文献速递脊柱外科小儿骨科

患者如何感知青少年特发性脊柱侧凸椎体拴系术与融合术后的成功与满意度?一项定性研究

How Do Patients Perceive Success and Satisfaction After Vertebral Body Tethering and Fusion for Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis? A Qualitative Study.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2025-02-04

该定性研究通过半结构化访谈,探讨接受前路椎体拴系术(VBT)或后路脊柱融合术(PSF)的青少年特发性脊柱侧凸(AIS)患者术后至少3年对治疗成功与满意度的感知。患者将成功定义为疼痛缓解、维持身体功能、改善外观、确保长期畸形矫正及减轻对未来健康风险的担忧,两组虽仍有疼痛、副作用和身体限制,但总体对症状缓解、身体功能和外观改善表示满意。

要点

  • 患者对治疗成功的定义涵盖疼痛缓解、身体功能、外观、长期矫正及减轻未来健康担忧。
  • 患者优先事项各异,部分重视灵活性以游泳或演奏乐器,部分重视无痛生活或外观改善。
  • 两组患者尽管仍有疼痛、副作用和身体限制,但总体对症状缓解、身体功能和外观改善满意。

核心结论

  • 这些发现可作为术前咨询的指导,并强调将患者视角纳入AIS术前咨询的重要性,需就疼痛缓解、身体功能、长期稳定性和情绪健康设定现实期望。
  • 尽管患者常报告疼痛减轻、活动能力和外观方面的积极结果,咨询应涉及可能的残余不适、身体限制和身体意象担忧以提高满意度。
  • 未来研究应优先开发细致的、以患者为中心的结果测量,捕捉详细疼痛特征、功能能力和外观相关担忧等具体优先事项。
  • 比较有效性研究应探索细致结果,为共享决策提供证据,并指导患者和临床医生根据个体目标在VBT和PSF之间选择。
  • 此外,检查术前关于权衡和长期结果的讨论如何塑造患者期望和满意度,可改善手术实践与患者优先事项之间的对齐。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用受现象学概念启发的方法捕捉患者生活体验,使用访谈指南进行半结构化访谈。
  • 纳入标准要求患者:(1)手术时为进展性AIS伴中度畸形(< 60°);(2)接受VBT或PSF且随访至少3年;(3)达到完全骨骼成熟。
  • 排除无法沟通或安排访谈的患者。
  • 从96例合格患者(VBT n = 47,PSF n = 49)中招募40例(每组20例),样本量参考该领域定性研究并以达到饱和为目标。
  • 参与者均在同一中西部城市医院由同一位医生治疗;VBT组中位年龄18岁(范围16至22),85%为女性;PSF组中位年龄21岁(范围18至27),70%为女性。

主要发现

  • 两组患者均将成功定义为实现疼痛缓解、维持身体功能、改善外观、确保长期畸形矫正及减轻对未来健康风险的担忧。
  • 患者优先事项各异:部分优先考虑灵活性以参加竞技游泳或演奏乐器,另一些优先考虑无痛生活或改善外观。
  • 总体而言,两组均对症状缓解、身体功能和外观改善表示满意,尽管仍有持续疼痛、副作用和身体限制。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为这些发现可作为术前咨询的指导,并强调将患者视角纳入AIS术前咨询的重要性,需就疼痛缓解、身体功能、长期稳定性和情绪健康设定现实期望。
  • 作者认为咨询应涉及可能的残余不适、身体限制和身体意象担忧以提高满意度。
  • 作者建议未来研究应优先开发细致的、以患者为中心的结果测量,捕捉详细疼痛特征、功能能力和外观相关担忧等具体优先事项。
  • 作者建议比较有效性研究应探索细致结果,为共享决策提供证据,并指导患者和临床医生根据个体目标在VBT和PSF之间选择。
  • 作者建议检查术前关于权衡和长期结果的讨论如何塑造患者期望和满意度,以改善手术实践与患者优先事项之间的对齐。

局限性

  • participants were treated at a single urban Midwest hospital by the same physician.

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) is the most common spinal deformity among children. Although posterior spinal fusion (PSF) is a commonly used treatment for curves ≥ 45°, anterior vertebral body tethering (VBT) has recently gained traction as an alternative for some patients. Surgeons have established radiographic definitions of success for PSF, with similar efforts underway for VBT. However, these definitions may not align with patient perceptions of success or their satisfaction with achieved outcomes. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: To enhance patient-centered care and inform subsequent comparative effectiveness research, we asked: (1) How do patients who have undergone VBT or PSF define and perceive treatment success ≥ 3 years after surgery? (2) What are patients' perceptions of their outcomes, specifically regarding satisfaction with symptom relief, side effects, physical function, and physical appearance? METHODS: Using an approach informed by concepts from phenomenology to capture patients' lived experiences, we conducted semistructured interviews using an interview guide. Inclusion criteria required patients to have (1) progressive AIS with moderate deformity (< 60°) at surgery, (2) undergone VBT or PSF with at least 3 years of follow-up, and (3) reached full skeletal maturity. Patients unable to communicate or schedule interviews were excluded. From 96 eligible patients (VBT n = 47, PSF n = 49), we recruited 40 (20 per cohort). The sample size was guided by qualitative studies in the field and aimed to achieve saturation, defined as the point at which minimal new information and no new coding categories were identified. Participants were treated at a single urban Midwest hospital by the same physician. The VBT cohort (median age 18 years [range 16 to 22]) was 85% women/girls, while the PSF cohort (median age 21 years [range 18 to 27]) was 70% women. Interviews were analyzed using a collaborative content analysis approach in which two researchers independently identified key ideas, assigned codes, and resolved discrepancies through consensus to develop themes and subthemes aligned with the research questions. RESULTS: Patients from both cohorts defined success as achieving pain relief, maintaining physical function, improving appearance, ensuring long-term deformity correction, and alleviating concerns about future health risks. Patient priorities varied; some prioritized flexibility to swim competitively or play musical instruments, while others prioritized pain-free living or improved physical appearance. Overall, both groups expressed satisfaction with symptom relief, physical function, and appearance improvements despite ongoing pain, side effects, and physical limitations. CONCLUSION: These findings may be used as a guide for preoperative counseling and highlight the importance of incorporating patient perspectives into preoperative counseling for AIS, emphasizing the need to set realistic expectations regarding pain relief, physical function, long-term stability, and emotional well-being. While patients frequently reported positive outcomes in pain reduction, mobility, and appearance, counseling should address potential residual discomfort, physical limitations, and body image concerns to improve satisfaction. Future research should prioritize developing nuanced, patient-centered outcome measures that capture specific priorities such as detailed pain characteristics, functional abilities, and appearance-related concerns. Comparative effectiveness studies should explore granular outcomes to provide evidence that supports shared decision-making and guides patients and clinicians in choosing between VBT and PSF based on individual goals. Additionally, examining how presurgery discussions about tradeoffs and long-term outcomes shape patient expectations and satisfaction can improve alignment between surgical practices and patient priorities. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Royse LA, Saparova D, Boeyer ME, et al. How Do Patients Perceive Success and Satisfaction After Vertebral Body Tethering and Fusion for Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis? A Qualitative Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 39914997. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003373

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。