文献速递关节外科

短柄与标准柄股骨假体的累积翻修率与首次再翻修率是否存在差异:一项跨国登记研究

Do Cumulative Revision Rate and First-time Re-revision Rate Vary Between Short and Standard Femoral Stem Lengths? A Multinational Registry Study.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2024-12-30

基于澳大利亚、荷兰和瑞典三个国家关节登记库2007年1月至2022年12月的数据,纳入15771例短柄全髋关节置换(THA)并按1:2倾向评分匹配31542例标准柄THA。12年总体累积翻修率短柄组4.7% vs 标准柄组5.1%(p=0.20),5年再翻修率20.9% vs 20.4%(p=0.80),均无显著差异;短柄THA首次翻修时更多使用标准柄(58% vs 46%,p=0.01)。

要点

  • 短柄THA首次翻修时使用标准柄的比例为58%(116/201),高于标准柄THA翻修时的46%(149/322),p=0.01。
  • 12年总体累积翻修率短柄组4.7%(95%CI 4.0%–5.5%)vs 标准柄组5.1%(95%CI 4.5%–5.7%),p=0.20。
  • 5年第二次翻修的总体累积翻修率短柄组20.9%(95%CI 16.8%–25.8%)vs 标准柄组20.4%(95%CI 17.3%–23.9%),p=0.80。

核心结论

  • 作者认为,若日后需要翻修,初次THA使用短柄可能存在可感知的益处,因为本研究中短柄更多以标准(更保留骨量)柄进行翻修。
  • 作者认为,所研究的短柄THA首次与第二次总体累积翻修率与标准柄THA无差异,这也支持使用短柄THA。
  • 作者提出,应开展进一步研究,最好是跨国登记库研究,以证实本研究结果。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入2007年1月至2022年12月在澳大利亚骨科协会国家关节置换登记库(AOANJRR)、荷兰关节置换登记库(LROI)或瑞典关节置换登记库(SAR)登记的短柄THA患者,短柄定义为以干骺端固定为主的短柄,n=15771。
  • 另设倾向评分匹配(1:2)的标准柄THA队列,标准柄定义为标准长度柄,n=31542;匹配因素为性别、年龄、手术年份、诊断、摩擦界面材料与手术入路。
  • 匹配后两组年龄(均值±标准差63±11岁 vs 64±11岁)、男性比例(48%[7546/15771]vs 48%[15093/31542])与骨关节炎诊断比例(93%[14655/15771]vs 94%[29585/31542])无差异。
  • 翻修手术所用柄类型分为标准柄(<160 mm)与长柄(≥160 mm);采用Kaplan-Meier生存分析计算初次THA随访12年的总体累积翻修率及所有首次翻修随访5年的总体累积翻修率,终点为任何类型翻修。
  • 证据等级为Level III,治疗性研究。

主要发现

  • 短柄THA首次柄翻修中使用标准柄的比例为58%(116/201),高于标准柄THA翻修时的46%(149/322),p=0.01。
  • 初次短柄THA与标准柄THA的12年总体累积翻修率无差异:4.7%(95%CI 4.0%–5.5%)vs 5.1%(95%CI 4.5%–5.7%),p=0.20。
  • 初次短柄THA与标准柄THA的5年第二次翻修总体累积翻修率无差异:20.9%(95%CI 16.8%–25.8%)vs 20.4%(95%CI 17.3%–23.9%),p=0.80。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,若日后需要翻修,初次THA使用短柄可能存在可感知的益处,因为本研究中短柄更多以标准(更保留骨量)柄进行翻修。
  • 作者认为,短柄THA首次与第二次总体累积翻修率与标准柄THA无差异,这也支持使用短柄THA。
  • 作者提出,应开展进一步研究,最好是跨国登记库研究,以证实本研究结果。

局限性

  • 作者提出,应开展进一步研究,最好是跨国登记库研究,以证实本研究结果。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Advocates of short-stem THA suggest that these devices preserve proximal femoral bone for future revisions. This contention is as yet unsupported by robust evidence, and ultimately, it will be irrelevant if short-stem THA increases the overall risk of premature revision. To our knowledge, large, registry-based efforts have yet to explore the types of stems used in first-time stem revision as well as the survivorship of short versus standard-length femoral stems in THA. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Which stems are used in the first stem revision of primary short-stem and standard-stem THAs? (2) What is the overall cumulative revision rate (CRR) of primary short-stem THAs compared with primary standard-stem THAs? (3) What is the overall cumulative re-revision rate of primary short-stem THAs compared with primary standard-stem THAs? METHODS: Patients with short-stem THAs, defined as a short stem with mainly metaphyseal fixation, registered in the Australian Orthopaedic Association National Joint Replacement Register (AOANJRR), the Dutch Arthroplasty Register (Landelijke Registratie Orthopedische Interventies [LROI]), or the Swedish Arthroplasty Register (SAR) between January 2007 and December 2022 were included (n = 15,771), as well as a propensity score-matched cohort (1:2) with standard-stem THAs, defined as a stem with a standard length (n = 31,542). Groups were matched on sex, age, year of procedure, diagnosis, bearing material, and surgical approach. After matching, the groups did not differ in terms of age (mean ± SD 63 ± 11 versus 64 ± 11 years), sex (48% [7546 of 15,771] male versus 48% [15,093 of 31,542] male), and diagnosis (93% [14,655 of 15,771] osteoarthritis [OA] versus 94% [29,585 of 31,542] OA). We used those three registries because all are high-quality national arthroplasty registries with high levels of completeness. Also, the AOANJRR is the only registry globally that reports on short-stem THA as its own entity. The type of stem used in revision surgery was classified as standard stem (< 160 mm) or long stem (≥ 160 mm). Overall CRR of primary THAs at 12 years of follow-up and overall CRR of all first-time revisions at 5 years were calculated using Kaplan-Meier survival analyses. Any type of revision was used as endpoint. RESULTS: In first-time stem revisions of the short-stem THAs, a standard stem was used more often (58% [116 of 201]) than in the revision of standard-stem THAs (46% [149 of 322]; p = 0.01). The 12-year overall CRRs between primary short-stem and standard-stem THAs did not differ (4.7% [95% confidence interval (CI) 4.0% to 5.5%] versus 5.1% [95% CI 4.5% to 5.7%], respectively; p = 0.20). The overall CRR for a second revision at 5 years also did not differ when primary short-stem THAs were compared with standard-stem THAs (20.9% [95% CI 16.8% to 25.8%]) versus 20.4% [95% CI 17.3% to 23.9%]; p = 0.80). CONCLUSION: In light of these findings, there may be a perceived benefit of using short stems in primary THA if a revision is later required, as the short stems included in this study were to a higher degree revised using a standard (more bone-sparing) stem. Further, the first and second overall CRR of the studied short-stem THAs did not differ from that of standard-stem THAs, also supporting use of short-stem THA. Further research, preferably multinational registry-based studies, should be performed to confirm our findings. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Rilby K, van Veghel MHW, Mohaddes M, et al. Do Cumulative Revision Rate and First-time Re-revision Rate Vary Between Short and Standard Femoral Stem Lengths? A Multinational Registry Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2024. PMID: 40388488. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003354

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。