文献速递关节外科

如何改善骨科医生对患者报告结局数据的使用?一项全国性定性研究

How Can the Use of Patient-Reported Outcomes Data by Orthopaedic Surgeons Be Improved? A National Qualitative Study.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2025-05-14

该描述性定性研究对20名澳大利亚骨科医生进行半结构化访谈,探讨使用患者报告结局测量(PROMs)数据的障碍与促进因素。主要障碍包括时间限制和对PROMs缺乏认识或理解;促进因素包括更好的PROMs专项报告和参与PROMs研究。参与者建议提供多种PROMs教育选项、继续教育激励和现代技术解决方案。

要点

  • 障碍主题包括时间限制和对PROMs及其使用方式缺乏认识或理解。
  • 促进因素主题包括更好的PROMs专项报告及参与PROMs研究活动。
  • 参与者建议提供多种PROMs教育选项、继续教育激励和现代技术解决方案。

核心结论

  • 尽管PROMs数据广泛可用,但若为医生提供支持性教育工具,可解决对如何有效解读和利用数据理解不完整的问题。
  • 我们将开展进一步研究,通过与医生共同设计的方法促进这些工具的开发,并仔细考虑影响医生获取和使用PROMs数据能力的时间限制。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用描述性定性研究设计,共纳入20名骨科医生参与者,其中18人为男性。
  • 参与者从研究团队专业联系人精心构建的矩阵中目的性抽样,该抽样数据库由从事关节置换术的医生组成,力求涵盖不同人口学和专业特征,包括执业环境(澳大利亚都市和区域、私立和公立医院)、临床经验(<10年至30+年)和医生年龄(30至39岁至70至79岁)。
  • 共邀请28名骨科医生参与,其中25名被确定符合条件;医生招募、数据收集和数据分析同时进行,邀请分批发送给潜在合格医生,并持续考虑样本特征的多样性。
  • 访谈者在分析最后四次访谈后确定主题饱和,显示重复主题且无新见解,因此在20次访谈后停止招募。
  • 由两名研究人员独立审查五份随机选择的去标识化访谈转录稿,以确保编码和主题开发的一致性;采用演绎与归纳相结合的方法进行数据分析。

主要发现

  • 影响骨科医生使用PROMs数据的关键障碍主题包括时间限制和对PROMs及其数据使用方式缺乏认识或理解。
  • 关键促进因素主题包括更好的PROMs专项报告可用性,包括医院层面审计中的报告,以及提供医生参与PROMs研究活动的机会以改善对PROMs数据的熟悉度。

临床怎么用

  • 为增加PROMs数据在临床实践中的使用,参与者建议为骨科医生开发和提供多种PROMs教育选项(例如研讨会和书面材料,如包含PROMs临床实践应用实例的电子邮件通讯)。
  • 参与者建议提供使用PROMs数据的继续教育激励(例如审查个人PROMs报告可获得继续专业发展学分)。
  • 参与者建议采用现代技术解决方案(包括PROMs系统的便携式选项)以改善获取便利性。
  • 作者认为,与骨科医生共同开发的有针对性的教育工具可帮助实现PROMs数据支持共享决策和患者护理的潜力。

局限性

  • 我们将开展进一步研究,通过共同设计方法促进这些工具的开发,并仔细考虑影响医生获取和使用PROMs数据能力的时间限制。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Routine collection of patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) is increasing within orthopaedic settings. Although PROMs have the potential to aid orthopaedic surgeons in clinical decision-making, surgeon engagement with and use of these data is limited. Identifying and addressing the facilitators and barriers to the use of PROMs data by orthopaedic surgeons may increase their usage in routine clinical practice. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In a qualitative study, we asked: (1) What are the barriers to the use of PROMs data by orthopaedic surgeons? (2) What are the facilitators to the use of PROMs data by orthopaedic surgeons? (3) How can orthopaedic surgeons' uptake of and engagement with PROMs data in clinical practice be enhanced? METHODS: A descriptive qualitative study design was undertaken by enrolling 20 orthopaedic surgeon participants (18 of whom were men). The surgeons were purposively sampled from a carefully curated matrix developed from the research team's professional contacts. This sampling database comprised surgeons performing arthroplasty and endeavored to span a range of demographic and professional characteristics including practice setting (metropolitan and regional Australia, private and public hospitals), clinical experience (< 10 years to 30+ years), and surgeon age (30 to 39 years to 70 to 79 years). In total, 28 orthopaedic surgeons were invited to participate, of which 25 were determined to be eligible. Following established qualitative methods, surgeon recruitment, data collection, and data analysis occurred concurrently. Specifically, invitations to participate were sent to potentially eligible surgeons in successive batches, with ongoing consideration of diversity in sample characteristics. The interviewer determined that thematic saturation had occurred after analyzing the final four interviews, which revealed repetitive themes and no new insights, leading to the cessation of recruitment after 20 interviews. Individual semistructured interviews explored participants' perceptions of factors that support and hinder the use of orthopaedic PROMs data in clinical practice. Surgeons' views on enhancing the utilization of PROMS data were also sought, including opportunities for improving electronic PROMs reporting systems, using a national registry platform as an exemplar. To enhance methodological rigor and reduce researcher bias, five randomly selected, deidentified interview transcripts were independently reviewed by two researchers to ensure consistency in coding and theme development. A combined deductive and inductive approach was then used for data analysis, enabling the categorization of themes into barriers, enablers, and opportunities for improving PROMs use by orthopaedic surgeons. RESULTS: Key barrier themes impacting orthopaedic surgeons' use of PROMs data included time constraints and a lack of awareness or understanding of PROMs and how these data could be used. Key facilitator themes included better availability of PROMs-specific reports, including reporting within hospital-level audits and providing opportunities for surgeon participation in PROMs research activities to improve familiarization with PROMs data. To increase the use of PROMs data in clinical practice, participants suggested the development and delivery of multiple PROMs education options (for example, seminars and written materials such as email communications with practical examples of PROMs use in clinical practice) for orthopaedic surgeons, continuing education incentives for using PROMs data (for continuing professional development points for reviewing individual PROMs reports), and modern technology solutions (including portable options of PROMs systems) to improve ease of access. CONCLUSION: Despite the widespread availability of PROMs data, an incomplete understanding of how to interpret and utilize the data effectively could be addressed if surgeons are provided with supportive educational tools. We will conduct further research to facilitate the development of these tools through codesign methods with surgeons, with careful consideration of the time limitations that impact surgeons' abilities to access and utilize PROMs data. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Targeted educational tools, codeveloped with orthopaedic surgeons, could help realize the potential of PROMs data to support shared decision-making and patient care.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Heath EL, Harris IA, Berkovic D, et al. How Can the Use of Patient-Reported Outcomes Data by Orthopaedic Surgeons Be Improved? A National Qualitative Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 40388802. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003503

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。