支点弯曲X线片在估算青少年特发性脊柱侧凸术后转归中的准确性如何:系统评价与Meta分析
该系统评价与Meta分析检索6个数据库至2024年8月27日,纳入11项研究,评估支点弯曲X线片估算青少年特发性脊柱侧凸患者行单阶段后路脊柱融合术后冠状面矫正的准确性。结果显示支点弯曲X线片倾向于低估术后矫正,但差异无临床重要性;更柔软的主胸弯和近端胸弯与较少低估相关。
要点
- 支点弯曲X线片估算术后即刻矫正平均差为-0.6°(95%CI -0.9°至-0.4°),倾向于低估但无临床重要性。
- 术后2年随访平均差为-0.43°(95%CI -0.6°至-0.2°),支点弯曲矫正指数为1.10(95%CI 1.04至1.16)。
- 更柔韧的弯曲和近端胸弯与较少低估相关;僵硬弯曲的解释需谨慎,可考虑牵引等其他柔韧性评估方法。
核心结论
- 支点弯曲X线片能可靠估算术后冠状面矫正,所观察到的低估程度在某些终点上太小而无临床意义。
- 尽管存在明显统计学异质性,但所有研究的效应方向相似。
- 使用交替椎弓根螺钉固定时支点弯曲估算也可靠;更柔韧的弯曲和近端胸弯与较少低估相关。
- 在更僵硬的弯曲中,支点弯曲估算结果应谨慎解释,可考虑如牵引等其他柔韧性评估方法。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与Meta分析,检索PubMed、Embase、Medline、Journals@Ovid、Web of Science和Scopus自建库至2024年8月27日。
- 纳入标准:青少年特发性脊柱侧凸患者行单阶段后路脊柱融合术且未行前路松解、使用支点弯曲X线片、评估影像学手术结局、随访至少2年。
- 排除标准:未评估支点弯曲X线片使用、未报告p值、方法学质量差的研究;初始检索433篇,去重后172篇,最终11项研究纳入分析。
- 采用纽卡斯尔-渥太华质量评估量表评价证据质量,11项纳入研究中除1项质量差被排除外均为高质量。
- 因存在明显统计学异质性(I²>50%)采用随机效应Meta分析合并数据;绝对矫正估算用标准化均数差(称为均数差),百分比矫正估算用矫正率与支点柔韧性比值的均数比(称为支点弯曲矫正指数FBCI)。
主要发现
- 术后即刻均数差为-0.6°(95%CI -0.9°至-0.4°,p<0.001),术后即刻FBCI为1.15(95%CI 1.09至1.21,p<0.001)。
- 术后2年随访均数差为-0.43°(95%CI -0.6°至-0.2°,p<0.001),术后2年随访FBCI为1.10(95%CI 1.04至1.16,p=0.001)。
- 校正潜在混杂因素后发现更柔韧的弯曲(回归系数0.07[95%CI 0.01至0.13],p=0.02)与较少低估相关。
- 术后即刻主胸弯与近端胸弯均数差为-0.8°(95%CI -1.4°至-0.2°,p=0.01),术后2年随访主胸弯与近端胸弯均数差为-0.7°(95%CI -1.3°至-0.1°,p=0.03),近端胸弯与较少低估相关。
- 节段性与交替水平螺钉置入与支点弯曲X线片低估矫正相关但临床不重要;节段性螺钉置入术后即刻均数差-1.0°(95%CI -1.9°至-0.1°,p<0.001),术后2年随访均数差-1.0°(95%CI -1.6°至-0.4°,p<0.001);仅1项研究使用节段性螺钉置入策略,证据不确定。
关键数值与推荐
- 支点弯曲X线片估算术后即刻矫正均数差-0.6°(95%CI -0.9°至-0.4°,p<0.001),FBCI 1.15(95%CI 1.09至1.21,p<0.001)。
- 支点弯曲X线片估算术后2年随访矫正均数差-0.43°(95%CI -0.6°至-0.2°,p<0.001),FBCI 1.10(95%CI 1.04至1.16,p=0.001)。
- 更柔韧弯曲回归系数0.07(95%CI 0.01至0.13,p=0.02);近端胸弯术后即刻均数差-0.8°(95%CI -1.4°至-0.2°,p=0.01),2年随访均数差-0.7°(95%CI -1.3°至-0.1°,p=0.03)。
- 节段性螺钉置入术后即刻均数差-1.0°(95%CI -1.9°至-0.1°,p<0.001),2年随访均数差-1.0°(95%CI -1.6°至-0.4°,p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 支点弯曲X线片可用于估算青少年特发性脊柱侧凸行单阶段后路脊柱融合术后冠状面矫正。
- 使用交替椎弓根螺钉固定时支点弯曲估算也可靠。
- 在更僵硬的弯曲中,支点弯曲估算结果应谨慎解释,作者认为可考虑如牵引等其他柔韧性评估方法。
局限性
- 纳入研究存在明显统计学异质性(I²>50%)。
- 关于节段性与交替水平螺钉置入低估程度差异的证据不确定,因仅1项研究使用节段性螺钉置入策略。
- 支点柔韧性与冠状面失衡、肩部失衡关系的证据不确定,因仅2项或更少研究报告。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Fulcrum bending radiographs can be used to assess coronal flexibility in patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) to estimate postoperative correction. To obtain fulcrum bending radiographs, patients are passively bent over a radiolucent fulcrum at the apex of the curve. Available studies have disagreed about the accuracy in estimating postoperative correction, although these studies differed in terms of patients' baseline characteristics as well as other methods. Moreover, factors associated with accuracy were never explored. By pooling (meta-analyzing) results from these studies, we hoped to address these gaps in knowledge. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In a meta-analysis, we asked: (1) Can fulcrum bending radiographs accurately estimate postoperative curve correction in patients with AIS? (2) What factors are associated with the accuracy of fulcrum bending estimation on postoperative coronal correction? (3) Is fulcrum flexibility associated with other surgical outcomes such as shoulder and coronal balance? METHODS: PubMed, Embase, Medline, Journals@Ovid, Web of Science, and Scopus were searched from their inception up to August 27, 2024. Studies that (1) included patients with AIS undergoing single-stage posterior spinal fusion surgery without anterior release, (2) used fulcrum bending radiographs, (3) assessed radiographic surgical outcomes, and (4) had a minimum follow-up of 2 years were included. Studies that did not evaluate the use of fulcrum bending radiographs, those that did not report a p value, and studies with poor methodological quality were excluded. Our initial search yielded 433 articles, of which 172 remained after duplicate articles were removed. A total of 161 articles were excluded as the studies included patients who did not have AIS (n = 14), did not undergo surgery (n = 14), or did not undergo posterior spinal fusion (n = 23) or the studies did not evaluate the use of fulcrum bending radiographs (n = 59); had an insufficient follow-up duration of < 2 years (n = 15); did not evaluate the relationship between fulcrum bending radiographs and postoperative outcomes (n = 1); were reviews, commentaries, articles, conference proceedings, or non-English studies (n = 33); were animal studies (n = 1); or had poor methodological quality (n = 1). This left 11 studies for analysis. The Newcastle-Ottawa Quality Assessment Scale was used to evaluate the quality of evidence in three domains, including participant selection, comparability, and outcome measurement. Eleven included studies were of good quality except one with poor-quality evidence that was subsequently excluded from analysis. A random-effects meta-analysis was used to pool the data because of substantial statistical heterogeneity (I 2 > 50%) in the included studies. The estimation of absolute correction was pooled using standardized mean differences, referred to as the mean difference; a value > 0 indicated overestimation and vice versa. Estimation of percentage correction was pooled using ratio of means between correction rate and fulcrum flexibility, referred to as fulcrum bending correction index (FBCI); a value > 1 indicated underestimation and vice versa. RESULTS: Fulcrum bending radiographs tended to underestimate postoperative curve correction, although the difference was not clinically important (immediate postoperative mean difference -0.6° [95% confidence interval (CI) -0.9° to -0.4°], p < 0.001; immediate postoperative FBCI 1.15 [95% CI 1.09 to 1.21], p < 0.001; 2-year follow-up mean difference -0.43° [95% CI -0.6° to -0.2°], p < 0.001; 2-year follow-up FBCI 1.10 [95% CI 1.04 to 1.16], p = 0.001). To address the high between-study heterogeneity, we adjusted for potential confounders, which found that more flexible curves (regression coefficient 0.07 [95% CI 0.01 to 0.13]; p = 0.02) and proximal thoracic (immediate postoperative main thoracic versus proximal thoracic curves mean difference -0.8° [95% CI -1.4° to -0.2°], p = 0.01; 2-year follow-up main thoracic versus proximal thoracic curves mean difference -0.7° [95% CI -1.3° to -0.1°], p = 0.03) curves were associated with less underestimation. Segmental and alternate level screw placement were associated with underestimation of curve correction by fulcrum bending radiographs, although the difference was clinically unimportant. The degree of underestimation was worse with segmental screw placement at immediate postoperative (mean difference -1.0° [95% CI -1.9° to -0.1°]; p < 0.001) and 2-year follow-up (mean difference -1.0° [95% CI -1.6° to -0.4°]; p < 0.001). However, evidence surrounding more serious underestimation in segmental compared with alternate level screw placement was uncertain as only one study used a segmental screw placement strategy. Regarding the relationship between fulcrum flexibility and other radiographic outcomes, more rigid main thoracic curves were at risk of coronal imbalance, while more flexible curves were associated with postoperative shoulder imbalance. However, the evidence was inconclusive as it was reported by two or fewer studies. CONCLUSION: Fulcrum bending radiographs offer a reliable estimate of postoperative coronal correction; the amount of underestimation that we observed on some endpoints was too small to be clinically meaningful. Although there was substantial statistical heterogeneity, the direction of effect was similar across all studies. Fulcrum bending estimation was also reliable when using alternate pedicle screw constructs. More flexible curves and proximal thoracic curves were associated with less underestimation. In more rigid curves, results of fulcrum bending estimation should be interpreted with caution, and alternate flexibility assessment methods such as traction should be considered. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, diagnostic study.
引用
- Hui VYT, Cheung STY, Cheung JPY, et al. How Accurate Are Fulcrum Bending Radiographs in Estimating Postoperative Outcomes in Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 40132870. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003468
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。