文献速递关节外科

你的手术头盔系统是否正在破坏无菌区域?全关节置换术中污染风险与预防措施的系统综述

Is Your Surgical Helmet System Compromising the Sterile Field? A Systematic Review of Contamination Risks and Preventive Measures in Total Joint Arthroplasty.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2025-02-05

该系统综述检索536篇文献后纳入21项研究,评估手术头盔系统在全关节置换术中对无菌区域污染、伤口污染及感染的影响。最佳证据提示头盔系统常携带微生物,不当穿戴可污染手术衣和手套,排气可能污染手术室空气,但头盔系统与伤口感染之间的直接关联尚不明确。作者建议待完全穿好手术衣后再启动头盔风扇,并将手术衣袖口胶带固定于内层手套、使用托加系统及对可重复使用头盔实施灭菌方案。

要点

  • 手术头盔系统常携带与手术部位感染和假体周围感染相关的微生物,不当穿戴可污染手术衣和手套。
  • 头盔排气可能是手术室空气污染来源,使用托加系统并密封手术衣-手套接口可减少空气污染物。
  • 头盔系统与伤口感染的直接关联尚不明确,一项回顾性分析显示与标准手术衣相比感染 odds 无差异。

核心结论

  • 最佳证据提示全关节置换术中使用手术头盔系统可能增加无菌区域污染的可能性,包括无菌手术衣、设备和手术室空气,但该发现主要来自实验研究,其效应量难以或无法转换为真实世界感染风险。
  • 本综述未发现证据直接表明手术头盔系统增加感染风险,但污染风险在很大程度上由穿戴技术和手术衣类型驱动,作者推荐待完全穿好手术衣后再启动头盔风扇、将手术衣袖口胶带固定于内层手套、使用托加系统设置并对可重复使用头盔实施灭菌方案。
  • 适当使用时,尚无充分高质量证据表明手术头盔系统对患者安全构成有意义的危害,但持续缺乏证明其达到降低感染初始目的有效性的证据,值得仔细评估其在全关节置换术中的效用。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索 PubMed、Medline、EBSCOhost 和 Google Scholar 于2024年7月31日进行,纳入从建库至2024年7月发表的评估全关节置换术中手术头盔系统对无菌区域污染、伤口污染和感染影响的研究。
  • 纳入标准为评估手术头盔系统灭菌、穿戴或术中(包括模拟全关节置换术)使用与污染或感染关联的研究;排除病例报告、病例系列、综述、评论、社论、重复研究、灰色文献、非全关节置换术研究及无法获得英文全文的研究。
  • 筛选536篇文章后纳入21项研究;评估手术头盔系统和同时使用个人防护装备无菌性的13项研究包括126次穿戴模拟、445次模拟全关节置换术和191例接受全关节置换术的患者。
  • 评估手术室空气污染的7项研究包括38次穿戴模拟、82次模拟全关节置换术和96例接受全关节置换术的患者;直接评估伤口污染或感染的3项研究包括83888例接受全关节置换术的患者。
  • 采用非随机研究方法学指数(MINORS)工具评估偏倚风险,比较性研究平均±标准差评分为20±1.4(满分24),非比较性研究为14±0.8(满分16),表明研究质量良好;研究间异质性妨碍了Meta分析,故进行定性综合。

主要发现

  • 最佳证据提示手术头盔系统常携带已知为手术部位感染和假体周围感染常见原因的微生物,其不当穿戴和使用(例如在完全穿好手术衣前启动排气扇)可导致手术人员所穿手术衣和无菌手套污染。
  • 多项研究提示手术头盔系统的排气是手术室空气污染的潜在来源,但基于空气采样位置以及是否使用托加系统和手术衣-手套接口是否密封(两者均被证明可减轻空气污染物),研究结果不一致。
  • 一项回顾性比较分析显示,在全关节置换术中比较使用手术头盔系统与标准手术衣时,感染 odds 无差异;另一项报告使用手术头盔系统时12个月随访深部感染翻修 odds 降低(调整 OR 0.55)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 一项回顾性比较分析显示,全关节置换术中手术头盔系统与标准手术衣相比感染 odds 无差异。
  • 另一项报告显示,使用手术头盔系统时12个月随访深部感染翻修 odds 降低(调整 OR 0.55)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者推荐待完全穿好手术衣后再启动手术头盔系统风扇。
  • 作者推荐将手术衣袖口胶带固定于内层手套。
  • 作者推荐使用托加系统设置。
  • 作者推荐对可重复使用头盔实施灭菌方案。
  • 适当使用时,尚无充分高质量证据表明手术头盔系统对患者安全构成有意义的危害;但持续缺乏证明其降低感染有效性的证据,值得仔细评估其效用,并充分考虑其作为手术人员个人防护系统的作用。

局限性

  • 证据质量受限于纳入的实验性研究设计,这些研究未直接测量感染;但纳入此类研究是必要的,因为前瞻性直接评估手术头盔系统与感染关联所需的研究人群规模不可行。
  • 研究间异质性妨碍了Meta分析,故进行了定性综合。
  • 手术头盔系统使用与伤口感染之间是否存在直接关联研究不足且不明确。
  • 本综述未发现证据直接表明手术头盔系统增加感染风险。
  • 需要不可行的大规模研究人群才能开展足够把握度的临床试验来稳健研究手术头盔系统与感染的关联。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Surgical helmet systems remain widely used in total joint arthroplasty (TJA) despite evidence to suggest that they may increase infection risk via contamination of sterile equipment and operating room air. However, the challenging nature of conducting high-quality clinical trials to study outcomes with low incidence, such as prosthetic joint infection (PJI), has made drawing definitive conclusions from the available experimental studies difficult. Therefore, a comprehensive analysis of the best available evidence is needed to clarify the association between surgical helmet system use and contamination and infection risk and to provide clinical recommendations for use in TJA. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: This systematic review aimed to address the following questions: (1) What is the level of sterility of surgical helmet systems and concomitantly used personal protective equipment (PPE)? (2) Is there an association between surgical helmet systems and air contamination within the operating room? (3) Does the use of a surgical helmet system affect wound contamination and/or infection? METHODS: PubMed, Medline, EBSCOhost, and Google Scholar were queried on July 31, 2024, to identify studies published from inception to July 2024 that have evaluated the impact of surgical helmet system use in TJA on sterile field contamination (operating room air, PPE, sterile equipment), wound contamination and infection, or practices that may impact related outcomes. Inclusion criteria were that the study evaluate the sterility, donning, or intraoperative use (including mock TJA) of a surgical helmet system in association with contamination or infection. The following articles were excluded: case reports, case series, reviews, commentaries, editorials, duplicate studies among databases, gray literature, studies specific to a procedure other than TJA, and studies unavailable as a full-text English manuscript. After screening 536 articles, 21 were included. The 13 studies that evaluated the sterility of surgical helmet systems and concomitantly used PPE comprised 126 gowning simulations, 445 mock TJA procedures, and 191 patients who had undergone TJA. The seven studies that evaluated contamination of operating room air comprised 38 gowning simulations, 82 mock TJA procedures, and 96 patients who had undergone TJA. Three studies directly evaluated wound contamination or infection, comprising 83,888 patients who had undergone TJA. Risk of bias was determined via the Methodological Index for Nonrandomized Studies (MINORS) tool, with a mean ± SD score of 20 ± 1.4 (of 24) for comparative studies and 14 ± 0.8 (of 16) for noncomparative studies, indicating good study quality. Notably, the quality of evidence was limited by the inclusion of experimental study designs that did not directly measure infection; however, the inclusion of such studies is necessitated by the infeasibly large study population required to directly evaluate the association between surgical helmet systems and infection prospectively. Heterogeneity among studies precluded meta-analysis, and a qualitative synthesis was instead conducted. RESULTS: The best available evidence suggests that surgical helmet systems frequently harbor microbes known to be common causes of SSI and PJI, and that their improper donning and use (for example, activation of the exhaust fan before fully gowned) can lead to the contamination of gowns and sterile gloves worn by surgical personnel. Furthermore, several studies suggest that the exhaust from surgical helmet systems presents a potential source of operating room air contamination, although there were mixed findings based on the location of air sampling and whether or not a toga was used and the gown-glove interface was sealed (both of which were shown to mitigate airborne contaminants). However, whether there is a direct association between surgical helmet system use and wound infection remains understudied and unclear, with one retrospective comparative analysis demonstrating no difference in odds of infection when comparing surgical helmet systems used to a standard gown during TJA, and another reporting reduced odds of revision for deep infection with a 12-month follow-up time when a surgical helmet system was used (adjusted OR 0.55). CONCLUSION: Although the best available evidence suggests that the use of surgical helmet systems in TJA can increase the likelihood of sterile field contamination, including sterile surgical attire and equipment, as well as operating room air, that finding derives largely from experimental studies with effect sizes (based on endpoints like colony counts) that are difficult or impossible to convert to real-world infection risk. Robust investigations into the association between surgical helmet systems and infection are limited by the need for infeasibly large study populations to conduct sufficiently powered clinical trials, with no evidence found by this review to directly implicate surgical helmet systems in increased infection risk. Still, because the risk for contamination has been shown to be driven substantially by donning technique and the type of gown used, we recommend waiting to activate the surgical helmet system fan until fully gowned, taping the gown cuff at the inner glove, utilizing a toga system set up, and implementing sterilization protocols for reusable helmets. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: When used appropriately, there is insufficient high-quality evidence to suggest that surgical helmet systems pose meaningful harm to patient safety. However, the persistent lack of evidence to demonstrate their effectiveness in achieving the initial purpose of reducing infection warrants careful evaluation of their utility in TJA. Ample consideration must be given to their role as personal protection systems for surgical personnel, as studies have demonstrated superior protection from surgical debris and splatter compared with conventional surgical attire. While the added cost of surgical helmet systems may therefore be justified, surgeons wishing to continue utilizing surgical helmet systems in their practice should do so while taking proper precautionary measures to mitigate contamination risks.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Porto JR, Lavu MS, Hecht CJ, et al. Is Your Surgical Helmet System Compromising the Sterile Field? A Systematic Review of Contamination Risks and Preventive Measures in Total Joint Arthroplasty. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 39915114. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003383

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。