were compared. RESULTS: Scoliosis curves were reduced to < 50°, without unplanned return to the operating room, at 2 years in 70% (14 of 20) of patients who underwent AVBT and 100% (21 of 21) of patients who had PSF (p < 0.001). No patients who had PSF underwent revisions. Although both groups showed postoperative curve correction, patients who had AVBT showed less curve correction at first erect (35% versus 65% correction; p < 0.001) and at 2 years (34% versus 61% correction; p < 0.001). No differences were found in any revised SRS-22 domains or total score at 2 years between the AVBT and PSF groups (4.3 ± 0.5 versus 4.5 ± 0.4; p = 0.14). No instrumentation complications occurred in the PSF group. Thirty-five percent (7) of patients who received AVBT experienced a tether rupture, and 30% (6) of patients who received a tether required a revision procedure prior to the 2-year follow-up. Intraoperative data revealed that AVBT resulted in a shorter length of stay (2 ± 1 versus 3 ± 1 days; p = 0.02) and fewer levels instrumented (7 ± 1 versus 10 ± 1 levels; p < 0.001); however, there was increased operative time when compared with PSF (231 ± 41 versus 194 ± 26 minutes; p = 0.001). CONCLUSION: Pediatric orthopaedic spine surgeons should carefully consider discussing the use of vertebral body tethering with their patients who have adolescent idiopathic scoliosis, as this evidence points to the more established technique of PSF leading to better outcomes. Additional research supporting AVBT as noninferior to PSF in radiographic and safety measures is needed before the procedure becomes widely available to patients and their families. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Lott C, Capraro A, Qiu C, et al. How Does Anterior Vertebral Body Tethering Compare to Posterior Spinal Fusion for Thoracic Idiopathic Scoliosis? A Nonrandomized Clinical Trial. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 40537949. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003575
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。