基于机器学习算法预测胫骨平台骨折治疗后2年和5年全膝关节置换术风险的模型开发
该多中心横断面研究纳入2003至2019年六家医院2057例胫骨平台骨折患者,构建逻辑回归、随机森林和XGBoost三种机器学习模型预测2年和5年全膝关节置换术(TKA)转换风险。三种模型AUC范围0.76至0.83,逻辑回归校准最佳(2年斜率0.82,5年斜率0.95),被选为最终预测模型并开发免费网络应用。作者结论认为逻辑回归可提供准确可靠的预测,但需外部验证。
要点
- 2年和5年TKA转换率分别为7%(79/1160)和10%(109/1082)。
- 三种机器学习模型AUC范围0.76至0.83,敏感性及特异性无差异。
- 逻辑回归校准最优,选为最终模型并开发免费网络预测工具。
核心结论
- 作者结论认为机器学习算法特别是逻辑回归可对胫骨平台骨折后2年和5年TKA转换提供准确可靠的预测。
- 作者指出该个性化风险评估工具可支持临床决策和患者咨询,但需外部验证以评估其他机构和国家中的性能。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心横断面研究,在六家医院纳入2003至2019年治疗的胫骨平台骨折患者。
- 2057例符合纳入标准并收到知情同意书和问卷;56%(1160/2057)至少随访2年,53%(1082/2057)至少随访5年。
- 应答者平均随访6±4年;采用六折交叉验证,用五家中心数据训练、剩余一家中心验证。
- 构建逻辑回归、随机森林和XGBoost三种模型,以AUC、校准斜率和截距、Brier评分评估性能。
主要发现
- 2年和5年TKA转换率分别为7%(79/1160)和10%(109/1082)。
- 三种模型AUC范围0.76至0.83,敏感性及特异性无差异。
- 逻辑回归校准最佳:2年斜率0.82(随机森林0.60,XGBoost 0.26),5年斜率0.95(随机森林0.85,XGBoost 0.48);截距均为0.01(随机森林0.01至0.02,XGBoost 0.05至0.07)。
- Brier评分在各模型间相似,范围0.06至0.09。
- 应答者较无应答者年龄稍大(53±16岁 vs 51±17岁,p=0.001),女性更多(68%[788/1160] vs 58%[523/897],p=0.001),非手术治疗更少(30%[346/1160] vs 43%[387/897],p=0.001),骨折间隙更大(6.4±6.3 mm vs 4.2±5.2 mm,p<0.001),台阶更大(6.3±5.7 mm vs 4.5±4.7 mm,p<0.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 模型纳入特征包括年龄、性别、BMI、AO/OTA骨折分型、骨折移位(间隙、台阶)、胫骨近端内侧对线和胫骨近端后侧对线。
- 最终预测模型为逻辑回归,免费网络应用可通过https://3dtrauma.shinyapps.io/tka_prediction/访问。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为该工具可在临床或急诊科快速简便地用于患者,但需符合医疗器械法规。
- 作者指出外部验证是必要的,以评估其他机构和国家中的性能,并考虑患者和外科医生偏好、资源和文化。
局限性
- 外部验证是必要的,以评估其他机构和国家中的性能,并考虑患者和外科医生偏好、资源和文化。
- 应答者与无应答者在年龄、性别、非手术治疗比例、骨折间隙和台阶大小上存在差异(p值均<0.05),AO/OTA分型无差异(p=0.26)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: When faced with a severe intraarticular injury like a tibial plateau fracture, patients count on surgeons to make an accurate estimation of prognosis. Unfortunately, there are few tools available that enable precise, personalized prognosis estimation tailored to each patient's unique circumstances, including their individual and fracture-specific characteristics. In this study, we developed and validated a clinical prediction model using machine-learning algorithms for the 2- and 5-year risk of TKA after tibia plateau fractures. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Can machine learning-based probability calculators estimate the probability of 2- and 5-year risk of conversion to TKA in patients with a tibial plateau fracture? METHODS: A multicenter, cross-sectional study was performed in six hospitals in patients treated for a tibial plateau fracture between 2003 to 2019. In total, 2057 patients were eligible for inclusion and were sent informed consent and a questionnaire to inquire whether they underwent conversion to TKA. For 56% (1160 of 2057), status of conversion to TKA was accounted for at a minimum of 2 years, and 53% (1082 of 2057) were accounted for at a minimum of 5 years. The mean follow-up among responders was 6 ± 4 years after injury. An analysis of nonresponders found that responders were slightly older than nonresponders (53 ± 16 years versus 51 ± 17 years; p = 0.001), they were more often women (68% [788 of 1160] versus 58% [523 of 897]; p = 0.001), they were treated nonoperatively less often (30% [346 of 1160] versus 43% [387 of 897]; p = 0.001), and they had larger fracture gaps (6.4 ± 6.3 mm versus 4.2 ± 5.2 mm; p < 0.001) and step-offs (6.3 ± 5.7 mm versus 4.5 ± 4.7 mm; p < 0.001). AO Foundation/Orthopaedic Trauma Association (AO/OTA) fracture classification did not differ between nonresponders and responders (B1 11% versus 15%, B2 16% versus 19%, B3 45% versus 39%, C2 6% versus 8%, C3 22% versus 17%; p = 0.26). A total of 70% (814 of 1160) of patients were treated with open reduction and internal fixation, whereas 30% (346 of 1160) of patients were treated nonoperatively with a cast. Most fractures (80% [930 of 1160]) were AO/OTA type B fractures, and 20% (230 of 1160) were type C. Of these patients, 7% (79 of 1160) and 10% (109 of 1082) underwent conversion to a TKA at 2- and 5-year follow-up, respectively. Patient characteristics were retrieved from electronic patient records, and imaging data were shared with the initiating center from which fracture characteristics were determined. Obtained features derived from follow-up questionnaires, electronic patient records, and radiographic assessments were eligible for development of the prediction model. The first step consisted of data cleaning and included simple type formatting and standardization of numerical columns. Subsequent feature selection consisted of a review of the published evidence and expert opinion. This was followed by bivariate analysis of the identified features. The features for the models included: age, gender, BMI, AO/OTA fracture classification, fracture displacement (gap, step-off), medial proximal tibial alignment, and posterior proximal tibial alignment. The data set was used to train three models: logistic regression, random forest, and XGBoost. Logistic regression models linear relationships, random forest handles nonlinear complexities with decision trees, and XGBoost excels with sequential error correction and regularization. The models were tested using a sixfold validation approach by training the model on data from five (of six) respective medical centers and validating it against the remaining center that was left out for training. Performance was assessed by the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC), which measures a model's ability to distinguish between classes. AUC varies between 0 and 1, with values closer to 1 indicating better performance. To ensure robust and reliable results, we used bootstrapping as a resampling technique. In addition, calibration curves were plotted, and calibration was assessed with the calibration slope and intercept. The calibration plot compares the estimated probabilities with the observed probabilities for the primary outcome. Calibration slope evaluates alignment between predicted probabilities and observed outcomes (1 = perfect, < 1 = overfit, > 1 = underfit). Calibration intercept indicates bias (0 = perfect, negative = underestimation, positive = overestimation). Last, the Brier score, measuring the mean squared error of predicted probabilities (0 = perfect), was calculated. RESULTS: There were no differences among the models in terms of sensitivity and specificity; the AUCs for each overlapped broadly and ranged from 0.76 to 0.83. Calibration was most optimal in logistic regression for both 2- and 5-year models, with slopes of 0.82 (random forest 0.60, XGBoost 0.26) and 0.95 (random forest 0.85, XGBoost 0.48) and intercepts of 0.01 for both (random forest 0.01 to 0.02; XGBoost 0.05 to 0.07). Brier score was similar between models varying between 0.06 to 0.09. Given that its performance metrics were highest, we chose the logistic regression algorithm as the final prediction model. The web application providing the prediction tool is freely available and can be accessed through: https://3dtrauma.shinyapps.io/tka_prediction/ . CONCLUSION: In this study, a personalized risk assessment tool was developed to support clinical decision-making and patient counseling. Our findings demonstrate that machine-learning algorithms, particularly logistic regression, can provide accurate and reliable predictions of TKA conversion at 2 and 5 years after a tibial plateau fracture. In addition, it provides a useful prognostic tool for surgeons who perform fracture surgery that can be used quickly and easily with patients in the clinic or emergency department once it complies with medical device regulations. External validation is needed to assess performance in other institutions and countries; to account for patient and surgeon preferences, resources, and cultures; and to further strengthen its clinical applicability. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Assink N, Gonzalez-Perrino MP, Santana-Trejo R, et al. Development of Machine Learning-based Algorithms to Predict the 2- and 5-year Risk of TKA After Tibial Plateau Fracture Treatment. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 40106382. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003442
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。