定制关节周围注射鸡尾酒制剂与全关节置换术中的重大经济负担相关
该研究评估了某单中心20名关节置换外科医生使用的16种关节周围注射(PAI)配方成本,并与术中制备的布比卡因注射进行比较。定制鸡尾酒的平均成分成本为10.33美元,比布比卡因注射高435%,年成分成本为22,496.17美元,年 labor 成本为93,600美元,消除定制鸡尾酒每年可为机构节省116,096.17美元,且仅用布比卡因与外科医生定制PAI配方的住院疼痛评分无显著差异。
要点
- 定制PAI鸡尾酒平均成分成本10.33美元,比布比卡因注射高435%。
- 消除定制鸡尾酒并采用单纯布比卡因每年可为机构节省116,096.17美元。
- 仅用布比卡因与外科医生定制PAI配方的住院疼痛评分无显著差异。
核心结论
- 外科医生定制PAI配方通过药物采购成本和每种独特组合的 labor 成本给医院系统带来较大且某种程度上隐性的开支。
- 由于仅用布比卡因PAI在全关节置换患者中达到满意临床结局,从价值医疗角度看消除定制鸡尾酒具有重大益处。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心研究,识别20名关节置换外科医生使用的16种独特PAI配方,每种由该机构药房和护理人员制备。
- 成本包括鸡尾酒各药物成分成本和制备相关 labor 成本,并与手术室内制备布比卡因注射进行比较。
- 基于该机构年全关节置换量外推潜在成本节省。
主要发现
- 外科医生定制配方平均成分成本为10.33美元,比布比卡因注射高435%,PAI年成分成本为22,496.17美元。
- 制备这些鸡尾酒每年需要总 labor 成本93,600美元。
- 消除定制鸡尾酒并采用单纯布比卡因每年可为机构节省116,096.17美元。
- 仅用布比卡因与外科医生定制PAI配方之间的住院疼痛评分无显著差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Periarticular injections (PAIs) are an important component in modern multimodal pain management protocols for total joint arthroplasty. There is a wide variety of formulas reported in the literature, from simple bupivacaine to surgeon-specific "cocktails" that include up to seven different components. Due to the broad lack of standardization in PAI formulations, this study aimed to evaluate the cost savings associated with our institution's transition to a standardized approach while ensuring no adverse impact on inpatient pain outcomes. METHODS: We identified 16 unique PAI formulations used by 20 arthroplasty surgeons at a single institution, each prepared by the institution's pharmacy and nursing staff. Costs associated with the PAI formulations included the cost of each medication comprising the "cocktail" and the labor cost associated with their preparation. These costs were compared to the in-operating room preparation of bupivacaine injections. An evaluation of the potential cost savings was extrapolated based on our annual total joint volume. RESULTS: The average surgeon-specific formulation costs $10.33 for ingredients alone, which is 435% higher than a bupivacaine injection and leads to an annual ingredient cost of $22,496.17 for PAIs. The preparation of these cocktails required a total labor cost of $93,600 annually. Taken together, the elimination of custom cocktails and the adoption of isolated bupivacaine translated into institutional savings of $116,096.17 per year. Inpatient pain scores were not significantly different between bupivacaine-only and surgeon-specific PAI formulations. CONCLUSIONS: Surgeon-specific PAI formulations impose a large, somewhat hidden expense on hospital systems through the cost of sourcing medications and, in particular, the labor cost of preparing each unique combination. As bupivacaine-only PAI achieves satisfactory clinical outcomes for joint arthroplasty patients, the elimination of custom cocktails is of major benefit from a value-based care perspective.
引用
- Taylor WL, Saleh JN, Bergstein VE, et al. Custom Periarticular Injection Cocktail Preparations Are Associated With a Major Financial Burden in Total Joint Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2025. PMID: 40058509. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2025.03.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。