教育性演示在儿童骨科门诊中的效果
该前瞻性病例系列在儿童骨科门诊为56例新患者提供针对诊断的PowerPoint教育演示,家长在共享医疗决策满意度量表上平均得分43±4分(满分45分),60%的家长将教育演示列为首选学习方式(p < 0.001)。作者认为教育演示似乎有助于信息传递和共享决策,但为每个诊断制作演示不可行,常见诊断的演示可能有助于提高实践效果。
要点
- 家长对教育演示的共享决策满意度量表平均得分为43±4分(满分45分),各分量表平均分均超过4.5分(满分5分)。
- 60%(24/40)的家长将教育演示列为首选学习方式,高于口头解释(23%[9/40])、网页建议(10%[4/40])和印刷材料(8%[3/40])(p < 0.001)。
- 作者认为教育演示似乎有助于信息传递和共享决策,但为每个诊断制作演示不可行,常见诊断的演示可能有助于提高实践效果。
核心结论
- 教育性PowerPoint演示似乎有助于向患者和家庭传递信息并促进共享决策过程。
- 为门诊遇到的每个诊断制作演示不可行,但为最常见诊断制作演示可能有助于提高实践效果。
- 需要进一步研究哪些幻灯片最有效、每种诊断最适合通过PowerPoint传达哪些医疗信息以及阅读水平如何影响患者理解演示的能力。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性病例系列,于2024年5月至2025年1月在门诊儿童骨科手术诊所开展。
- 所有因单一问题初次就诊的新患者接受由资深作者(EDS)通过笔记本电脑提供的针对其诊断的教育性PowerPoint演示。
- 演示为儿童骨科门诊最常见的10种诊断开发,平均耗时4分钟,概述诊断详情、疾病自然史、治疗计划和常见问题解答。
- 共纳入56例患者,平均年龄11±5岁,最常见的疾病为脊柱侧弯(52%[29/56])。
- 就诊后家长或监护人填写共享医疗决策满意度量表(9个问题,评分1至5或「不适用」,最高45分,分数越高表示对诊断和治疗方案的理解越好),并完成首选学习方式排名(56个家庭完成量表,71%(40个)完成排名)。
主要发现
- 家长或监护人在共享医疗决策满意度量表上给出平均±标准差43±4分(满分45分),分数越高代表感知过程越投入和满意。
- 该工具所有分量表的平均分均超过4.5分(满分5分)。
- 将教育演示与既往口头解释、印刷手册或网络资源体验比较,60%(24/40)的家长将教育演示列为首选信息获取方式。
- 口头解释被23%(9/40)的家长列为首选,网页建议被10%(4/40)列为首选,印刷材料被8%(3/40)列为首选(p < 0.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 共享医疗决策满意度量表评分:平均±标准差43±4分(满分45分),各分量表平均分均超过4.5分(满分5分)。
- 首选学习方式排名:教育演示60%(24/40)vs 口头解释23%(9/40)vs 网页建议10%(4/40)vs 印刷材料8%(3/40)(p < 0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 作者指出为门诊遇到的每个诊断制作演示不可行。
- 需要进一步研究哪些幻灯片最有效、每种诊断最适合通过PowerPoint传达哪些医疗信息以及阅读水平如何影响患者理解演示的能力。
- 证据等级为IV级,治疗性研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The patient education process is an important part of healthcare, and tools including handouts, videos, and webpage suggestions have been used to aid this process. Although educational slide presentations are commonly used for teaching in academic settings and have been used in certain specialty clinics, their use for educating families and improving the shared decision-making process has, to our knowledge, not been described in the orthopaedic surgery clinic. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) How effective were educational PowerPoint presentations in the pediatric orthopaedics clinic as assessed by scores on a validated shared decision-making scale? (2) What were the families' preferred ways of learning about healthcare conditions? METHODS: This prospective case series was conducted at an outpatient pediatric orthopaedic surgery clinic. Between May 2024 to January 2025, all new patients whose clinic visit was the initial visit for a single problem received an educational PowerPoint presentation specific to their diagnosis, delivered by the senior author (EDS) from a laptop. These presentations were developed for the top 10 most common diagnoses seen in the pediatric orthopaedic clinic. The presentation took on average 4 minutes to complete and outlined details of the diagnosis, natural history of the condition, treatment plan, and answers to frequently asked questions. Fifty-six patients with mean ± age of 11 ± 5 years were included in this study. The most common condition was scoliosis (52% [29 of 56]). After the clinic visit, the parents or guardians were given the Shared Medical Decision Making Satisfaction Scale, a validated tool that assessed their understanding of the diagnosis, ability to participate in shared decision-making, and perception of the visit. This survey included nine questions scored 1 to 5 or "not applicable" for a maximum score of 45. Higher scores indicated better understanding of the diagnosis and treatment options. Parents or guardians also ranked their preferred ways of learning from a list of four options, with options including educational presentation, verbal explanation, handout, or webpage suggestion. They were asked to draw from past experiences with the different modalities to compare to their experience with the provided educational PowerPoint. Fifty-six families completed the Shared Medical Decision Making Satisfaction Survey; 71% (40) of those families completed the ranking of preferred ways of learning, while the others left it blank for unknown reasons. A chi-square goodness-of-fit test was performed to determine which method of learning was preferred among parents or guardians. RESULTS: Parents or guardians of the children treated generally gave the educational tool (the brief PowerPoint presentation about the child's condition) very high scores on the Shared Medical Decision Making Satisfaction Scale (mean ± SD 43 ± 4 of a possible 45 points, with higher scores representing the perception of a more engaging and satisfying process). Mean scores on all of the subscales of that tool exceeded 4.5 of a possible 5 points. When asked to compare their experience with the educational PowerPoint presentation to earlier experiences with verbal explanations, printed handouts, or web-based resources, the presentation was the preferred mode of receiving information; 60% (24 of 40) ranked this as the preferred approach, compared with verbal explanation (23% [9 of 40]), webpage suggestion (10% [4 of 40]), and printed materials (8% [3 of 40]) (p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: Educational PowerPoint presentations seemed useful in delivering information to patients and families and in the facilitating of the shared decision-making process. Creating presentations for every diagnosis encountered in clinic is not feasible; however, presentations for the most common diagnoses may help to create a more effective practice. Further studies are warranted to investigate which slides are most effective, which healthcare information is best conveyed over PowerPoint for each diagnosis, and how reading level affects the ability of patients to understand the presentations. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, therapeutic study.
引用
- Abraham VM, Shirley ED. Efficacy of Educational Presentations in the Pediatric Orthopaedics Clinic. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 40331676. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003539
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。