接受肩部手术的患者心理韧性会发生变化吗?一项利用简易韧性量表进行的回顾性对比研究
该单术者回顾性对比研究纳入2021年3月至2023年3月在一所美国军队教学医院接受肩部手术的患者,最终分析121例。按术前简易韧性量表评分分为低、中、高韧性组,随访至少6个月。结果显示韧性分组整体稳定,但个体层面46%患者术后韧性变化≥1个标准差;高韧性组术后疼痛评分可能更低,韧性变化与性别、年龄、手术类别无关。
要点
- 低韧性组末次随访时简易韧性量表评分较术前升高(18±3 vs 20±4;p<0.05)。
- 所有韧性组术后NRS疼痛评分降低、SANE评分改善。
- 高韧性组在1-2个月随访时NRS低于中韧性组(1.8±1.0 vs 3.8±2.3;p=0.003)。
核心结论
- 按韧性分组评估时该特质表现稳定,但个体层面韧性表现动态且复杂。
- 高韧性患者术后疼痛可能更轻。
- 识别低韧性患者可能提示该心理测量属性变化更明显的人群。
研究设计与样本
- 单术者回顾性对比研究,从一所美国军队教学医院病历中识别2021年3月至2023年3月接受肩部手术的患者144例。
- 排除年龄<18岁(1%,1/144)、因骨折/急性肌腱断裂(8%,11/144)或翻修手术(3%,4/144)、合并肩部疾病(如不稳定或肩袖撕裂)(1%,2/144)、随访数据不完整(4%,5/144)者,最终分析121例(84%,121/144)。
- 患者中女性12%(15/121),平均年龄41±15岁,最常见手术指征为肩关节不稳定(40%,48/121),其次为肩袖修复(29%,35/121)。
- 根据术前简易韧性量表评分与均值的偏差分为低韧性(低于均值>1个标准差)、中韧性(均值±1个标准差内)和高韧性(高于均值>1个标准差)组;术前低韧性19%(23/121)、中韧性62%(75/121)、高韧性19%(23/121)。
- 术后随访至少6个月,韧性不稳定定义为任意两个随访时间点之间简易韧性量表评分变化>1个标准差。
主要发现
- 除低韧性组外,各时间点简易韧性量表分组保持一致,无分组改变或交叉。
- 低韧性组末次随访时简易韧性量表平均评分较术前升高(18±3 vs 20±4;p<0.05)。
- 无论韧性分组,术后NRS平均评分降低(4.4±2.2 vs 2.4±2.3;p<0.001),SANE平均评分改善(46±19 vs 69±21;p<0.001)。
- 在1-2个月随访时,高韧性组患者NRS评分低于中韧性组(1.8±1.0 vs 3.8±2.3;p=0.003);在6-10个月随访时,高韧性组患者NRS评分低于低韧性组(1.5±1.8 vs 3.3±2.4;p<0.001)。
- 韧性分组与SANE评分、手术类别及达到NRS或SANE最小临床重要差异(MCID)的患者百分比之间未观察到关系。
关键数值与推荐
- 简易韧性量表为六条目量表,计算总分范围6至30分,评分越高提示感知韧性越强。
- 术前简易韧性量表平均评分为25±4。
- 韧性不稳定定义为任意两个随访时间点之间简易韧性量表评分变化>1个标准差。
- 证据等级为III级,治疗性研究。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Resilience refers to the ability to adapt or recover from stress. There is increasing appreciation that it plays an important role in wholistic patient-centered care and may affect patient outcomes, including those of orthopaedic surgery. Despite being a focus of the current orthopaedic evidence, there is no strong understanding yet of whether resilience is a stable patient quality or a dynamic one that may be modified perioperatively to improve patient-reported outcome scores. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Does resilience change postoperatively? (2) How do outcome measures change postoperatively in relation to resilience grouping? (3) For patients who do have resilience instability (change in resilience of ≥ 1 SD between any two follow-up points), how were patient-level factors, surgical characteristics, and outcome measures associated with instability? METHODS: In this single-surgeon, retrospective, comparative study, we identified all patients who underwent shoulder surgery between March 2021 and March 2023 from the medical records of one US military teaching hospital, resulting in 144 initial patients. Data on resilience (measured by the Brief Resilience Scale) and outcomes (assessed using the Numeric Rating Scale [NRS] and the Single Assessment Numeric Evaluation [SANE]) were collected for all patients and maintained in a longitudinal outcomes score database. Patients younger than 18 years of age (1% [1 of 144]) who underwent surgery for fracture, acute tendon rupture (8% [11 of 144]), or revision surgery (3% [4 of 144]); had concomitant shoulder conditions (such as, instability or rotator cuff tear) (1% [2 of 144]); or had incomplete follow-up data (4% [5 of 144]) were excluded, leaving 84% (121 of 144) of the original sample size for analysis. Among the patients, 12% (15 of 121) were women, the mean age was 41 ± 15 years, and the most common indication for surgery was instability (40% [48 of 121]) followed by rotator cuff repair (29% [35 of 121]). Based on their preoperative Brief Resilience Scale and its deviation from the mean, patients were stratified into low (> 1 SD below mean), intermediate (within 1 SD above and below mean), and high (> 1 SD above mean) resilience groups. Preoperatively, 19% (23 of 121) of patients were classified as low resilience, 62% (75 of 121) as intermediate resilience, and 19% (23 of 121) as high resilience. The mean ± SD preoperative Brief Resilience Scale score was 25 ± 4. The Brief Resilience Scale is a six-item scale with a calculated summary score ranging from 6 to 30. A higher score is suggestive of greater perceived resilience. There were no differences in the preoperative Brief Resilience Scale score with regard to age, gender, type of surgery performed, or outcome measures. Patient resilience was followed during the postoperative period for a minimum of 6 months, and instability in the scale was evaluated. Instability in resilience was defined as change in Brief Resilience Scale score by > 1 SD from one follow-up time point to another. Perioperative NRS and SANE outcomes, in addition to demographic data, were utilized to evaluate the relationship between resilience and patient-level factors. RESULTS: Brief Resilience Scale groups across all time points remained consistent with no change in grouping or crossover in groups except for patients with low resilience who had an increase in mean ± SD Brief Resilience Scale score by the final follow-up (18 ± 3 versus 20 ± 4; p < 0.05). Regardless of resilience group, there was a decrease in mean ± SD NRS (4.4 ± 2.2 versus 2.4 ± 2.3; p < 0.001) and an improvement in mean ± SD SANE (46 ± 19 versus 69 ± 21; p < 0.001) scores during the postoperative period. At the 1- to 2-month follow-up and the 6- to 10-month follow-up visits, patients with high resilience were more likely to have lower NRS scores than patients with intermediate resilience (1.8 ± 1.0 versus 3.8 ± 2.3; p = 0.003) and low resilience (1.5 ± 1.8 versus 3.3 ± 2.4; p < 0.001), respectively. No relationship was observed between resilience groups and SANE scores, surgical category, and percentage of patients meeting the minimum clinically important difference (MCID) of the NRS or the SANE. Regarding resilience instability, 46% (56 of 121) of patients were categorized as having a Brief Resilience Scale change of ≥ 1 SD from baseline during the postoperative period. Gender (r = 0.03; p = 0.21), age (p = 0.81), and surgical category (r = 0.01; p = 0.88) were not associated with the likelihood of resilience instability. Individuals whose resilience increased had a lower starting Brief Resilience Scale score than those whose resilience stayed the same (22 ± 4 versus 25 ± 4, respectively; p < 0.001) or those whose resilience decreased (22 ± 4 versus 26 ± 3, respectively; p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: When evaluated by resilience group, the trait appears static; however, at the individual level, resilience appears dynamic and complex. Patients with high resilience may have less postoperative pain. Identification of patients with low resilience may indicate patients who experience more dynamic change in this psychometric property. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Song DJ, McDermott ER, Homeier D, et al. Does Resilience Change in Patients Undergoing Shoulder Surgery? A Retrospective Comparative Study Utilizing the Brief Resilience Scale. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 39842009. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003368
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。