优化前内侧旋转性膝关节不稳定的控制:不同前内侧重建技术的生物力学验证
在9例非配对膝关节尸体标本上,用6自由度机器人模拟临床松弛度,测试完整状态、切断sMCL和dMCL后以及5种重建方式。结果显示,在sMCL重建基础上增加斜向前内侧移植物可更好地控制前内侧旋转不稳定,胫骨附着点位于sMCL前方即可,股骨附着于后内侧上髁对移植物等长性至关重要。
要点
- 在sMCL重建基础上增加斜向前内侧移植物支可更好地约束前内侧旋转不稳定。
- 前内侧移植物支的胫骨附着点应位于sMCL前方,但精确位置不太重要。
- 股骨附着于后内侧上髁对优化移植物等长性至关重要。
核心结论
- 在尸体模型中,在sMCL重建基础上增加斜向前内侧移植物支可更好地约束前内侧旋转不稳定,复制sMCL和dMCL的功能。
- 前内侧移植物支的胫骨附着点应位于sMCL前方,但其在胫骨上的精确附着位置不太重要,这提供了手术灵活性,可能有助于避免前交叉韧带胫骨隧道汇合。
- 股骨附着于后内侧上髁对优化移植物等长性至关重要。
研究设计与样本
- 受控实验室研究,采用6自由度机器人装置在9例非配对膝关节上模拟临床松弛度。
- 测试条件包括:5 N·m外旋、8 N·m外翻旋转和前内侧抽屉试验(联合89 N前胫骨平移和5 N·m外旋)。
- 膝关节在完整状态、切断sMCL和dMCL后以及5种不同重建后测试:改良Lind重建、短sMCL重建、以及sMCL联合3种不同倾斜度的前内侧移植物支重建。
主要发现
- 短sMCL重建后,前内侧抽屉和外旋松弛度与MCL缺损状态或完整状态均无显著差异。
- 短sMCL重建后,外翻旋转在0°至60°屈曲范围内较MCL缺损状态降低,但在90°时未降低。
- 联合sMCL+前内侧重建后,外翻旋转在所有屈曲角度均较MCL缺损状态降低;前内侧抽屉和外旋松弛度也降低至与完整状态相似,但在30°时,倾斜度更大的T1和T2前内侧重建的松弛度小于完整状态。
- 改良Lind重建在所有屈曲角度将前内侧抽屉和外旋松弛度从MCL缺损状态降低至与完整状态相似;外翻旋转松弛度在所有屈曲角度降低,在0°至30°与完整膝关节相似;但与具有更斜向前内侧支的sMCL重建相比,其在约束前内侧抽屉和外旋方面不如后者。
临床怎么用
- 在sMCL重建基础上增加前内侧移植物支可优化即刻前内侧旋转不稳定的控制。
- 胫骨附着位置不太关键,提供了手术灵活性;股骨附着于后内侧上髁对优化移植物等长性至关重要。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Anteromedial rotatory instability (AMRI) can result from combined injury to the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and medial collateral ligament (MCL) complex (superficial and deep [sMCL and dMCL]). HYPOTHESIS: Adding an oblique anteromedial (AM) limb to an sMCL reconstruction improves the control of AMRI. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: A 6 degrees of freedom robotic setup simulated clinical laxity in 9 unpaired knees under the following tests: 5-N·m external rotation (ER), 8-N·m valgus rotation (VR), and AM drawer (combined 89-N anterior tibial translation and 5-N·m ER). Knees were tested intact after cutting the sMCL and dMCL and after 5 different reconstructions: modified Lind, short sMCL, and sMCL with the addition of an AM graft limb with 3 different obliquities. RESULTS: After short sMCL reconstruction, AM drawer and ER laxity were not significantly different from either the MCL-deficient state or the intact state. VR was reduced from the MCL-deficient state between 0° and 60° of flexion but not at 90°. For combined sMCL + AM reconstructions, VR was reduced as compared with the MCL-deficient state at all flexion angles. AM drawer laxity and ER laxity were also reduced, similar to the intact state, except at 30° where, for the more oblique T1 and T2 AM reconstructions, laxity was less than in the intact state. The modified Lind reconstruction reduced AM drawer and ER laxity from the MCL-deficient state to values similar to the intact state at all flexion angles. VR laxity was also reduced at all flexion angles, similar to the intact knee at 0° to 30°. However, it was not as good at restraining AM drawer and ER when compared with the sMCL reconstructions with more oblique AM limbs. CONCLUSION: AMRI appears to be better restrained by adding an oblique AM graft limb to an sMCL reconstruction, replicating the function of the sMCL and dMCL in a cadaveric model. The tibial attachment of the AM limb should be anterior to the sMCL, but its precise attachment on the tibia is less important. This offers surgical flexibility, which may be helpful in avoiding anterior cruciate ligament tibial tunnel coalition. The femoral attachment on the posterior medial epicondyle is critical to optimize graft isometry. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Adding an AM limb to a medial reconstruction optimizes the control of AMRI at time zero. The tibial attachment site is less critical, offering surgical flexibility.
引用
- Gellhaus F, Robinson JR, Lind M, et al. Optimizing the Control of Anteromedial Rotatory Knee Instability: A Biomechanical Validation of Different Anteromedial Reconstruction Techniques. Am J Sports Med. 2025. PMID: 40371817. doi:10.1177/03635465251339820
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。