蛋白质与运动联合干预对中老年人骨骼健康的影响——随机对照试验的系统文献综述与荟萃分析
该系统综述与荟萃分析检索截至2023年1月24日的多个数据库,评估蛋白质联合运动对比单独运动或单独蛋白质对中老年人骨矿物质含量或密度的影响。联合补充蛋白质与运动对比单独运动时,骨矿物质含量合并效应量WMD 0.03 kg(95%CI -0.00至0.05;4项RCT;干预组97例/对照组98例;I²=58.4%),几乎无干预效果;敏感性分析限制为牛奶蛋白补充联合运动,结果相似(0.01 kg;95%CI -0.01至0.03;4项RCT;干预组71例/对照组71例;I²=0.0%;低证据质量)。联合干预对比单独蛋白质时无骨矿物质含量RCT,骨密度结果不确定。结论认为无法得出稳健结论,需足够把握度、更长 duration 的研究。
要点
- 联合蛋白质补充与运动对比单独运动,骨矿物质含量WMD 0.03 kg(95%CI -0.00至0.05;4项RCT;干预组97例/对照组98例;I²=58.4%),几乎无干预效果。
- 敏感性分析限制为牛奶蛋白补充联合运动,骨矿物质含量WMD 0.01 kg(95%CI -0.01至0.03;4项RCT;干预组71例/对照组71例;I²=0.0%;低证据质量)。
- 联合蛋白质与运动对比单独蛋白质,无骨矿物质含量RCT,骨密度结果不确定,无法得出联合干预是否优于单一成分的稳健结论。
核心结论
- 基于本研究发现,无法就蛋白质与运动联合干预是否比单一成分更有利于骨骼健康得出稳健结论。
- 需要足够把握度、持续时间更长的研究来阐明这些问题(CRD42022334026)。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与荟萃分析,检索Medline、CINAHL、CENTRAL、Web of Science和SPORTDiscus至2023年1月24日。
- 纳入随机对照试验(RCT),对象为中老年人,比较联合蛋白质与运动干预对比单独运动或单独蛋白质对骨矿物质含量或密度的影响。
- 采用配对随机效应荟萃分析计算加权均数差(WMD)及95%置信区间(95%CI),使用Cochrane RoB2评估偏倚风险,GRADE评估证据质量。
- 无法合并时进行描述性总结。
主要发现
- 联合蛋白质补充与运动对比单独运动,骨矿物质含量WMD 0.03 kg(95%CI -0.00至0.05;4项RCT;干预组97例/对照组98例;I²=58.4%),几乎无干预效果。
- 敏感性分析限制为牛奶蛋白补充联合运动,骨矿物质含量WMD 0.01 kg(95%CI -0.01至0.03;4项RCT;干预组71例/对照组71例;I²=0.0%;低证据质量),结果相似。
- 联合蛋白质与运动对比单独运动,骨密度无荟萃分析(2项RCT)。
- 联合蛋白质与运动干预对比单独蛋白质,未发现骨矿物质含量的RCT;总骨密度或区域骨密度(2项RCT)结果不确定。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 联合蛋白质补充与运动对比单独运动,骨矿物质含量合并分析异质性I²=58.4%。
- 敏感性分析限制为牛奶蛋白补充联合运动,证据质量为低。
- 联合蛋白质与运动对比单独运动,骨密度仅2项RCT,无法进行荟萃分析。
- 联合蛋白质与运动干预对比单独蛋白质,总骨密度或区域骨密度仅2项RCT,结果不确定。
- 需要足够把握度、持续时间更长的研究来阐明这些问题。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Osteoporosis has become a global public health concern making prevention and treatment essential to reduce severe consequences for individuals and health systems. This systematic review with meta-analysis aimed to determine the effects of combined protein and exercise interventions compared to (a) exercise alone and (b) protein alone on bone mineral content (BMC) or density (BMD) in middle-aged and older adults. METHODS: We systematically searched Medline, CINAHL, CENTRAL, Web of Science, and SPORTDiscus until 24th January 2023. Pairwise random-effects meta-analyses were performed to calculate weighted mean differences (WMD) with 95% confidence intervals (95% CI). We evaluated risk of bias (Cochrane RoB2) and certainty of evidence (CoE; GRADE). If pooling was not possible, the results were summarized descriptively. RESULTS: For the comparison of combined protein supplementation and exercise vs. exercise alone, no meta-analysis for BMD (2 RCTs) was possible. For BMC, little to no intervention effect was found (WMD 0.03 kg; 95% CI - 0.00 to 0.05; 4 RCTs; IG = 97/CG = 98; I2 = 58.4%). In a sensitivity analysis, restricted to combined milk-protein supplementation and exercise, the result remained similar (0.01 kg; 95% CI - 0.01 to 0.03; 4 RCTs; IG = 71/CG = 71; I2 = 0.0%; low CoE). For the comparison of combined protein and exercise interventions vs. protein alone, no RCT on BMC was identified; the results on total or regional BMD (2 RCTs) were inconclusive. CONCLUSION: Based on our findings, no robust conclusions can be drawn on whether combining protein and exercise interventions is more beneficial for bone health than one component alone. Sufficiently powered studies with longer duration are required to clarify these questions (CRD42022334026).
引用
- Wolf JVE, Schoene D, Kohl M, et al. Effects of combined protein and exercise interventions on bone health in middle-aged and older adults - A systematic literature review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Osteoporos Int. 2025. PMID: 39915336. doi:10.1007/s00198-025-07393-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。