文献速递关节外科创伤骨科

假体周围关节感染诊断标准报告与使用中的差异:范围综述及对标准化报告框架的呼吁

Discrepancies in Periprosthetic Joint Infection Diagnostic Criteria Reporting and Use: A Scoping Review and Call for a Standard Reporting Framework.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2025-03-12

该范围综述评估了2012年至2022年间引用假体周围关节感染(PJI)定义的研究,发现2011年MSIS定义最常被引用(40%),31%的研究在方法中详述了定义,19%的研究所述定义与引用来源不一致,其中85%声称使用受认可定义却引用了未获认可的2018年定义。作者建议学术团体建立标准化报告框架。

要点

  • 2011年MSIS定义最常被引用(40%),其次为2013年MSIS/ICM定义(30%)。
  • 仅31%的研究在方法中详述了PJI定义,18%的研究对定义进行了修改。
  • 19%的研究所述PJI定义与引用来源不一致,其中85%声称使用受认可定义却引用了未获认可的2018年定义。

核心结论

  • 2011/2013年MSIS的PJI定义尽管有更新的定义可用,截至2022年仍被广泛引用。
  • 许多PJI定义研究缺乏方法学透明度,妨碍了可重复性和有效性评估。
  • 引用错误率高及广泛使用未获认可的评分系统,代表了现有科学记录中的系统性错误。

研究设计与样本

  • 范围综述,检索PubMed 2012年1月1日至2023年8月1日发表的PJI研究,识别出16篇出版物中的6个正式PJI定义。
  • 通过后向引用这16篇出版物,识别出2012年1月1日至2022年12月31日间引用这些定义的457项研究。
  • 457项研究分布于《Journal of Arthroplasty》n=285、《Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research》n=69、《Bone and Joint Journal》n=58、《Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery》n=45。

主要发现

  • 457项研究中,2011年MSIS定义被引用40%(183项),2013年MSIS/ICM定义30%(139项),未获认可的2018年定义14%(65项),2018年ICM定义3.7%(17项),2013年IDSA定义3.5%(16项),2021年EBJIS定义1项,7.9%(36项)引用多个定义。
  • 31%(141/457)的研究在名称和引用之外详述了PJI定义,18%(83/457)的研究对定义进行了修改。
  • 使用含不确定分类定义的研究中,18%(18/98)提供了不确定组的详细信息。
  • 19%(86/457)的研究方法部分所述PJI定义与引用来源不一致,其中85%(73/86)引用了未获认可的2018年定义却声称使用受认可定义。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议学术团体为使用正式PJI定义的研究建立标准化报告框架和清单,类似PRISMA、CONSORT和STROBE。
  • MSIS和EBJIS正在创建受认可的标准化报告框架,旨在提高PJI研究的报告透明度。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Numerous criterion-based definitions of periprosthetic joint infection (PJI) with differing criteria and point systems have been published, but the frequency of their use or application to study methods in publications on PJI has not been evaluated. Assessing the use of these definitions in studies is an important step to ensuring the validity and reproducibility of PJI research and to determining best practices for the application of these definitions in future research. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: As a scoping review, we identified and evaluated studies published since 2012 that defined PJI, and we asked: (1) Which of those definitions are cited most frequently in other peer-reviewed publications? (2) How often are the definition criteria and scoring systems reported in the methods beyond the name or citation or modified from the published definition? (3) How often did the PJI definition stated in a citing study's methods section fail to align with the definition provided in the cited source? METHODS: To identify published PJI definition citations, we queried PubMed for studies on PJI published between January 1, 2012, and August 1, 2023, identifying 75 unique citations in studies with human patients diagnosed with PJI. This study focused on PJI definitions detailing specific clinical and laboratory criteria for PJI, recognizing and including six formal definitions for PJI presented across 16 publications: the 2011 Musculoskeletal Infection Society (MSIS), 2013 MSIS/International Consensus Meeting (ICM), 2013 Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA), 2018 ICM, and 2021 European Bone and Joint Infection Society (EBJIS) definitions, and an unendorsed 2018 Definition. Back citation of these 16 publications identified 457 studies (Journal of Arthroplasty n = 285, Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research n = 69, Bone and Joint Journal n = 58, Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery n = 45) published between January 1, 2012, and December 31, 2022, that cited one of the identified PJI definition citations. Trends in PJI definition citation and reporting were assessed based on the following criteria: (1) the PJI definition claimed in the methods, (2) the cited reference to this claim, (3) the description of the definition in the manuscript, and (4) the definition modification. RESULTS: Of 457 studies published between 2012 and 2022 that cited at least one PJI definition, the most cited was the 2011 MSIS definition (40% [183 studies]), followed by the 2013 MSIS/ICM definition (30% [139]), the unendorsed 2018 Definition (14% [65]), the 2018 ICM definition (3.7% [17]), the 2013 IDSA definition (3.5% [16]), and the 2021 EBJIS definition (one study); 7.9% (36) cited multiple definitions. Overall, 31% (141 of 457) of studies detailed the PJI definition beyond its name and citation. Authors modified definitions in 18% (83 of 457) of studies. Of the 98 studies using a definition with an inconclusive category, 18% (18 of 98) provided details on the inconclusive group. The PJI definition stated in the methods section did not align with the cited source in 19% (86 of 457) of studies. Of these, 85% (73 of 86) cited the unendorsed 2018 Definition while claiming use of an endorsed definition. CONCLUSION: The 2011/2013 MSIS definitions of PJI remain commonly cited through 2022 despite the availability of newer definitions. Many studies on PJI definitions suffer from a lack of methodological transparency, hindering both reproducibility and the assessment of their validity. There also exists an alarming rate of citation errors and widespread use of unendorsed scoring systems despite claims of adherence to accepted standards, representing a systematic error in the existing scientific record. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: In response to these findings, we recommend that academic societies establish a standard reporting framework and checklist for studies using formal PJI definitions, such as those that exist for systematic reviews (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses [PRISMA]), randomized trials (Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials [CONSORT]), and observational studies (Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology [STROBE]). The MSIS and EBJIS, as discussed in an accompanying letter to the editor, are creating an endorsed standard reporting framework that aims to improve reporting transparency in the PJI research.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hohmann AL, DeSimone CA, Lowenstein NA, et al. Discrepancies in Periprosthetic Joint Infection Diagnostic Criteria Reporting and Use: A Scoping Review and Call for a Standard Reporting Framework. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 40153676. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003457

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。