骨水泥股骨假体设计与预防性钢丝置入对初次全髋关节置换术后早期假体周围股骨骨折的影响:一项生物力学研究
该生物力学研究将21根锥形滑移(TS)股骨柄(8根单独、6根加股骨距钢丝、7根加股骨距远端2cm处骨干钢丝)和7根复合梁(CB)股骨柄骨水泥固定于标准人工骨,测量失效峰值扭矩。CB柄峰值扭矩显著高于TS柄、加股骨距钢丝TS柄和加骨干钢丝TS柄;加钢丝的TS柄并未比未加钢丝TS柄承受更高扭矩。作者认为CB柄抗扭矩能力更强,可能解释其假体周围骨折风险较低,并建议骨折高风险患者考虑使用CB骨水泥柄。
要点
- CB柄平均失效峰值扭矩205.3 Nm,显著高于TS柄的159.5 Nm(p=0.012)。
- 加股骨距钢丝TS柄148.2 Nm、加骨干钢丝TS柄164.9 Nm,均显著低于CB柄(p=0.031、p=0.027)。
- 加钢丝的TS柄未显示比未加钢丝TS柄更高的失效峰值扭矩,股骨距钢丝也不比骨干钢丝更强(p=0.400)。
核心结论
- 在该模型中,CB柄抗扭矩能力大于TS柄,可能解释其假体周围骨折风险较低。
- 给TS柄加股骨距或骨干钢丝后,骨折前峰值扭矩无显著变化。
- 作者认为,假体周围骨折高风险患者应考虑使用CB骨水泥柄。
研究设计与样本
- 生物力学研究:21根TS柄(8根单独、6根加股骨距钢丝、7根加股骨距远端2cm处骨干钢丝)和7根CB柄骨水泥固定于标准人工骨。
- 使用伺服液压试验机测量失效峰值扭矩并记录骨折位置。
- 先验效能分析确定每组需7个标本,以90%效能检测30 Nm差异,假设组间峰值扭矩标准差为14.8 Nm。
- 比较采用配对t检验。
主要发现
- CB柄平均失效峰值扭矩205.3 Nm(SD 26.9),显著高于TS柄159.5 Nm(SD 17.4;p=0.012)。
- CB柄显著高于加股骨距钢丝TS柄148.2 Nm(SD 38.6;p=0.031)和加骨干钢丝TS柄164.9 Nm(SD 21.5;p=0.027)。
- 本研究未证明加钢丝TS柄的失效峰值扭矩高于未加钢丝TS柄。
- 股骨距钢丝未显示比骨干钢丝更强(p=0.400)。
- 4例CB骨折发生在柄远端,而所有TS骨折均发生在柄中段,模拟Vancouver B型骨折。
关键数值与推荐
- 加股骨距钢丝TS柄148.2 Nm(SD 38.6)vs 加骨干钢丝TS柄164.9 Nm(SD 21.5),p=0.400。
- 加骨干钢丝使7根中4根骨折位置更向远端移位(p=0.070)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,假体周围骨折高风险患者应考虑使用CB骨水泥柄。
- 本研究未证明给TS柄加股骨距或骨干钢丝能提高失效峰值扭矩。
局限性
- 本研究未证明加钢丝TS柄的失效峰值扭矩高于未加钢丝TS柄。
- 股骨距钢丝未显示比骨干钢丝更强(p=0.400)。
- 加骨干钢丝使骨折位置更向远端移位未达统计学显著(p=0.070)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Previous studies have highlighted differences in the risk of periprosthetic fractures (PPFs) in patients undergoing total hip arthroplasty with either a cemented taper slip (TS) stem or a composite beam (CB) stem. This biomechanical study explored the occurrence of PPF around these stems, and the protective effect of adding a 16-gauge prophylactic calcar or diaphyseal wire to the TS stems to increase the resistance to torque as a potential way to prevent these fractures. METHODS: A total of 21 TS stems (eight alone, six with calcar wiring, and seven with diaphyseal wiring placed 2 cm distal to the lesser trochanter) and seven CB stems were cemented into standard sawbones. The peak torque at failure was measured using a servohydraulic test machine, and the fracture location was recorded. An a priori power analysis determined that seven specimens per group were needed to detect a 30 Nm difference with 90% power, assuming a 14.8 Nm SD in peak torque between groups. Comparisons were performed using paired t-tests. RESULTS: CB stems exhibited a significantly higher mean peak torque at failure (205.3 Nm (SD 26.9)) than TS stems (159.5 Nm (SD 17.4); p = 0.012), calcar-wired TS (148.2 Nm (SD 38.6); p = 0.031), and diaphyseal-wired TS (164.9 Nm (SD 21.5); p = 0.027). This study did not demonstrate that wired-TS stems had a higher peak torque at failure than non-wired TS stems. Additionally, calcar wiring was not found to be stronger than diaphyseal wiring (p = 0.400). Four CB fractures occurred distal to the stem, whereas all TS fractures occurred at the mid-stem, simulating a Vancouver type B fracture. Interestingly, adding the diaphyseal wire shifted the fracture location more distally in four of the seven stems (p = 0.070). CONCLUSION: In this model, CB stems had greater resistance to torque than TS stems, which may explain the lower risk of PPF. Adding calcar or diaphyseal wires to the TS stems resulted in no significant change in peak torque to fracture. CB cemented stems should be considered in patients at high risk of PPF.
引用
- Guarin Perez SF, Zhao G, Tsukamoto I, et al. The effect of cemented femoral component design and prophylactic wire placement against early periprosthetic femoral fracture in primary total hip arthroplasty : a biomechanical study. Bone Joint J. 2025. PMID: 40306725. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.107B5.BJJ-2024-1116.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。