成功的内侧半月板修复可减轻前交叉韧带重建术后10年膝关节疼痛:在MOON队列中通过因果中介分析探讨后续手术的后果
该研究基于MOON队列2387例初次单侧前交叉韧带重建患者,采用因果中介分析评估内侧半月板修复对10年KOOS疼痛的影响及后续手术的中介效应。结果显示,成功的内侧半月板修复(无后续手术)使KOOS疼痛<80的可能性较内侧半月板切除降低7.1%(95%CI -13.3%至-1%;P=0.024),但后续手术的中介效应显著,使该可能性增加2.9%(95%CI 1.1%-5.3%;P<0.001),削弱了修复的整体贡献。
要点
- 成功的内侧半月板修复使10年KOOS疼痛<80的可能性较切除降低7.1%(95%CI -13.3%至-1%;P=0.024)。
- 内侧半月板修复后行后续手术使KOOS疼痛<80的可能性增加2.9%(95%CI 1.1%-5.3%;P<0.001)。
- 后续手术的中介效应显著,削弱了内侧半月板修复降低KOOS疼痛的整体贡献。
核心结论
- 初次前交叉韧带重建时成功的内侧半月板修复可减轻术后10年临床显著的膝关节疼痛。
- 后续手术的中介效应显著,削弱了内侧半月板修复降低KOOS疼痛<80可能性的整体贡献。
- 应继续努力降低初次前交叉韧带重建时内侧半月板修复后后续手术的可能性。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,证据等级2。
- 纳入2002年至2008年因单侧初次前交叉韧带重建入组多中心骨科预后网络且无内侧或外侧半月板手术史及对侧前交叉韧带重建史的患者。
- 采用R软件(版本4.2.3)进行因果中介分析,比较内侧半月板修复(纵向撕裂内侧至外侧长度>10 mm)与基线内侧半月板切除对10年随访时KOOS疼痛<80的影响。
- 构建有向无环图定性表示已知混杂因素的影响,缺失数据采用链式方程多元插补,所有检验为双侧,假设I类错误率为0.05。
- 最终分析纳入2387例参与者(女性1074例[45%];男性1313例[55%])。
主要发现
- 1502例(62.9%)无内侧半月板撕裂报告;885例有内侧半月板撕裂者中,109例(12.4%)未治疗,396例(44.7%)行半月板切除,380例(42.9%)行半月板修复。
- 2387例中1825例(76.5%)报告了10年随访时的KOOS疼痛:252例(13.8%)KOOS疼痛<80,1573例≥80。
- KOOS疼痛<80组中75例(29.8%)有后续手术;KOOS疼痛≥80组中223例(14.2%)有后续手术。
- 内侧半月板处理方式(未治疗、修复或切除)显著影响后续手术的可能性(χ2=28.9;P<0.001),后续手术显著增加KOOS疼痛<80的可能性(χ2=17.3;P<0.001)。
- 无后续手术的成功内侧半月板修复较内侧半月板切除使KOOS疼痛<80的可能性降低7.1%(95%CI -13.3%至-1%;P=0.024);内侧半月板修复和ACLR后行后续手术使KOOS疼痛<80的可能性增加2.9%(95%CI 1.1%-5.3%;P<0.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- KOOS疼痛<80定义为临床显著的膝关节疼痛。
- 内侧半月板修复适用于纵向撕裂内侧至外侧长度>10 mm者。
- 比较效应:成功内侧半月板修复(无后续手术)较内侧半月板切除使KOOS疼痛<80可能性降低7.1%(95%CI -13.3%至-1%;P=0.024)。
- 比较效应:内侧半月板修复和ACLR后行后续手术使KOOS疼痛<80可能性增加2.9%(95%CI 1.1%-5.3%;P<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Medial meniscal repair performed at the time of primary anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) has been shown to be significantly associated with subsequent surgery, and subsequent surgery has been associated with increased Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) pain score and decreased patient satisfaction. HYPOTHESIS/PURPOSE: The purpose was to determine if medial meniscal repair decreases KOOS pain 10 years after ACLR and to assess the consequences of subsequent surgery on the development of KOOS pain. The authors hypothesized that medial meniscal repair performed at the time of primary ACLR decreases the likelihood of developing KOOS pain. It was further hypothesized that surgery performed subsequent to medial meniscal repair and primary ACLR increases KOOS pain 10 years after ACLR. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 2. METHODS: Our inclusion criteria were all patients undergoing unilateral primary ACLR from 2002 to 2008 who were enrolled in the Multicenter Orthopaedic Outcomes Network without a history of medial or lateral meniscal surgery and contralateral ACLR. Causal mediation analysis using R software (Version 4.2.3) was employed to compare 2 effects on the development of significant knee pain, as represented by a KOOS pain score <80, at 10-year follow-up: (1) medial meniscal repair for longitudinal tears >10 mm in medial-to-lateral length and (2) medial meniscal excision at baseline of ACLR. A directed acyclic graph was constructed to provide a qualitative representation of the influence of known confounders that have been shown to affect the outcome of interest. Missing data were multiply imputed using multivariate imputation by chained equations. All tests were 2-sided, assuming a type I error rate of .05. RESULTS: In total, 2387 participants (1074 female [45%]; 1313 male [55%]) were included in the final analysis. In 1502 (62.9%) cases, there was no medial meniscal tear reported. Of the 885 cases with medial meniscal tears, no treatment was performed in 109 (12.4%), meniscal excision was performed in 396 (44.7%), and meniscal repair was performed in 380 (42.9%). An overall 1825 of 2387 (76.5%) patients reported KOOS pain at 10-year follow-up: 252 (13.8%) had KOOS pain <80 and 1573 had ≥80. In the KOOS pain <80 group, 75 (29.8%) had subsequent surgery. In the KOOS pain ≥80 group, 223 (14.2%) had subsequent surgery. The step-by-step approach to causal mediation analysis demonstrated that a medial meniscal procedure (ie, no treatment for the tear, repair, or excision) significantly affected the likelihood of subsequent surgery (χ2 = 28.9; P < .001) and subsequent surgery significantly increased the likelihood of KOOS pain <80 (χ2 = 17.3; P < .001). However, the direct effect of a successful medial meniscal repair without subsequent surgery decreased the likelihood of KOOS pain <80 by 7.1% when compared with medial meniscal excision (95% CI, -13.3% to -1%; P = .024). When subsequent surgery was performed after medial meniscal repair and ACLR, the likelihood of KOOS pain <80 increased by 2.9% (95% CI, 1.1%-5.3%; P < .001.)Conclusion:Successful medial meniscal repair performed at the time of primary ACLR decreased clinically significant knee pain 10 years postoperatively. However, the mediating effect of subsequent surgery was significant and diminished the overall contribution of medial meniscal repair in decreasing the likelihood of KOOS pain. Continued efforts should be made to decrease the likelihood of subsequent surgery after medial meniscal repair performed at the time of primary ACLR.
引用
- Sheean AJ, Jin Y, Amendola A, et al. Successful Medial Meniscal Repair Reduces Knee Pain 10 Years After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: Exploring the Consequences of Subsequent Surgery With Causal Mediation Analysis in the MOON Cohort. Am J Sports Med. 2025. PMID: 39939845. doi:10.1177/03635465251317742
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。